Who decides Bitcoin's rules? Nobody signs off, and the block size war proved it
No person, company or committee decides Bitcoin's rules. Changes are written up as public proposals, turned into software, and become rules only if the people running nodes choose to run them. The block size war of 2015 to 2017 showed that even a deal signed by big companies can't force a change.
Somebody pins a proposal to the village notice board: bigger pages for the notebook, so more lines fit on each. The scribes who write the copying instructions argue about it for months. The biggest traders and copyists meet in the city and sign a paper: bigger pages, by autumn.
Grandma Rosa reads the paper and asks the obvious question. "Who said they could decide that?"
Nobody, it turns out. The houses keep copying the notebook the way they always have, and the signed paper ends up as kindling. That's the short answer to who decides Bitcoin's rules: whoever runs the notebook in their own house, one house at a time.
What it is
Bitcoin has no board, no owner and no vote. Its rules are whatever the software on thousands of nodes enforces, and each node operator chooses which software to run.
The document that describes how changes are proposed says it plainly: "No formal or informal decision body governs Bitcoin development or decides adoption of BIPs" (BIP 3). "Who controls crypto?" lists the six groups with influence and walks through the Taproot upgrade. This article follows the paperwork, and a fight.
How it works: the paper trail
A rule change travels through three stages. None of them is a vote.
- The proposal. Changes are written up as Bitcoin Improvement Proposals, or BIPs. From 2016, the process was set by BIP 2. BIP 3, assigned its number in January 2025, replaced it. A BIP "represents a personal recommendation by the BIP authors", and the editors who assign numbers "do NOT evaluate whether the proposal is likely to be adopted" (BIP 3). A number is a filing stamp, not a blessing.
- The software. Someone has to write the change into code. Bitcoin Core, the most widely used program, aims "to make a major release every 6 months" and maintains the three most recent major versions. Version 32 came out on 27 October 2026 (Bitcoin Core). Other programs exist, and nothing obliges anyone to use Core.
- The adoption. Nobody's computer updates itself. Under BIP 3, a proposal reaches the status "Deployed" only with "evidence that the BIP is in active use" (BIP 3). The status follows reality. It doesn't create it.
The block size war, step by step
Bitcoin blocks were limited to 1,000,000 bytes. From 2015, a long argument raged about raising that. It's the clearest test of who decides.
- 22 June 2015: a proposal. Gavin Andresen's BIP 101 proposed "replacing the fixed one megabyte maximum block size" with 8,000,000 bytes from 11 January 2016, doubling every two years. It needed 750 of 1,000 consecutive blocks to signal support (BIP 101). It never got there. Its status is Closed.
- 2016: the rulebook spells it out. BIP 2 set a high bar for changes that old software rejects: "A hard-fork BIP requires adoption from the entire Bitcoin economy" (BIP 2).
- 23 May 2017: a deal. A group of bitcoin companies published the "Bitcoin Scaling Agreement at Consensus 2017", known as the New York Agreement (Digital Currency Group). Two promises: "Activate Segregated Witness at an 80% threshold, signaling at bit 4" and "Activate a 2 MB hard fork within six months" (via bitcoin-dev mailing list).
- August 2017: one half happens, another chain leaves. Segwit took effect on Bitcoin. Separately, some of those who wanted bigger blocks at once split off as Bitcoin Cash. "What is a fork?" has both, block by block, and "Who controls crypto?" covers BIP 148, the node operators' threat that pushed segwit along.
- 8 November 2017: the other half dies. The organisers of the 2 MB part, known as Segwit2x, wrote: "we have not built sufficient consensus for a clean blocksize upgrade at this time." And: "Until then, we are suspending our plans for the upcoming 2MB upgrade" (Belshe and others, 2017).
Companies signed a deal with a deadline on it. The part that node operators were willing to run happened. The part they weren't willing to run didn't.
Why it matters
- Your coins can't be changed by a press release. A rule change needs the people running nodes to install it, one by one.
- Change is slow and loud. Every proposal is public, argued over for months or years, and often fails. That's the price of having no boss.
- Disagreement has an exit. Those who wanted bigger blocks didn't win the argument. They left with their own chain. That's freedom, and also how one village becomes two.
Where people get it wrong
- "Bitcoin Core decides." Core's developers write and release code. Node operators decide whether to run it.
- "A BIP number means it's approved." It means it's filed. BIP 3 says individual BIPs don't represent community consensus.
- "Miners decide." Miners write the blocks. Nodes decide which blocks are valid, and a block that breaks their rules is thrown out.
- "Big companies decide." They signed a deal in 2017 with a six-month deadline. See above.
- "Nobody decides, so nothing can change." Bitcoin has changed its rules several times. Slowly, and only with wide agreement.
The sting: read the status, not the hype
When someone says "Bitcoin is about to change", look the proposal up in the public BIP repository. Check its status. Draft means someone wrote it down. Deployed means it's in use. Everything in between is an argument.
The stranger at the gate will tell you an upgrade is "confirmed" and you need his new wallet to get ready. Ask him for the BIP number. Then ask the houses.
Frequently asked questions
Who decides Bitcoin's rules?
No single person or body. Developers propose changes, but a change becomes a rule only when enough people running nodes choose software that enforces it. BIP 3 states that no formal or informal decision body governs Bitcoin development.
What is a BIP?
A Bitcoin Improvement Proposal is a public document describing a suggested change or standard for Bitcoin. Under BIP 3, it represents the personal recommendation of its authors. Getting a number from the BIP editors doesn't mean the change is approved or adopted.
What was the Bitcoin block size war?
A dispute from about 2015 to 2017 over whether to raise Bitcoin's 1,000,000-byte block size limit. It included BIP 101 in 2015, the New York Agreement of May 2017, the Bitcoin Cash split in August 2017 and the suspension of the Segwit2x 2 MB plan on 8 November 2017.
What was the New York Agreement?
A deal published on 23 May 2017 by a group of bitcoin companies. It promised to activate segwit and then a 2 MB hard fork within six months. Segwit was activated, but the 2 MB part was called off in November 2017 for lack of consensus.
How often is Bitcoin Core released?
Bitcoin Core aims for a major release about every six months and maintains the three most recent major versions. Version 32 was released on 27 October 2026. Node operators decide for themselves whether and when to upgrade.
Sources
- Murch, BIP 3: Updated BIP Process
- Luke Dashjr, BIP 2: BIP process, revised
- Bitcoin Core, Software life cycle
- Gavin Andresen, BIP 101: Increase maximum block size
- Digital Currency Group, Bitcoin Scaling Agreement at Consensus 2017 (23 May 2017)
- bitcoin-dev mailing list, Barry Silbert segwit agreement (26 May 2017), quoting the agreement's terms
- Mike Belshe and others, Segwit2x Final Steps, bitcoin-segwit2x mailing list (8 November 2017)

