Level 1 · Start hereThe village#068

Why bitcoin is called "digital gold": half a good comparison, half a sales slogan

Bitcoin is called digital gold because its supply is limited and no government or company issues it. The comparison breaks down on price swings, on everyday uses and on history: gold has thousands of years behind it, bitcoin dates from 2009.

Ben has a plan to get rich: he'll make more of whatever the village saves in. When the village saved in shells, he went to the beach. When it saved in notes from the keeper, he made friends with the keeper.

Then the village starts saving in a notebook where new coins appear only on a fixed timetable, written into the rules every house checks. Ben can't dig, print or befriend his way to more. Good luck, Ben.

That's why people call bitcoin "digital gold": like gold, nobody can simply make more of it. It's a fair comparison on that one point. On several others, it falls apart.

What it is

"Digital gold" is a nickname, not a technical term. It says bitcoin is meant to work like gold as a store of value: something you keep, rather than something you spend.

The idea is as old as Bitcoin. The white paper itself compares new coins to mining: "The steady addition of a constant of amount of new coins is analogous to gold miners expending resources to add gold to circulation" (Nakamoto, 2008). The odd wording is in the original.

How it works: test the comparison point by point

In August 2010, Satoshi Nakamoto ran a thought experiment on the Bitcoin forum. Imagine "a base metal as scarce as gold" but grey, useless for anything practical, with one "magical property": it "can be transported over a communications channel" (Bitcointalk, 2010). That's the whole pitch in one post. Now test it.

Where the comparison holds:

  1. Limited supply. Gold is limited by geology. Bitcoin is limited by a rule: just under 21 million coins, released on a schedule that halves every four years or so. Our article on digital scarcity does the sum.
  2. No issuer. No central bank can decide to make more of either. With euros or dollars, the central bank sets the policy. With gold and bitcoin, nobody does.
  3. Nobody's promise. A bank deposit is a claim on a bank. A gold bar or a bitcoin, held yourself, is a claim on nobody. If you hold the key, there's no keeper who can fail.

Where it fails:

  1. Price swings. The ECB blog notes that bitcoin "peaked at USD 69,000 in November 2021 before falling to USD 17,000 by mid-June 2022" (Bindseil and Schaaf, 2022). That's a fall of about three quarters in seven months. Gold moves too, as our crypto vs gold article shows, but a store of value that can lose three quarters in seven months is a strange kind of safe.
  2. No other use. Gold has buyers who never think of it as savings: jewellers and industry. Our crypto vs gold article has the World Gold Council's figures. Bitcoin has no use outside its own network. Its price rests entirely on what the next holder believes.
  3. Short history. Gold has been money for thousands of years. Bitcoin's first block was mined in January 2009. Gold has been through wars, plagues and empires. Bitcoin has been through a few market cycles.

Score: two strong points and one good one for, three serious points against. Fair enough for a nickname. Not enough for a promise.

Two named views

The nickname has fans and critics, and both write it down.

For. BlackRock, which sells a bitcoin fund, described bitcoin in a September 2024 paper as "a global, decentralized, fixed-supply, non-sovereign asset" (BlackRock, 2024). The same paper concedes: "Bitcoin, with its high volatility, is obviously a 'risky' asset on a standalone basis."

Against. Two senior ECB staff, writing on the ECB blog in their own names, argued that bitcoin "cannot be used productively (like commodities) or provide social benefits (like gold)", and that its market valuation "is therefore based purely on speculation" (Bindseil and Schaaf, 2022). The blog notes that these views are not necessarily the ECB's.

Notice who says what. The firm selling the fund lists the strengths, and still warns about volatility. Two staff of the central bank whose money bitcoin competes with list the weaknesses. Read both. Trust neither blindly.

Why it matters

  • It shapes what people buy. "Gold" sounds safe. People who hear "digital gold" may expect gold's calm and get bitcoin's swings.
  • It shapes how long people hold. If you think of it as gold, you plan in decades. That only works if you can sit through falls of three quarters.
  • It sells other coins. Every second token claims to be "the new digital gold". Most have neither Bitcoin's supply rule nor gold's history.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Digital gold means it's a safe haven." Even BlackRock, in its own bitcoin paper, calls it "risky" on a standalone basis.
  • "Bitcoin has no value because it has no use." It has no industrial use. Whether it has value depends on whether people keep wanting to hold it, which is true of much money.
  • "Gold is boring and bitcoin is better." Different tools. Gold needs no electricity or password. Bitcoin can cross a border in minutes.
  • "Any coin with a cap is digital gold." A cap is a start. Who can change it, and who still wants the coin in twenty years, matters more.

The two-question check

Before you think of anything as "gold", ask two questions. Could I sit through a fall of three quarters without selling? And would I still want this if nobody else talked about it for a year?

If both answers are yes, the nickname might fit your plan. If not, it's just a slogan. And slogans, unlike gold, are free to print.

Frequently asked questions

Why is bitcoin called digital gold?

Because, like gold, its supply is limited and no government or company can create more of it at will. Bitcoin's supply follows a fixed schedule in its software, capped at just under 21 million coins.

Is bitcoin as safe as gold?

No. Bitcoin's price swings much more than gold's. According to the ECB blog, bitcoin fell from about $69,000 in November 2021 to about $17,000 by mid-June 2022. Gold also has buyers in jewellery and industry, which bitcoin doesn't.

Who first compared bitcoin to gold?

The comparison goes back to Satoshi Nakamoto. The 2008 white paper compares new coins to gold miners adding gold to circulation, and in August 2010 Satoshi described a thought experiment about a metal as scarce as gold that could be sent over a communications channel.

Does bitcoin have any use besides holding it?

It can be sent as payment across borders without a bank. It has no industrial or decorative use like gold, so its price depends on people continuing to want to hold and use it.

Is digital gold a good investment?

We don't give investment advice. What we can say is that bitcoin has fallen by about three quarters within months in the past, and anything called gold should be judged on that record, not on the name.

Sources

  1. Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A peer-to-peer electronic cash system (2008), section 6
  2. Bitcointalk, Re: Bitcoin does NOT violate Mises' Regression Theorem (Satoshi Nakamoto, 27 August 2010)
  3. Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, archive of the same post
  4. BlackRock, Bitcoin: a unique diversifier (September 2024)
  5. The Block, BlackRock's new bitcoin paper outlines the cryptocurrency's qualities as 'unique' hedge against global risks (18 September 2024)
  6. Ulrich Bindseil and Jürgen Schaaf, The ECB Blog: Bitcoin's last stand (30 November 2022)

Read next.