Level 1 · Start hereThe village#053

Blockchain without crypto: does it make sense? Sometimes, and the test is trust

Companies and public bodies have tried to use blockchains for shares, shipping and food, without any coin. Some projects run; some big ones were stopped. A shared ledger helps when several parties need one record and don't want any one of them to own it.

The town council has watched the village notebook for years. It doesn't care about the coins. It likes the idea: one record, a copy in every house, nobody can tear out a page. Why not keep the land register that way? Or the list of who owns which share in the mill?

The council hires builders, buys new shelves, and promises a revolution. Some of the shelves end up holding something useful. Some are taken down years later, quietly, with a large bill.

That's the honest history of blockchain without crypto. The notebook can work without coins. Whether it beats an ordinary filing cabinet depends on one question: who in the room doesn't trust whom?

What it is

"Blockchain without crypto" means using a shared, append-only ledger for something other than a currency: securities, shipping papers, food records, payments between banks. These systems are almost always permissioned. Only approved members keep copies and write entries, as we explain in "Public vs private blockchains".

Without a coin, there's no mining reward and no open crowd of strangers. The protection comes from the members watching each other. The question is whether that does a job a normal shared database can't.

How it works: three documented cases

  1. Australia's share register. On 7 December 2017, the Australian Securities Exchange announced it would replace CHESS, its system for clearing and settling share trades, with distributed ledger technology. CHESS "was world-leading when introduced in the 1990s", ASX said, and its chief executive said DLT would "enable our customers to develop new services and reduce their costs" (ASX, 2017). In April 2018, ASX described the system as one that "incorporates a permissioned distributed ledger", built by the software company Digital Asset (ASX, 2018).
  2. The stop. On 17 November 2022, after an independent review, ASX said "current activities on the project have been paused while ASX revisits the solution design". It wrote off A$245 million to A$255 million before tax (ASX, 2022). The Reserve Bank of Australia's governor called it "very disappointing" (RBA and ASIC, 2022).
  3. Shipping papers. TradeLens, announced by Maersk and IBM in 2018, was "a blockchain-enabled shipping solution". On 29 November 2022 the two companies said they would close it, because "the need for full global industry collaboration has not been achieved". The platform was to go offline by the end of the first quarter of 2023 (Maersk, 2022).
  4. Mangoes. Walmart and IBM announced food-tracing pilots in October 2016. According to the case study published by Hyperledger, the open-source project behind the software, the time needed to trace where mangoes came from fell from almost seven days to 2.2 seconds (LF Decentralized Trust). That's the builders describing their own results, and worth reading as such.

Two big projects stopped, one success story told by the people who built it. That's not a verdict on the technology. It's a reminder to ask what problem it solved.

Why it matters

  • The hype was real. The US standards body NIST wrote in October 2018: "There is a tendency to overhype and overuse most nascent technology." And: "Many projects will attempt to incorporate the technology, even if it is unnecessary" (NIST, 2018).
  • The cost is real too. Every copy has to store and check every entry. The BIS noted in 2018 that decentralised trust requires every user "to download and verify the history of all transactions ever made" (BIS, 2018). If you trust the keeper, you're paying for nothing.
  • A shared ledger needs sharers. TradeLens's own explanation for closing wasn't the code. It was that not enough of the industry joined.
  • Some uses fit. Several banks or firms that compete with each other, need one record, and don't want any one of them to own it: that's the case a shared ledger was made for.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Blockchain without crypto is pointless." For some groups of parties who don't fully trust each other, a shared record can make sense. Banks run such systems.
  • "Blockchain makes data true." It records what members enter. A wrong entry is stored as faithfully as a right one.
  • "If ASX dropped it, the idea failed." ASX paused one project and said it needed to revisit the design. That is a statement about one project.
  • "Faster tracing proves the blockchain worked." It proves the records were digital and shared. Whether a ledger was needed for that is a separate question.

Ask the one question

When a company announces a blockchain project with no coin, ask: which parties don't trust each other, and why can't one of them just run the database? If the answer is "nobody, and they could", it's a database with a press release.

The council's filing cabinet never made the newspapers. It also never cost A$250 million.

Frequently asked questions

Can a blockchain be used without cryptocurrency?

Yes. Permissioned blockchains run by banks and companies usually have no public coin. Approved members keep copies of the ledger and check each other's entries, instead of miners or validators being paid in a currency.

What happened to the ASX blockchain project?

The Australian Securities Exchange chose distributed ledger technology to replace its CHESS settlement system in December 2017. On 17 November 2022 it paused the project to revisit the design and wrote off A$245 million to A$255 million before tax.

Why did TradeLens shut down?

Maersk and IBM announced on 29 November 2022 that they would close the blockchain-based shipping platform. Maersk said "the need for full global industry collaboration has not been achieved", so it wasn't commercially viable. The platform was due to go offline by the end of the first quarter of 2023.

When does a blockchain make sense for a business?

When several parties need the same record, don't want any one of them to control it, and can't agree on a trusted keeper. If one trusted party could run the database, an ordinary database is usually simpler and cheaper.

Is a private blockchain just a database?

Technically, it's a database shared among members, where each keeps a copy and entries are linked so changes can be detected. Whether that's worth the extra cost depends on how much the members trust each other.

Sources

  1. ASX, ASX selects distributed ledger technology to replace CHESS (7 December 2017)
  2. ASX, CHESS Replacement: New Scope and Implementation Plan (April 2018)
  3. ASX, CHESS replacement: ASX to reassess all aspects of the project (17 November 2022)
  4. Reserve Bank of Australia, ASIC-RBA joint statement on ASX CHESS replacement program (17 November 2022)
  5. A.P. Moller - Maersk, Maersk and IBM to discontinue TradeLens (29 November 2022)
  6. LF Decentralized Trust (Hyperledger), Walmart case study
  7. NIST, Blockchain Technology Overview, NISTIR 8202 (October 2018)
  8. Bank for International Settlements, Annual Economic Report 2018, chapter V

Read next.