Level 2 · First stepsThe village#114

Where your coins come from when you buy them: another customer, a dealer, or nobody yet

On an exchange, your coins come from another customer whose sell order matched yours. In a broker app, they come from the firm's own stock. Either way, nothing is written to the blockchain until you withdraw: until then, your coins are a line in the firm's own book.

Anna needs eggs. The village market gives her three ways to get them.

She can pin a note to the market board: "Buying 10 eggs at 2 coins each." When a farmer pins a matching note, the board keeper pairs them up. Or she can walk to the stall that keeps its own basket of eggs and buys and sells all day at prices on a chalkboard. Or, if she wanted 10,000 eggs, she'd skip both and strike a deal with a big farmer behind the barn.

Crypto works the same way: a board, a stall, or a deal behind the barn. And one more thing Anna should know. Whichever she picks, the village notebook doesn't hear about it until she carries the eggs home.

What it is

When you buy crypto, your coins come from one of three places. On an exchange with an order book, they come from another customer who wanted to sell. In a broker app, they come from the firm's own stock, which it tops up elsewhere. For very large amounts, they come from an over-the-counter deal, arranged privately between two parties.

In all three cases, the first record of your purchase is in the firm's own book. The blockchain only gets a new line when coins actually move to another address.

How it works

The board: an order book. An exchange lists everyone's buy and sell orders by price. When a buy price meets a sell price, the trade happens. The firm running the board is a referee, not a player. The EU's MiCA rules say a firm operating a trading platform "shall not deal on own account on the trading platform for crypto-assets they operate" (ESMA, Article 76; law text on EUR-Lex). It must also make public the bid and ask prices and how much is offered at each.

The stall: a dealer. Many broker apps sell you coins from their own inventory. MiCA calls this exchanging crypto-assets for funds. Here the firm must publish "a firm price" or a method for working out the price, and must execute orders "at the prices displayed at the time when the order for exchange is final" (ESMA, Article 77). The firm is your counterparty. It earns on the gap between its buying and selling price.

Behind the barn: over the counter. Big buyers often trade directly with a dealer instead of hitting the board, so a large order doesn't push the price up while it fills. You'll meet this again in the professional articles.

Now the notebook. Anna buys €100 of bitcoin on an exchange. At CoinGecko's price on 18 November 2026, €56,980.95 per bitcoin (CoinGecko), that's 0.00175497 bitcoin before fees.

What changes? Two lines in the exchange's database. Anna's euro balance goes down by €100. Her bitcoin balance goes up by 0.00175497. The seller's balances move the other way. On the public blockchain, nothing happens at all. The coins were already sitting in the exchange's addresses, and they stay there.

MiCA even allows for this. It gives platforms a deadline to start final settlement of a trade on the distributed ledger, and a separate deadline for trades settled off it (ESMA, Article 76). The same happens with transfers between customers of one firm. Coinbase's help page says that sends to a Coinbase user who has not opted into Instant sends "will be made on-chain and incur network fees" (Coinbase). The others stay inside its own books.

Only when Anna withdraws does the village notebook get a line: a real transaction from the exchange's address to hers, with a network fee, visible on any block explorer. The article "Bitcoin fees explained" covers what that line costs.

Why it matters

Until you withdraw, what you own is a claim on the firm, not a coin on the blockchain. If the firm is honest and solvent, the difference is invisible. If it isn't, the difference is everything. The myth article "My exchange is a bank" covers what happens when a firm fails.

It also explains the price. On a board, you pay what another customer asks. At a stall, you pay what the dealer asks, and the dealer builds in a margin. Neither is wrong. You just want to know which one you're standing at.

Where people get it wrong

  • "My purchase is on the blockchain." Not yet. It's in the firm's database. The blockchain sees it when coins move to a new address.
  • "The exchange sold me its own coins." On an order book, it didn't. Another customer did. In a broker app, it probably did.
  • "Internal transfers prove the coins exist." They prove the firm changed two numbers. Only a withdrawal to your own wallet proves you can move real coins.
  • "Big buyers move the price on my app." Sometimes. Often they trade over the counter and you never see it.

Ask which book you're in

Before you buy, find out which kind of firm you're using. The answer is usually in the terms: "trading platform" means a board, "we act as counterparty" means a stall. Then do one small withdrawal to your own wallet and look it up on a block explorer.

That's the moment your coins enter the village notebook. Until then, they're living in someone else's diary.

Frequently asked questions

Who sells me the bitcoin when I buy on an exchange?

On an exchange with an order book, another customer does. Your buy order is matched with their sell order at a price you both accepted. EU rules forbid the platform operator from trading on its own account on the platform it runs.

Who sells me the bitcoin in a broker app?

Usually the broker itself, from its own stock. Under MiCA, a firm that exchanges crypto for euros must publish a firm price or the method it uses to set one, and must fill your order at the price shown when the order becomes final.

Is my purchase recorded on the blockchain?

Not when you buy on an exchange or app. The firm records it in its own database. A blockchain transaction happens only when coins move to another address, for example when you withdraw to your own wallet.

What is an OTC trade?

OTC means over the counter: a large trade arranged directly between a buyer and a dealer instead of through a public order book. It lets big buyers trade without pushing the visible price around while their order fills.

Why do withdrawals cost a fee when buying didn't?

Buying only changes numbers in the firm's database. A withdrawal is a real blockchain transaction, and the network charges a fee for the space it takes in a block. Firms often add their own withdrawal fee on top.

Sources

  1. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)
  2. ESMA, Interactive single rulebook, MiCA Article 76: operation of a trading platform for crypto-assets
  3. ESMA, Interactive single rulebook, MiCA Article 77: exchange of crypto-assets for funds or other crypto-assets
  4. Coinbase Help, Steps to send crypto (read on 19 November 2026)
  5. CoinGecko, Bitcoin (BTC) price in euros (read on 18 November 2026)

Read next.