Level 4 · Money and marketsThe gold rush#294

DeFi insurance: cover that members vote to pay, with a long list of what it won't

Most DeFi cover is not insurance in the legal sense: it is a discretionary mutual or a protocol-backed scheme that pays if its members or committee agree. It can pay out after a code exploit, but phishing, lost keys, price falls, front-end errors and rug pulls are usually excluded.

Every boomtown with a strongbox eventually gets a man selling protection for it. Pay him a little each month, and if outlaws crack the box, he pays you back.

In DeFi, that man exists. But read his contract. He may not be an insurer at all, he decides together with his members whether to pay, and the list of things he doesn't cover is longer than the list of things he does.

DeFi cover can help after one kind of disaster: the code itself breaking. For most of the ways ordinary users lose money, it pays nothing.

What it is

DeFi cover is protection you buy against a loss in a specific protocol, paid for in crypto, usually for a fixed period. The best-known seller, Nexus Mutual, says plainly that its cover is "not a contract of insurance". It is a discretionary mutual: "Cover is provided on a discretionary basis with Nexus Mutual members having the final say on which claims are paid" (Nexus Mutual, FAQ).

Other models exist. Sherlock, an audit firm, offers Sherlock Shield: exploit payout coverage for code it has audited, worth from $1,000 to $500,000 depending on what the audit found, paid through its on-chain claims process. Sherlock "does not guarantee" payment (Sherlock, Sherlock Shield).

Both are examples, not recommendations. What they have in common: no insurance regulator stands behind the promise.

How it works: what the wording says

Nexus Mutual's Protocol Cover terms list what counts (Nexus Mutual, Protocol Cover terms):

  • Covered: "a smart contract code bug or error" that lets the protocol be used in an unintended way, plus sudden economic events caused by oracle failure, oracle manipulation, liquidation failure or a governance takeover.
  • Not covered, among others: "any losses due to phishing, private key security breaches, malware"; "movements in the market price of assets"; the de-peg of a token the protocol issues; owners "confiscating or stealing funds" (the rug pull); "user interface or website errors"; and bridges.

Now a real claim. On 13 March 2023, Euler Finance, a lending protocol, was drained of about $197 million through a code flaw (Euler Labs). The hack itself is told in "How DeFi protocols get hacked". Here is what the cover did.

Holders of Nexus Mutual's Euler cover waited a 72-hour cooling-off period, then filed. Assessors checked three things: cover was active at the time, there was proof of loss, and the amount matched the loss. Nine Protocol Cover claims were paid, $2,397,472.27 in total, under section 1.1 of the wording (Nexus Mutual, Euler claims).

Sherlock, which had sold cover to Euler (The Block), held excess cover of its own with Nexus Mutual. Its first claim was denied, because it ignored the $500,000 deductible in the wording. A corrected claim was paid: $1 million.

Then the twist. The attacker returned the funds, and Euler reimbursed users. Paid claimants had to hand their Euler claim tokens to the mutual, and eight of nine said they would return their payouts. Nexus Mutual records recovery rates of 99.05% for claims paid in DAI and 32.39% for claims paid in ether.

Why it matters

Cover can turn a total loss into a partial one, if three things line up: the loss is the covered kind, the wording is followed to the letter, and the members vote yes.

For the shovel sellers, cover is also a marketing badge. "Insured" on a protocol's website may mean the protocol bought cover for itself, not for you. It may also mean a capped amount far below what is deposited.

And the mutual's own capital is crypto, held in a smart contract. A large enough disaster across several protocols at once tests the protector as well.

Where people get it wrong

  • "It's insurance." Nexus Mutual itself says it isn't. No regulator guarantees the payout.
  • "I'm covered if I lose money in DeFi." Phishing, drained wallets, lost keys, falling prices and rug pulls are excluded in the wording above.
  • "The protocol is insured, so my deposit is." Cover the protocol bought may pay the protocol, not you, and may be capped.
  • "A claim is paid automatically." It is assessed, and it can be denied on a technicality like a missed deductible.
  • "Audited and insured means safe." Euler was both. It was still drained.

Read the exclusions before the price

Before you buy cover, open the cover wording and read the exclusions first. Then check one thing: is the risk you are actually worried about in the covered list, word for word?

If you mostly fear signing the wrong transaction, no protocol cover helps. Your own habits do.

The protection man is real. He just doesn't patrol the road home.

Frequently asked questions

Is DeFi insurance real insurance?

Usually not in the legal sense. Nexus Mutual, the best-known provider, describes its cover as "not a contract of insurance" and pays claims at its members' discretion. Other schemes are run by audit firms or protocols and do not guarantee payment either.

What does DeFi cover usually pay for?

Losses from a bug in the covered protocol's smart contracts, and in some products economic events such as oracle manipulation or a governance takeover. The exact list is in each product's cover wording.

What does DeFi cover not pay for?

Typical exclusions include phishing, stolen private keys, malware, market price falls, the de-peg of the protocol's own token, rug pulls by the team, front-end or website errors and bridges. Nexus Mutual's Protocol Cover terms list all of these.

Did DeFi cover pay out after the Euler hack?

Yes. Nexus Mutual paid nine Euler Protocol Cover claims totalling $2,397,472.27 and a $1 million excess cover claim from Sherlock. After the attacker returned the funds, most claimants said they would return their payouts.

Who decides whether a DeFi cover claim is paid?

It depends on the provider. At Nexus Mutual, a claims committee or designated assessors vote on each claim within a set period. Sherlock pays through its own on-chain claims process.

Sources

  1. Nexus Mutual Docs, FAQ
  2. Nexus Mutual, Protocol Cover terms and conditions (IPFS)
  3. Nexus Mutual Docs, Claims history: Euler Finance
  4. Sherlock Docs, Sherlock Shield
  5. The Block, Crypto auditor Sherlock to pay out $4.5 million to Euler Finance after exploit (March 2023)
  6. Euler Labs, War and peace: behind the scenes of Euler's $240M exploit recovery (10 January 2024)

Read next.