Level 4 · Money and marketsThe gold rush#282

Impermanent loss: the pool sells your winners on the way up, and the name is optimistic

Impermanent loss is the gap between what your share of a liquidity pool is worth and what the same coins would be worth if you had simply held them. It grows as the two prices move apart, and only fees can make up for it.

Imagine two prospectors who each own one ounce of gold and a pile of coins. The first keeps both under his bed. The second puts them in the vending machine's strongbox for a share of the fees.

Gold doubles in price. The first prospector still has his ounce. The second finds the machine has been selling his gold all the way up, a little at a time, to traders who knew the new price before it did.

That shortfall is impermanent loss. It's the price of letting a machine trade for you against people who trade for a living. "Impermanent" only means it would vanish if prices went back to where they started. Often they don't.

What it is

Impermanent loss compares two choices: putting two tokens into a pool, or holding the same two tokens in your wallet. When the prices of the two move apart, the pool share is worth less than the held tokens, before fees.

Uniswap's documentation explains the name. The loss would disappear "if the price were to return to the same value as when the liquidity provider added their liquidity. For this reason, we can call it an impermanent loss" (Uniswap). Some people prefer "divergence loss", which says what causes it.

How it works

The same documentation gives the formula for a constant product pool:

impermanent_loss = 2 * sqrt(price_ratio) / (1 + price_ratio) - 1

The price ratio is the new price of one token in the other, divided by the old price. Here is a worked example. The ether prices are assumptions, not readings.

The start. You deposit 1 ether and 2,000 dollar stablecoins into a pool, with ether at 2,000 dollars. Your share is worth 4,000 dollars.

Ether doubles to 4,000 dollars. Arbitrage traders buy the cheap ether from the pool until its price matches. The pool's product stays fixed, so your share of the reserves becomes the square root of 2,000 divided by 4,000 in ether, and the square root of 2,000 times 4,000 in stablecoins. That's about 0.7071 ether and 2,828.43 stablecoins, worth 5,656.85 dollars. Had you held, you'd have 1 ether and 2,000 stablecoins, worth 6,000. The gap is 343.15 dollars, or 5.72%. The formula agrees: 2 times the square root of 2, divided by 3, minus 1, is minus 5.72%.

Ether quadruples to 8,000 dollars. Your share becomes 0.5 ether and 4,000 stablecoins, worth 8,000. Held, you'd have 10,000. The gap is 2,000 dollars, minus 20%. Formula: 2 times 2, divided by 5, minus 1.

Uniswap's own table gives the same figures: "a 2x price change results in a 5.7% loss relative to HODL" and "a 4x price change results in a 20.0% loss relative to HODL". It adds that "a doubling in price results in the same loss as a halving". If ether had fallen to 1,000 dollars instead, you would also trail the holder by 5.72%.

Now the fees. Your fee income is the only thing on the other side of the scale. In Uniswap v2 pools, providers get 0.25% of each trade, according to Uniswap's fee page read on 19 November 2026 (Uniswap). To be level with the holder after a doubling, your share of fees must reach 343.15 dollars, about 8.6% of the 4,000 you put in. After a quadrupling, it must reach 2,000 dollars, half your deposit. Whether it does depends on volume and time, not on the formula.

Why it matters

The loss isn't a bug. It's where the arbitrage traders' profit comes from. Every time the pool's price lags the market, someone trades against it and pockets the difference, and that difference comes out of the providers' share.

It also explains which pools can pay. Two stablecoins worth one dollar each hardly ever diverge, so the loss stays small, and so do fees. A pool of a stablecoin and a volatile token can earn more fees and lose much more to divergence.

And it explains why promises to cover it are hard to keep. Bancor, a DEX, offered its providers protection against impermanent loss. On 19 June 2022, with markets falling, it paused that protection. The Block quotes Bancor: "The need to pause IL protection is a result of the recent sell-off of emissions" (via The Block). A guarantee is only as strong as whatever pays it out.

Where people get it wrong

  • "It's impermanent, so it doesn't count." It becomes permanent the moment you withdraw at a different price. Prices that run away rarely wait for you.
  • "I only lose if the price falls." The loss is the same whether the price doubles or halves. Any divergence costs.
  • "A pool return is fees minus nothing." The fair comparison is the pool against simply holding the tokens, fees included on one side and divergence on the other.
  • "The dashboard shows my profit." Many dashboards show fee income only. Check whether they compare with holding.
  • "Someone guarantees I won't lose." A protection scheme is only as good as whatever pays it out.

Do the holder's sum

Before you add to a pool, write down what your two tokens are worth if you just hold them. Then pick a price move you can imagine, say a doubling or a halving, and run the formula. Minus 5.7% for a doubling, minus 20% for a quadrupling.

Then ask whether the pool's fee income, over a long stretch rather than one hot week, has ever covered a move like that.

The machine shares its fees with you. It shares its losses first.

Frequently asked questions

What is impermanent loss?

Impermanent loss is the difference between the value of your share of a liquidity pool and the value of the same tokens if you had held them in your wallet. It appears when the prices of the two tokens in the pool move apart. Trading fees can offset it, but not always.

How do you calculate impermanent loss?

For a constant product pool, Uniswap's documentation gives: impermanent loss = 2 times the square root of the price ratio, divided by 1 plus the price ratio, minus 1. A doubling or halving of the price gives about minus 5.7%. A fourfold move gives minus 20%.

Why is it called impermanent?

Because the loss would disappear if prices returned exactly to where they were when you deposited. If you withdraw while prices are different, the loss becomes real. Some people call it divergence loss instead.

Can trading fees cover impermanent loss?

Sometimes. Fees go to liquidity providers with every trade, and over a long period with high volume they can outweigh the loss. With large price moves, the fees needed can be a large share of the deposit, for example half of it after a fourfold move.

Does impermanent loss happen with stablecoin pools?

Much less, because two stablecoins pegged to the same currency rarely move apart. If one of them loses its peg, though, the pool fills up with the weaker coin, and providers carry the loss.

Sources

  1. Uniswap, Understanding returns (v2 developer documentation)
  2. Hayden Adams, Noah Zinsmeister, Dan Robinson, Uniswap v2 Core (whitepaper, March 2020)
  3. Uniswap, Fees (developer documentation), read on 19 November 2026
  4. The Block, Bancor DEX pauses impermanent loss protection amid market instability (20 June 2022)

Read next.