Level 4 · Money and marketsThe gold rush#286

Yield farming: the harvest is paid in the farm's own coins, and they're printed daily

Yield farming means moving tokens into DeFi protocols to collect rewards, usually new tokens the protocol prints for its users. The headline yield is quoted at the token's price on the day, and that price often falls as the rewards are sold.

A new mine opens at the edge of the boomtown. To attract diggers, the owner pays a bonus: on top of the wage, every digger gets a share certificate in the mine, printed fresh every morning.

The diggers rush in. Some don't dig at all; they just stand on the claim long enough to collect certificates, then sell them in the saloon at noon. By evening the certificates are worth less, because everyone sold theirs at noon too.

That's yield farming. Protocols print tokens and hand them to users who deposit, lend or borrow. The yield is real tokens, but their dollar value depends on who still wants them after the farmers sell.

What it is

Yield farming is moving tokens between DeFi protocols to collect the best rewards. Some of the reward is ordinary income: interest from borrowers, or fees from traders. Often the bigger part is liquidity mining: new tokens a protocol pays to the people using it, to attract deposits and spread its governance votes.

Those reward tokens are emissions. Nobody earned them by paying interest. The protocol created them, and their value comes from buyers in the market.

How it works

The best-known start was Compound, a lending protocol. Its plan for the COMP token said the protocol "transfers 0.50 COMP per Ethereum block (~2,880 per day) into the protocol for distribution", and that "Within each market, 50% of the distribution is earned by suppliers, and 50% by borrowers" (Compound). The plan said it would "begin the COMP Distribution on June 15th", and "the distribution will last for approximately four years".

Distribution began on 15 June 2020. A few hours later, COMP was trading at around 62 dollars on Uniswap, according to The Block (via The Block).

Look at the second quote again. Borrowers earned COMP too. If the reward on a loan was worth more than the interest on it, borrowing paid you. That turned a lending market into a farm, where people borrowed not because they needed the money but to harvest certificates.

Now the arithmetic of a falling reward. The numbers are made up for the example.

The offer. You deposit 10,000 dollar stablecoins in a farm. It pays 2% interest from borrowers, plus 200 reward tokens over a year. At the token's starting price of 10 dollars, those are worth 2,000 dollars. The farm advertises 22%.

The fall. Farmers sell their rewards as they get them. The token slides steadily from 10 dollars to 4 over the year.

Sell as you go. If you sell each day's tokens, you get the average price, about 7 dollars: 1,400 dollars. Plus 200 in interest, that's 16%.

Hold to the end. If you keep the tokens and sell at 4 dollars: 800 dollars. Plus 200 interest, that's 10%.

The farm advertised 22%. You earned 10% or 16%, depending on how fast you sold to the next farmer. And you still carried the risk of the contract, the stablecoin and the farm itself.

Why it matters

Liquidity mining is a way to buy users with printed money. It can work: deposits arrive, governance spreads, and the protocol gets a market. But the reward is paid by whoever buys the token, not by the protocol. When emissions stop, or the token price falls far enough, the farmers move to the next field.

The yield also hides where it comes from. Interest has a payer: borrowers paying under a rate formula like Aave's two-slope model (Aave). Emissions have a printer. A farm that quotes one number for both blends a wage with a lottery ticket.

And the saloon loves it. A token printed daily, quoted as a three-figure annual percentage, makes a great screenshot. It makes a worse plan.

Where people get it wrong

  • "The APY is what I'll earn." It's usually one day's reward rate at one day's token price, stretched over a year. Both can change daily.
  • "Rewards are interest." Interest is paid by borrowers. Reward tokens are newly created and worth what buyers pay.
  • "High yield means a good protocol." It often means the protocol is printing heavily to attract deposits.
  • "I can always sell the rewards." Only if someone buys them. Thin markets for small tokens can collapse when many farmers sell together.
  • "Farming stablecoins is risk-free." The stablecoins can depeg, the contract can be exploited, and the reward token can fall to nothing.

Split the yield in two

Before you farm, split the advertised yield into two parts: what's paid by borrowers or traders, and what's paid in the protocol's own token. Then ask what happens to the second part if the token halves. If most of the yield vanishes, it was never yours; it was a price.

The farm pays you in its own certificates. Check who's buying them at noon.

Frequently asked questions

What is yield farming?

Yield farming means depositing, lending or borrowing tokens in DeFi protocols to collect rewards, often moving between protocols for the highest yield. Rewards usually combine interest or trading fees with newly created tokens. The token rewards make up much of the advertised yield and change with the token's price.

What is liquidity mining?

Liquidity mining is when a protocol hands out its own new tokens to people who use it, such as depositors or borrowers. Compound started distributing its COMP token this way on 15 June 2020, at about 2,880 COMP a day split between suppliers and borrowers. The aim is to attract users and spread governance votes.

Why do yield farming returns fall?

Because the rewards are often sold as soon as they are paid, which pushes the token's price down. More deposits also share the same fixed emissions. And emissions can be cut or stopped by the protocol's governance.

Is yield farming risky?

Yes. You carry the risks of each smart contract, of the tokens you deposit, of the reward token's price and, in pools, of impermanent loss. A high advertised yield usually means more of these risks, not fewer.

How do I compare yield farming offers?

Separate the part of the yield paid by borrowers or traders from the part paid in reward tokens. Check how the reward token's price has moved, and what the yield would be if it halved. Compare the remainder with a low-risk benchmark such as a government bill rate.

Sources

  1. Compound, Expanding Compound Governance (Medium, with update of June 2020)
  2. The Block, Compound governance token begins its first day of trading (15 June 2020)
  3. Aave, Interest rate strategy (Aave V3 documentation)

Read next.