David Chaum and DigiCash: the right map, a decade too early
David Chaum showed in 1982 that digital money could be private, and his company DigiCash put it into real banks in 1995. It still needed a bank in the middle, too few people used it, and the company filed for Chapter 11 in November 1998.
Every gold rush has someone who found gold first and wasn't there to see the crowds. He staked his claim in the right valley, years before anyone built a road there. By the time the town went up, his tent was gone.
In digital money, that man is David Chaum. In 1982 he showed how money on a computer could be as private as a coin in your pocket. In 1995 a real bank in St. Louis started using his system.
Three years later his company was in bankruptcy court. He had the right map. He arrived a decade before the road.
What it is
David Chaum is an American cryptographer. His paper "Blind signatures for untraceable payments" was published in 1983 in the proceedings of the Crypto 82 conference (Chaum, 1983). It starts from a worry: the shape of future electronic payments "may have a substantial impact on personal privacy".
DigiCash was the company he founded around 1990 to sell the idea, based in Amsterdam (American Banker, 1998; AP, 1995). Its product was called ecash.
How it worked: the blind signature
Picture an assay office. You bring a sealed envelope with a gold coin inside, and the assayer stamps the envelope without opening it. The stamp goes through onto the coin. Later the coin turns up in a shop, stamped and genuine, and the assayer has no idea whose envelope it came from.
That's a blind signature, in plain words. In ecash the bank was the assay office:
- Your computer makes a coin with a random serial number, then "blinds" it by mixing in a secret random factor.
- The bank signs the blinded coin and takes, say, one dollar from your account. It can't see the serial number.
- Your computer removes the blinding factor. The bank's signature stays valid on the real coin.
- You pay a shop. The shop sends the coin to the bank, which checks the signature and that the serial number hasn't been spent before.
Chaum explained it to a general audience in Scientific American in August 1992: the bank "has no way of linking the note numbers that Bob deposits with Alice's withdrawals" (Chaum, 1992). The bank knew you took money out. It couldn't tell what you spent it on.
From paper to bankruptcy, step by step
- 1982 to 1983. Chaum presents blind signatures at Crypto 82; the proceedings are printed in 1983.
- About 1990. Chaum founds DigiCash (American Banker, 1998).
- 23 October 1995. Mark Twain Bank in St. Louis launches ecash. An 11-month trial with play money had drawn "more than 30,000 users and 70 merchants" (AP, 1995).
- 1995 to 1998. Five banks license ecash, including Deutsche Bank and Bank Austria. According to American Banker, none got past the pilot stage. Mark Twain ends up with about 5,000 ecash customers holding well under $100,000 in total, and drops the system in September 1998.
- 4 November 1998. DigiCash announces from Palo Alto that it is entering a Chapter 11 reorganization (DigiCash, 1998). CNET reported debts of about $4 million and a staff cut to about six, from nearly 50 in February (CNET, via Hettinga).
The interim boss, Scott Loftesness, said: "Everybody feels anonymous e-cash is inevitable, but the existing situation was not going to get there from here."
Why it matters
- Privacy came first. Chaum proved that digital payments don't have to be a diary of your life. The cypherpunks built on that.
- The bank stayed in the middle. Ecash was private, but a bank still issued every coin and checked every serial number. If the bank stopped, the money stopped. That's exactly what happened.
- Bitcoin answered his open question. Satoshi Nakamoto's design removed the issuing bank altogether. Different trade-off: no central issuer, but every payment on a public ledger.
Where people get it wrong
- "DigiCash was a cryptocurrency." It wasn't. Ecash coins were dollars or other currency issued by licensed banks. No blockchain, no mining, no fixed supply.
- "It failed because the technology didn't work." The banks ran it, and the cryptography held. What was missing was users, shops and a reason for banks to push it.
- "Private means criminal." Chaum's own 1983 abstract wants a system that handles both privacy and "criminal use of payments".
- "He was too late." He was too early. After an 11-month trial, ecash had 70 merchants. The customers and the shops simply weren't online yet.
The sting: check who signs your coins
When someone pitches you a "private" payment app, ask Chaum's question in reverse: who signs the coins, and what happens to them if that signer disappears?
Ecash had serious cryptography behind it. Its customers still woke up one day to find the assay office had locked its doors. Privacy is worth a lot. A shop that's closed is worth nothing.
Frequently asked questions
Who is David Chaum?
David Chaum is an American cryptographer best known for inventing blind signatures, described in a paper published in 1983 in the proceedings of Crypto 82. He founded DigiCash, which offered one of the first private electronic cash systems.
What was DigiCash ecash?
Ecash was a digital cash system in which a bank issued signed electronic coins. Thanks to blind signatures, the bank could confirm a coin was genuine without knowing who had spent it. Mark Twain Bank in St. Louis launched it on 23 October 1995.
When did DigiCash go bankrupt?
DigiCash announced on 4 November 1998 that it was entering a Chapter 11 reorganization in the United States. CNET reported debts of about $4 million at the time, and the company had cut its staff to about six people.
Is DigiCash the same as Bitcoin?
No. Ecash coins were issued by banks and checked by them, so the bank stayed in the middle. Bitcoin, launched in 2009, has no issuer: a network of computers keeps a shared public ledger instead.
What is a blind signature?
It's a digital signature on a message the signer can't read. In ecash, the bank signed a disguised coin, and the customer then removed the disguise. The coin stayed valid, but the bank couldn't link it to the customer when it was spent.
Sources
- David Chaum, Blind signatures for untraceable payments, in Advances in Cryptology: Proceedings of Crypto 82 (Springer, 1983)
- David Chaum, Achieving electronic privacy, Scientific American (August 1992), via University of Miami
- Deseret News (AP), Electronic cash will be hitting the internet (23 October 1995)
- DigiCash press release, DigiCash Inc. to file reorganization (4 November 1998), via cryptoanarchy.wiki archive
- CNET News.com (Tim Clark, 4 November 1998), forwarded to the cryptography mailing list by Robert Hettinga, via MIT archive
- American Banker, Bankrupt DigiCash to seek financing, new allies (10 November 1998)

