The ICO boom of 2017: shares in mines that didn't exist yet
In an ICO, a project sold its own new tokens to the public to raise money, usually before it had a product. Billions were raised from 2017 to 2018, most tokens lost value, and regulators ruled that many of them were securities sold without the paperwork.
Every gold rush produces a man with a map and a stack of certificates. The mine isn't dug yet, he explains, but it will be rich. Buy a share now, before the price goes up. There's a lot of interest. He can't hold it for you past Friday.
In 2017, crypto mass-produced that man. Thanks to Ethereum, anyone could create a token in an afternoon and sell it to the world before lunch the next day.
That was the ICO boom. A few projects built something. Most sold certificates for mines that were never dug.
What it is
An ICO, short for initial coin offering, is a public sale of a new token by the project that creates it. Buyers send bitcoin or ether; the project sends back its tokens and keeps the coins to pay for development.
The template was Ethereum's own ether sale in 2014. The difference in 2017 was scale, speed and the absence of anyone checking the map. Often there was no product, only a white paper and a promise that the token would be needed once the product existed.
How it played out, step by step
- 30 April to 28 May 2016. "The DAO", a fund run by smart contracts on Ethereum, sells tokens for about 12 million ether, valued at about $150 million. An attacker later moves a third of it through a bug in the code (SEC, 2017).
- 25 July 2017. The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) concludes that DAO tokens were securities and subject to federal securities law. The same day it publishes an investor bulletin on ICOs (SEC, 2017). The sheriff has arrived, and he's reading the certificates.
- 4 September 2017. Seven Chinese regulators, led by the People's Bank of China, declare that ICOs are "essentially engaging in public financing without official authorization, which is illegal" (Law Library of Congress).
- 11 December 2017. SEC Chairman Jay Clayton says: "By and large, the structures of initial coin offerings that I have seen promoted involve the offer and sale of securities." He also warns investors to be careful "if an opportunity sounds too good to be true" (Clayton, 2017).
- 16 May 2018. The SEC launches its own fake ICO, "HoweyCoins", with a vague white paper, guaranteed returns and a countdown clock. Click "buy" and you land on the SEC's investor education pages (SEC, 2018). When a regulator can parody your industry with a straight face, the industry has a problem.
- 19 October 2018. EY publishes its study of the "class of 2017". ICOs claimed to have raised $4.1 billion in 2017 and more than $15 billion in 2018. Of the leading 2017 ICOs that listed on an exchange, 86% were trading below their listing price and 30% had lost substantially all their value. Only 29% of the projects EY assessed had a prototype or working product (EY, 2018).
- 29 November 2018. The SEC settles with boxer Floyd Mayweather Jr. and music producer DJ Khaled for promoting ICOs without disclosing they were paid: $300,000 for Mayweather from three issuers, $50,000 for Khaled. They agree to pay $614,775 and $152,725, without admitting or denying the findings (SEC, 2018). The saloon had its own paid singers.
Read step 6 slowly. By EY's count, the money kept pouring in during 2018, while the 2017 tokens were already sinking. The prospectors arrived after the gold had gone.
Why it matters
- Who gained. Projects that kept the bitcoin and ether they raised, whatever happened to the token, and the promoters paid to shout about them.
- Who paid. Buyers who came late, believed the white paper, or both.
- What it changed. The question "is this token a security?" became a central legal issue for crypto. Exchanges, regulators and lawyers have argued about which tokens fall under which rules ever since.
Where people get it wrong
- "It's a utility token, so it's not a security." Clayton's 2017 statement said that calling a token a currency, or giving it some use, doesn't by itself change what it is. The substance counts, not the label.
- "It raised millions, so it must be serious." Raising money proves that marketing worked. It says nothing about whether a product will ever exist.
- "A celebrity backed it." Celebrities get paid to back things. In 2018 the SEC fined two of them for not saying so.
- "ICOs are history." The name went out of fashion. Selling new tokens to the public before there's a product did not.
Run the HoweyCoins test
The SEC handed everyone a free checklist when it built its fake ICO. Before you buy any new token, look for the three things it put on its parody site: a white paper you can't explain to a friend, promised or guaranteed returns, and a clock telling you to hurry.
If you find all three, you've found HoweyCoins. The difference is that the SEC's version gives you your money back by not taking it.
Frequently asked questions
What is an ICO?
An initial coin offering is a public sale of a new crypto token by the project that creates it, usually to fund development. Buyers pay in bitcoin, ether or other coins and receive the new tokens. In the 2017 boom, many ICOs sold tokens before any product existed.
How much money did ICOs raise?
According to an EY study published on 19 October 2018, ICOs claimed to have raised $4.1 billion in 2017 and more than $15 billion in 2018. These are amounts the projects claimed, not audited figures.
Why did most ICO tokens fail?
Many projects never built a working product, and the tokens had no use without one. EY found that 86% of the leading 2017 ICOs that listed were trading below their listing price by 2018, and 30% had lost substantially all their value.
Are ICO tokens securities?
Often, in the US. On 25 July 2017 the SEC concluded that tokens sold by The DAO were securities, and in December 2017 its chairman said most ICO structures he had seen involved securities. Whether a specific token is a security depends on the facts of each case.
Were ICOs banned?
China's regulators declared ICOs illegal on 4 September 2017. In the US they were not banned, but token sales that count as securities must follow securities law, and the SEC brought cases, including against paid promoters who didn't disclose their fees.
Sources
- US SEC, SEC issues investigative report concluding DAO tokens, a digital asset, were securities (press release 2017-131, 25 July 2017)
- US SEC, Report of Investigation: The DAO (Release No. 81207, 25 July 2017), via IOSCO
- Law Library of Congress, Regulation of cryptocurrency: China
- US SEC, Statement on cryptocurrencies and initial coin offerings, Chairman Jay Clayton (11 December 2017), via IOSCO
- US SEC, The SEC has an opportunity you won't want to miss: act now! (press release 2018-88, 16 May 2018)
- EY, ICO portfolio is down by 66% in the first half of 2018, according to EY study (19 October 2018)
- US SEC, Two celebrities charged with unlawfully touting coin offerings (press release 2018-268, 29 November 2018)

