Level 2 · First stepsThe village#105

Metal seed backups explained: a room fire reaches 1,000°C, so the metal matters

A metal seed backup is your recovery phrase stamped or engraved into metal so it can survive a house fire or flood that would destroy paper. It only works if the metal won't melt at fire temperatures and the letters can't fall out or burn off.

Grandma Rosa watches Anna fold her seed phrase into an envelope and frowns. "Paper burns," she says. "Why not ask the blacksmith to stamp it into a plate?"

The blacksmith likes the idea. Then he asks two questions Rosa hadn't thought of. Which metal? Some of them melt in a house fire. And stamped or scratched? A scratch can vanish when the surface scorches.

That's the honest answer about metal backups. They do survive what paper can't, but only the right metal, with the right marks, in one solid piece.

What it is

A metal seed backup is your recovery phrase, the same 12 or 24 words, put onto metal instead of paper. Some are plates you stamp letter by letter with a punch. Some are engraved. Some hold small letter tiles in a frame.

Because every BIP 39 word can be identified by its first four letters (BIP 39), many metal backups only hold four letters per word. That keeps a 24-word phrase small enough to stamp in an evening.

What metal changes is survival. What it doesn't change is secrecy. A thief reads a steel plate as easily as a sheet of paper.

How it works: fire numbers against metal numbers

  1. The fire. The US standards body NIST lists gas temperatures of 400°C or more at the beginning of flashover, the moment a whole room catches fire, and about 1,000°C inside a room undergoing flashover (NIST).
  2. Aluminium. It melts at 660.3°C, according to the Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC). That's well below the temperature in a room at flashover.
  3. Stainless steel. A steel maker's data sheet for the common grade 304L gives a melting point of 1,450°C (thyssenkrupp data sheet). It can scorch and discolour, but it stays solid.

Melting point isn't the whole story, though. The marks have to survive too. The best-known public tests come from Jameson Lopp, a Bitcoin developer who has stress-tested metal backups since 2018. They are one person's tests, not a certified lab standard, and we name no products here.

  1. July 2018. Lopp heated each device with a torch he described as "capable of achieving 2,500° F", about 1,370°C, for over 20 minutes, then put them in acid and under a 20-ton press. Two designs that held loose letter tiles in a frame lost letters: "some letters did fall out". On one plate, engraved words were "completely lost at the point of heat application", while the stamped words stayed readable. In the acid bath, one design's screws had "completely dissolved" (Lopp, 2018).
  2. August 2022. In the sixth round, 22 new devices got "~2000°F heat for 10 minutes", about 1,090°C, then went into water, like a hose after a fire. A paper-thin copper sheet lost data across the heat, acid and crush tests, and several small screws seized or stripped (Lopp, 2022).

The pattern across both rounds is simple. One solid piece beats many small parts. Deep marks beat shallow ones. Thick metal beats thin. And aluminium doesn't belong anywhere near a fire plan.

Why it matters

Our article on wallet backups asked you to imagine your home gone. Paper fails that test. A good metal copy passes it, which means one copy of your words can sit at home without being the weakest link.

The cost is small, and it isn't only money. A plate is permanent: you can't burn it when you retire a wallet, so think about where it ends up. And ordering a product made for seed phrases tells the shop, and anyone who later steals its customer list, that you probably own crypto. Our article on hardware wallets told the story of one such leaked list.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Metal means fireproof." Aluminium melts at 660°C, and a room at flashover reaches about 1,000°C.
  • "Engraved is as good as stamped." In Lopp's 2018 test, engraved words burned off where the heat hit. Stamped words survived.
  • "Tiles are fine while the box is closed." Heat and crushing bent frames, and tiles fell out.
  • "A metal plate replaces my other copies." It replaces paper for one copy. You still need copies in separate places.
  • "A steel plate is safe from thieves." It survives fire, not curiosity. Store it like the paper: unlabelled and out of sight.

Ask the blacksmith's two questions

If you own a metal backup, or are about to buy one, check two facts before you trust it. First, what is it made of? If the maker won't name the alloy, or it's aluminium, treat it as paper with ambitions. Second, how are the letters made? Deep stamping in one solid plate is the shape that survived the tests. Loose tiles, printed letters and light engraving were the shapes that didn't.

Rosa got her plate. Stainless steel, stamped, no screws, no tiles. Paper is fine right up to the night of the fire. After that, only the metal can still read out your words, and only if someone picked the right metal.

Frequently asked questions

What is a metal seed backup?

It's a recovery phrase stamped, engraved or set in letter tiles on metal instead of written on paper. The aim is a copy that survives fire, water and time. It protects the words from damage, not from being read by a thief.

How hot does a house fire get?

NIST, the US standards body, lists about 1,000°C inside a room undergoing flashover, the point where everything in the room catches fire. Gas temperatures at the start of flashover are 400°C or more.

Is aluminium good enough for a seed backup?

No. Aluminium melts at about 660°C according to the Royal Society of Chemistry, well below the temperature of a room at flashover. Stainless steel grades such as 304L melt at around 1,450°C.

Are stamped letters better than engraved ones?

In stress tests published by Bitcoin developer Jameson Lopp in 2018, engraved words on one plate burned off where the heat was applied, while stamped words stayed readable. Deep, punched marks in solid metal did best in his tests.

Do I still need a paper copy if I have a metal one?

A metal plate can replace paper for one copy, but it doesn't replace having more than one copy in separate places. A single metal plate is still a single point of failure if it's lost or stolen.

Sources

  1. NIST, Fire Research Division, Fire dynamics
  2. Royal Society of Chemistry, Periodic table: aluminium
  3. thyssenkrupp Materials UK, Stainless steel 1.4307 (304L) data sheet
  4. Jameson Lopp, Metal bitcoin seed storage stress test (14 July 2018)
  5. Jameson Lopp, Metal bitcoin seed storage stress tests round VI (27 August 2022)
  6. Marek Palatinus, Pavol Rusnak, Aaron Voisine and Sean Bowe, BIP 39: Mnemonic code for generating deterministic keys

Read next.