Level 4 · Money and marketsThe gold rush#329

Why most traders lose money: fees, leverage and the urge to join the crowd

Regulators and researchers keep finding the same thing: most retail traders lose money. Before skill even enters the picture, fees, spreads, funding and leverage tilt the game against them, and the habit of buying after prices rise does the rest.

Picture the trading post at the height of the rush. Every day new prospectors arrive, trade their dust back and forth, and argue about tomorrow's price. Every trade, the clerk takes a pinch.

Some prospectors win for a while. Some lose everything in a week. The clerk never has a bad day, because his pinch doesn't depend on who's right.

That's the short answer to why most traders lose: the game costs money to play, the costs come out of every trade, and the players' own habits make it worse. The regulators have the numbers.

What it is

This isn't a guess. It's what regulators and researchers report whenever they look at real accounts.

  • EU, contracts for difference. In 2018, ESMA said national regulators' analysis found that "74-89% of retail accounts typically lose money on their investments" (ESMA). Since 1 August 2019, UK CFD firms must give a standard risk warning showing the percentage of their own retail accounts that lose money (FCA).
  • Bitcoin app users. A 2022 BIS working paper built a database of crypto app use in 95 countries from 2015 to 2022 and found that "around three-quarters of users have lost money on their Bitcoin investments", 73% to 81% by its estimate (BIS).
  • Day traders. A study of Brazilians who day-traded futures for at least 300 days found that "97% of them lost money, only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller (US$54 per day)" (Chague, De-Losso and Giovannetti, via RePEc).

Different markets, different years, the same picture.

How it works

Three forces, all measurable.

1. Costs come first. A worked example with assumed numbers. You have $10,000 and trade a perpetual future at 10x, so each position is $100,000. Assume a taker fee of 0.05% on each side, a round number in the range exchanges publish.

  • One round trip (open and close): 0.1% of $100,000 is $100. That's 1% of your account.
  • Five round trips a week: $500.
  • Over 52 weeks: $26,000. That's 2.6 times your starting money, paid before you win or lose a single trade.
  • Add funding. If it sat at the default 0.01% every eight hours, which is Binance's base interest component (Binance), a $100,000 long would pay $10 per interval, $30 a day.
  • Add the spread on every trade, covered in "The spread".

To break even, you have to beat the market by all of that, every year.

2. Leverage shortens the walk to zero. As "Leverage explained" shows, at 10x a 10% move wipes out the stake, and a 50% loss needs a 100% gain to recover. The FCA, when it banned crypto derivatives for UK retail consumers from 6 January 2021, estimated it would save them about £53m, and cited "extreme volatility" and "inadequate understanding of cryptoassets by retail consumers" (FCA).

3. The crowd arrives late. The BIS paper's first finding: "a rising Bitcoin price is followed by the entry of new users". New money arrives after the price has already climbed. About 40% of those new users were men under 35, a group the authors call "risk-seeking" (BIS).

Why it matters

  • The shop wins on volume, not on direction. Exchanges, brokers and signal sellers earn from every trade. More trading means more income, whatever happens to you.
  • The saloon sells hope by the month. Signal groups and courses charge subscriptions. If their system reliably beat the costs above, they wouldn't need your subscription.
  • The other side is often a machine. The Brazilian study concluded that "it is virtually impossible for individuals to compete with HFTs and day trade for a living", HFTs being high-frequency trading firms.
  • The sheriff's answer is caps, warnings and bans. Leverage caps, standard loss warnings and outright bans for some products: each one is a regulator saying the numbers above are not bad luck.

Where people get it wrong

  • "I'll be in the winning minority." Everyone thinks so. The numbers above include all of them.
  • "Fees are small." Small per trade, large per year. The example above turned 1% a trade into 2.6 times the account.
  • "A few big wins will cover it." At high leverage, the losses arrive first and close the account before the big win.
  • "I'm investing, not trading." Then the costs above mostly don't apply. Check whether your behaviour matches the word.

Count the pinch

Before you open a trading account, write down your planned trades per week, the fee per trade and the position size. Multiply by 52. Compare the total with your starting money.

If the clerk's pinch for a year is bigger than your bag, you don't need a strategy. You need a different trading post, or none.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of traders lose money?

It depends on the market and the study. ESMA reported in 2018 that 74% to 89% of retail CFD accounts typically lose money, a BIS working paper estimated in 2022 that 73% to 81% of bitcoin app users had lost money, and a Brazilian study found that 97% of persistent day traders lost money.

Why do most crypto traders lose money?

Trading costs such as fees, spreads and funding are paid on every trade, leverage turns small price moves into large losses, and many people buy after prices have already risen. Together, these tilt the odds against the average retail trader.

Do trading fees really matter that much?

Yes, especially with leverage, because fees are charged on the full position. At an assumed 0.05% per side on a $100,000 position, five round trips a week cost $26,000 a year, more than twice a $10,000 account.

Why do regulators limit leverage for retail traders?

Because their data shows most retail accounts lose money and leverage makes those losses bigger and faster. In the EU, ESMA capped crypto CFD leverage at 2:1 in 2018, and the UK's FCA banned crypto derivatives for retail consumers from 6 January 2021.

Can anyone make a living from day trading?

Very few. A study of Brazilian futures day traders who persisted for at least 300 days found that only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller, about US$54 a day, and 97% lost money.

Sources

  1. ESMA, ESMA agrees to prohibit binary options and restrict CFDs to protect retail investors (27 March 2018)
  2. FCA, FCA confirms permanent restrictions on the sale of CFDs and CFD-like options to retail consumers (1 July 2019)
  3. FCA, FCA bans the sale of crypto-derivatives to retail consumers (6 October 2020)
  4. BIS, Auer, Cornelli, Doerr, Frost and Gambacorta, Crypto trading and Bitcoin prices: evidence from a new database of retail adoption (BIS Working Paper 1049, 14 November 2022)
  5. Chague, De-Losso and Giovannetti, Day trading for a living? (FGV EESP discussion paper 525, February 2020), via RePEc
  6. Binance, Introduction to Binance Futures funding rates (support FAQ)