Level 3 · How it worksThe gold rush#201

What miners do after a halving: the old pickaxes go quiet, the big diggers buy new ones

On 20 April 2024 the new bitcoin paid per block fell from 6.25 to 3.125, halving what each unit of mining power earns from new coins. The blockchain shows the network's computing power dipping in the weeks after, while listed miners' own reports show them bringing in more efficient machines and cheaper power.

Imagine the assay office announcing one morning that it now pays half per ounce. The rock is the same. The digging is the same. The pay is half.

Bitcoin does this to its miners every 210,000 blocks, on a schedule written into the code. Our article on the halving explains the rule. This one is about the morning after.

The short answer: the least efficient machines go quiet, the network's computing power dips, and the big firms that planned ahead plug in newer machines on cheaper power.

What it is

At block 840,000, mined on 20 April 2024, the block subsidy fell from 6.25 to 3.125 bitcoin. Overnight, every terahash of mining power earned half as much in new coins.

Fees didn't halve. But in most blocks, fees are the smaller part of the pay. So for most miners, revenue per unit of work roughly halved, while the electricity bill stayed exactly where it was.

How it works: the blockchain's own record

Look at the blocks themselves, read from mempool.space.

The last block before. Block 839,999 paid its miner 7.29455386 bitcoin: 6.25 subsidy plus 1.04 in fees (block 839,999).

The halving block. Block 840,000 paid 40.75061499 bitcoin: 3.125 subsidy plus 37.63 in fees, about 92% of the reward (block 840,000). That was one block, not a new normal.

The difficulty afterwards. The network retargets every 2,016 blocks. Difficulty follows the computing power that's switched on, so it shows what miners did:

  1. Block 840,672 (24 April 2024): difficulty 88.10 trillion, up 1.99% on the previous period. Most of that period came before the halving (block 840,672).
  2. Block 842,688 (9 May 2024): 83.15 trillion, down 5.62%. The first full period at half pay (block 842,688).
  3. Block 850,752 (5 July 2024): 79.50 trillion, down 5.00% on the period before, and 9.77% below the level at block 840,672 (block 850,752).

So in the ten weeks after the halving, enough machines went quiet that the network needed almost a tenth less work per block. The fall in difficulty then raised everyone else's share. That's the self-correcting part.

What the miners themselves reported

Two listed US miners, as examples, not recommendations, in their own April 2024 updates:

Riot Platforms produced 375 bitcoin in April 2024, down 12% from 425 in March, or 12.5 a day against 13.7 (Riot, 6 May 2024). Its answer was more scale on its own power: it energised 400 megawatts of substations at a new site in Corsicana, Texas, "just ahead of the recent 'halving' on April 20th, 2024".

CleanSpark mined 721 bitcoin in April 2024, with 17.3 exahashes per second and a month-end fleet efficiency of 24.22 joules per terahash (CleanSpark, 2 May 2024). It was deploying newer S21 machines, credited "the remarkable increase in transaction fees immediately following the halving", and said it was "already observing signs of less efficient miners beginning to cease operations".

Read those two together and you get the halving playbook from the inside: newer machines, more megawatts at a cheaper price, and a hope that someone else switches off first.

Why it matters

Who pays: owners of older, hungrier machines. When pay halves, a machine that was barely covering its power bill now loses money on every hash. Switching it off is the rational move.

Who gains: whoever is left, because difficulty falls and their slice grows. And firms with the most efficient machines, whose costs were low enough to survive half pay.

For the network, a dip in hash rate after a halving is normal, not a crisis. Difficulty adjusts and blocks keep coming.

Where people get it wrong

  • "The halving makes miners rich because scarcity pushes the price up." Their pay per block halved for certain. The price is not certain at all.
  • "Fees will replace the subsidy right away." Block 840,000 carried 37.63 bitcoin in fees. Block 842,688, three weeks later, carried about 0.16.
  • "Hash rate falls, so the network is in trouble." It fell by under a tenth over ten weeks, and the difficulty adjustment did its job.
  • "All miners suffer equally." The ones with cheap power and efficient machines take market share from the rest.

Read the next monthly update

After the next halving, at block 1,050,000, don't read the headlines. Read the listed miners' own monthly updates: bitcoin produced per day, fleet efficiency in joules per terahash, and megawatts of power.

The firms that bought new pickaxes will say so. The ones that switched off old ones usually say less.

Frequently asked questions

What happened at the 2024 Bitcoin halving?

At block 840,000, mined on 20 April 2024, the new bitcoin paid per block fell from 6.25 to 3.125. That block itself carried 37.63 bitcoin in fees, an exception, so its miner received 40.75 bitcoin in total.

Does hash rate fall after a halving?

It did in 2024. Difficulty, which follows the network's computing power, fell 5.62% at block 842,688 on 9 May 2024, and by 5 July 2024 it was 9.77% below its level at block 840,672.

Why do miners switch off machines after a halving?

Because each machine earns about half as much in new coins while using the same electricity. Older, less efficient machines can end up costing more in power than they earn, so their owners turn them off.

How did listed miners prepare for the 2024 halving?

According to their own April 2024 updates, Riot Platforms energised a new 400-megawatt substation site in Texas and CleanSpark deployed newer, more efficient machines. Both reported their production, hash rate and expansion plans month by month.

When is the next Bitcoin halving?

At block 1,050,000. The date depends on how fast blocks are found, so it can only be estimated from the current block height.

Sources

  1. mempool.space API, Bitcoin block 839,999 (20 April 2024)
  2. mempool.space API, Bitcoin block 840,000 (20 April 2024)
  3. mempool.space API, Bitcoin block 840,672 (24 April 2024)
  4. mempool.space API, Bitcoin block 842,688 (9 May 2024)
  5. mempool.space API, Bitcoin block 850,752 (5 July 2024)
  6. Riot Platforms, Riot announces April 2024 production and operations updates (6 May 2024)
  7. CleanSpark, CleanSpark releases April 2024 bitcoin mining update (2 May 2024)

Read next.