Level 1 · Start hereThe village#080

"Stablecoins are always stable": only as stable as the chest behind them

A stablecoin is a promise to be worth one dollar or one euro, and the promise is only as good as the reserves behind it and the right to swap back. Even a fully backed stablecoin fell to 86 cents for a weekend in March 2023 when part of its cash sat in a failed bank.

Grandma Rosa doesn't want a coin that jumps around. The miller offers her the next best thing: a chit that says "worth one silver coin, swap it back any day". Behind every chit, he says, a real silver coin sits in his chest.

Rosa likes that. Then one Friday the news goes round the well: part of the miller's silver was stored at the notebook keeper's house, and the keeper's house has just burned down. By Saturday, people are selling their chits for less than a coin. Nobody can reach the miller's chest until Monday.

That's a stablecoin. It's not a coin that can't move. It's a promise that usually holds, backed by a chest you can't see.

What it is

A stablecoin is a crypto token meant to keep a fixed value, usually one dollar or one euro. Most big ones are issued by a company that promises to swap each token back for one unit of real money, and holds reserves to keep that promise.

"Always stable" assumes three things at once: the reserves are really there, they can be turned into cash fast, and holders can swap back when they want. When any one of the three wobbles, so does the price.

How it works: USDC, March 2023

USDC, issued by the company Circle, was one of the largest dollar stablecoins, and its reserves were cash and short-term US government debt. That's as boring as a reserve gets. Watch what happened anyway.

  1. Friday 10 March 2023. US regulators close Silicon Valley Bank after a run. Late that evening Circle says part of its reserve cash is stuck there.
  2. The size. Circle later put it at $3.3 billion, "about 8% of the USDC total reserve". The rest was 77% ($32.4 billion) in short-dated US Treasury bills and 23% ($9.7 billion) in cash (Circle, 2023).
  3. The weekend. Banks are shut, so nobody can swap USDC back to dollars with Circle. The market price is all there is. A Federal Reserve note records: "At its trough, USDC traded at 86 cents to the dollar" (Federal Reserve, 2025).
  4. Sunday 12 March. The US Treasury, Federal Reserve and FDIC announce that all of the bank's depositors "will have access to all of their money starting Monday, March 13" (Federal Reserve, 2023).
  5. Monday 13 March. Circle's press release carries the headline "Dollar De-peg Closes". In the following days, the Fed note says, Circle redeemed $3.8 billion of USDC.

Now the arithmetic. If 8% of the chest had really been lost, a fully backed token would be worth about 92 cents. The market priced it at 86 cents at the low. Panic always charges a little extra.

The damage spread. The same Fed note records that Dai, a stablecoin with no money at the bank but a lot of USDC behind it, also lost its peg, and that another dollar token, USDP, fell to about 91 cents. In a crowded village, one burned house darkens several chests.

Not every chest is the same

USDC got its dollar back because the reserves were real and the government rescued the bank's depositors. Terra's UST had no chest of dollars at all, only a swap with its own sister token. In May 2022 it broke and never came back. Our article on the Terra and FTX collapses tells that story.

So "stablecoin" covers very different promises. Some hold cash and government debt, some hold other crypto, some hold a formula. The word on the label is the same.

What the rules say

In the EU, a stablecoin tied to one official currency is an e-money token under MiCA (EUR-Lex; readable version in ESMA's single rulebook). Holders have a claim on the issuer, which must redeem "at any time and at par value", and redemption "shall not be subject to a fee" (Article 49). At least 30% of the money received must sit in separate accounts at banks, and the rest in "secure, low-risk assets" in the same currency (Article 54). Note the irony: part of the chest must sit in banks, and banks can fail.

In the US, the GENIUS Act, signed in July 2025, requires issuers to hold reserves on an at least one-to-one basis in assets such as cash, bank deposits and Treasury bills with "a remaining maturity of 93 days or less", and to "publish the monthly composition of the issuer's reserves" on their website (GENIUS Act). Our world overview covers the law in more detail.

Rules make the chest more likely to be full. They don't make the price unable to move for a weekend.

Where people get it wrong

  • "One stablecoin equals one dollar, always." It equals one dollar if you can redeem it at the issuer. On the market, USDC hit 86 cents for a weekend.
  • "Fully backed means risk-free." USDC's backing was real. Part of it sat in a bank that failed.
  • "All stablecoins are alike." A token backed by Treasury bills and one backed by a formula share a name, not a risk.
  • "A depeg means the coin is finished." USDC recovered within days. UST never did. The chest decides.

Ask who holds the chest

Before you treat any stablecoin as safe money, look for three things on the issuer's own site: what the reserves are, where they are held, and who checks them, with a date on the most recent report. Then read the redemption terms: who can swap back, how fast, and at what fee.

If you can't find the chest, you're not holding a stablecoin. You're holding a chit from a friendly miller.

Frequently asked questions

Can a stablecoin lose its peg?

Yes. USDC, backed by cash and US Treasury bills, traded as low as 86 cents in March 2023 after part of its reserves got stuck in Silicon Valley Bank. It recovered within days. Terra's UST lost its peg in May 2022 and never recovered.

Why did USDC fall below one dollar in March 2023?

Circle had $3.3 billion, about 8% of USDC's reserves, at Silicon Valley Bank when the bank was closed on 10 March 2023. Over the weekend nobody could redeem with Circle, and the market price fell. It recovered after US authorities said all the bank's depositors would get their money.

What does MiCA require from euro or dollar stablecoins?

Under MiCA, a stablecoin tied to one official currency is an e-money token. Holders can redeem it at any time at face value without a fee, and the issuer must keep at least 30% of the funds in separate bank accounts and the rest in secure, low-risk assets in the same currency.

What does the US GENIUS Act require from stablecoin issuers?

The GENIUS Act, signed in July 2025, requires at least one-to-one reserves in cash, bank deposits, short-term Treasury bills and similar assets. Issuers must publish the composition of their reserves every month.

Is a stablecoin the same as money in a bank?

No. A bank deposit in the EU is covered by a deposit guarantee up to €100,000. A stablecoin is a claim on the issuer and its reserves, with no guarantee scheme behind it.

Sources

  1. Circle, $3.3 billion of USDC reserve risk removed, dollar de-peg closes (press release, 12 March 2023), via the Internet Archive
  2. Federal Reserve, FEDS Notes: In the shadow of bank runs: lessons from the Silicon Valley Bank failure and its impact on stablecoins (17 December 2025)
  3. Federal Reserve, Joint statement by Treasury, Federal Reserve, and FDIC (12 March 2023)
  4. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)
  5. ESMA, Interactive single rulebook: MiCA Article 49, Issuance and redeemability of e-money tokens
  6. ESMA, Interactive single rulebook: MiCA Article 54, Investment of funds received in exchange for e-money tokens
  7. US Government Publishing Office, GENIUS Act, S. 1582 (enrolled bill, 119th Congress)

Read next.