Level 4 · Money and marketsThe gold rush#308

Soulbound tokens and on-chain identity: a certificate you can't sell, and everyone can read

A soulbound token is an NFT that cannot be transferred, meant to record a credential, membership or reputation tied to one wallet. That makes it useful for identity and risky for privacy, because a public blockchain shows it to everyone, permanently.

In a boomtown, almost everything is for sale. Claims, deeds, scrip, the mule. But some papers can't be sold: a miner's licence, a certificate from the assay office, a note saying who vouches for you.

Those papers were about the person, not the property. Selling them would make them worthless.

A soulbound token is the crypto version: a token nailed to one wallet. The catch is where it's nailed. On a public blockchain, it hangs on a door the whole town walks past, forever.

What it is

A soulbound token, or SBT, is a non-transferable NFT. The Ethereum standard ERC-5192, created in July 2022 and marked Final, puts it in one line: "A soulbound token is a non-fungible token bound to a single account" (ERC-5192).

The idea was set out in a paper posted on 11 May 2022 by Puja Ohlhaver, E. Glen Weyl and Vitalik Buterin, "Decentralized Society: Finding Web3's Soul" (SSRN). They call wallets "Souls" and imagine them holding credentials, memberships and affiliations: "A university could be a Soul that issues SBTs to graduates" (full text).

How it works: one function and a real example

ERC-5192 adds almost nothing to an ordinary NFT contract. There is one function, locked(tokenId), which answers true or false. When it is true, "all EIP-721 functions of the contract that transfer the token from one account to another must throw". In plain words: the transfer fails. Two events, Locked and Unlocked, tell wallets and explorers when the status changes.

Now a real one. Binance, the exchange, launched its Binance Account Bound token, BAB, on BNB Chain on 8 September 2022 at 09:00 UTC (Binance announcement). Its own description:

  • What it is: "identity credentials for Binance users who completed KYC verification".
  • Who can mint: "All Binance users who have completed KYC verification".
  • Transfers: "Users cannot transfer BAB tokens to other users."
  • Revoking: users can revoke their own token, after which there is a 72-hour lock period.
  • Cost: a gas fee, fixed at first at 1 BUSD, taken from the user's Binance balance.

Follow what that does. A wallet holding BAB proves to any app that its owner passed an identity check at Binance, without showing a passport. Useful. But the token sits on a public chain. Anyone can see that this address belongs to a person who has a verified Binance account, and anyone can read everything else that address has ever done.

Why it matters

SBTs promise portable reputation: a degree, a loan history or a community vote you can carry from app to app, without a platform owning it. The paper also suggests using them against sybil attacks, where one person fakes many wallets, and for recovering a lost wallet through the people who know you.

The privacy cost is the price of that portability. The authors say it plainly: "Blockchain-based systems are public by default", and "too many public SBTs may reveal too much information about a Soul" (full text). Their own fixes include keeping data off-chain with only a hash on-chain, and zero-knowledge proofs, which prove a fact without revealing the data behind it.

The EU went the other way with its own identity project. Regulation (EU) 2024/1183 entered into force on 20 May 2024 and requires every member state to offer a European Digital Identity Wallet to citizens and residents by the end of 2026 (European Commission; EU digital strategy). Users choose which parts of their identity to share with each service, with the stated aim of "eliminating unnecessary data sharing". Not a public ledger. Close to the opposite of one.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Soulbound means it can never be removed." Many designs let the issuer or holder revoke or burn it. BAB lets users revoke theirs.
  • "Non-transferable means private." Transfer and visibility are different things. An SBT on a public chain is readable by anyone.
  • "An SBT proves who I am." It proves that an issuer said something about a wallet. Trust the issuer, not the token.
  • "If I lose the wallet, the credential follows me." It stays in the lost wallet unless the issuer reissues it.
  • "It's just an NFT that can't be sold." Technically, yes. Socially, it's a label that anyone can attach to everything else your wallet has done.

Count what your wallet says about you

Before you mint any credential to a wallet, open that wallet's address on a block explorer and read it as a stranger would. Every token, every swap, every vote is there. A soulbound token adds your name, or something close to it, to the whole history.

If that's fine, keep that wallet for credentials only. If it isn't, use a fresh one.

In the boomtown, the miner's licence stayed in his coat. On a blockchain it's pinned to his door, next to his bank statements.

Frequently asked questions

What is a soulbound token?

A soulbound token is a non-transferable NFT tied to one wallet. It is meant to record credentials, memberships or reputation, and the Ethereum standard ERC-5192 defines one as a non-fungible token bound to a single account.

Where does the idea of soulbound tokens come from?

The idea was set out in the paper "Decentralized Society: Finding Web3's Soul" by Puja Ohlhaver, E. Glen Weyl and Vitalik Buterin, posted on SSRN in May 2022. It describes wallets called Souls holding non-transferable tokens for credentials and affiliations.

Can a soulbound token be removed?

Often yes. The original paper allows tokens that the issuer can revoke, and Binance's BAB token lets users revoke their own. What can't happen is a normal transfer to another wallet while the token is locked.

Are soulbound tokens private?

Not on a public blockchain. Anyone can see which soulbound tokens an address holds, and combine that with the address's full transaction history. The paper's authors themselves warn that too many public SBTs may reveal too much about their holder.

How is the EU digital identity wallet different from a soulbound token?

The European Digital Identity Wallet, which every EU member state must offer by the end of 2026, lets users choose which parts of their identity data to share with each service. A soulbound token on a public chain is visible to everyone.

Sources

  1. Ohlhaver, Weyl and Buterin, Decentralized Society: Finding Web3's Soul (SSRN, May 2022)
  2. Full text of the paper (RadicalxChange PDF)
  3. Ethereum Improvement Proposals, ERC-5192: Minimal Soulbound NFTs
  4. Binance, Binance to launch Binance Account Bound (BAB) token, the first-ever soulbound token on BNB Chain (September 2022)
  5. European Commission, The Digital Identity Regulation enters into force
  6. European Commission, European Digital Identity Regulation

Read next.