Proof of history, authority and space: a clock, a guest list and a full hard drive
Proof of history is a clock that Solana used alongside proof of stake, not a replacement for it. Proof of authority lets a list of known validators sign blocks, which suits private networks. Proof of space and time, used by Chia, makes hard-drive space the scarce resource instead of electricity or a deposit.
The village has settled on two ways to decide who writes the next page: dig for it, or put savings in the deposit box by the well. Then travellers arrive with three more ideas.
One wants to hang a clock on the church tower, so every page carries the exact time it was written. One says: why not let five respected elders take turns with the pen? The third says the right to write should go to whoever has the biggest empty barn.
Grandma Rosa asks the obvious question: which of these replaces the box? Only two of them. The clock was never meant to. And in October 2026, the most famous clock in crypto stopped setting the pace.
What it is
These are three other answers to "who writes the next block?":
- Proof of history is a running clock made of hashes. Solana's white paper calls it "a proof for verifying order and passage of time between events", meant to be "used alongside a consensus algorithm such as Proof of Work (PoW) or Proof of Stake (PoS)" (Solana white paper).
- Proof of authority gives the pen to a known list of validators. In the words of the Hyperledger Besu documentation: "PoA consensus protocols work when participants know each other and there is a level of trust between them" (Besu docs).
- Proof of space and time is Chia's design. Its consensus "uses storage capacity as the scarce resource", combined with a cryptographic proof "that real time has passed" (Chia docs).
How it works
The clock: proof of history
A computer hashes its own output again and again. Each hash depends on the one before, so the chain can only be made in order, one step at a time. The white paper's trick is the check: the sequence "can be verified correct by a multicore computer in significantly less time than it took to generate it" (Solana white paper).
On Solana, the leader's clock stream emitted 64 tick entries per slot. That changed with the Alpenglow upgrade, which activated on mainnet in epoch 1064, starting on 21 October 2026. Solana's own page says "Proof of History no longer paces block production"; votes and timeouts do instead. It puts finality at about 12.8 seconds before and a target of about 150 milliseconds after (Solana). The deposit box was there all along. The clock just stopped setting the pace.
The guest list: proof of authority
A fixed group of validators, known by name, signs the blocks. They vote new members in or out. Besu's versions, QBFT and IBFT 2.0, need at least two-thirds of the validators to be running to make blocks. A network of four or five validators survives one going silent; six to eight survive two (Besu docs).
Ethereum's own test networks used it. Clique, specified in EIP-225 in March 2017, ran the Rinkeby test network from April 2017. Its author's reason: "proof-of-work cannot work securely in a network with no value" (EIP-225). Test coins are worthless, so nobody would pay the electricity to protect them honestly. Besu has since dropped Clique (Besu docs).
The barn: proof of space and time, worked through
Chia farmers fill disks once with precomputed tables, called plots. Chia's docs give the example that someone storing 500 GiB has 5 "votes" and someone storing 100 GiB has 1 (Chia docs). Here's what that means for one ordinary 4 TB drive, using the docs' own numbers:
- Plots. The smallest standard plot, k32, takes 101.4 GiB (Chia docs). A 4 TB drive is 4,000,000,000,000 bytes, about 3,725 GiB. That's 36 full plots, using 3,650 GiB.
- Challenges. The network issues 64 signage points per 600-second sub-slot (Chia docs): one every 9.375 seconds, 9,216 a day.
- The filter. At each signage point, a filter rules out most plots. The docs give the ratio as 1 in 512, as of December 2023 (Chia docs).
- The work. 36 plots times 9,216 challenges, divided by 512: on average about 648 plot look-ups a day. The disk mostly sits there.
- The clock. Separate machines called timelords run the proof of time and add the winning blocks to the chain (Chia docs).
On 27 February 2026, Chia announced a new plot format for version 3.0, with plots of about 1 GiB and a fork proposed at block height 9,562,000. Old plots will then fade out over 256 days (Chia Network). The sizes change. The idea, disk space as the ticket, stays.
Why it matters
- Each swaps the scarce thing. Electricity, a deposit, a name on a list, a full disk. Whatever is scarce decides who can cheat, and what it costs them.
- Proof of authority is fast and simple, and it's trust. That suits a company network or a test network. For open money, it's a committee with a notebook.
- Proof of space moves the cost. Less power while farming, but the disks and the plotting are real costs, paid up front.
- Clocks help speed, not security. A clock orders events. The deposit box still decides who may write.
Where people get it wrong
- "Solana runs on proof of history instead of proof of stake." Its white paper describes the clock as working alongside a consensus algorithm, and since October 2026 the clock no longer paces Solana's blocks.
- "Proof of authority is just efficient proof of stake." Nothing is staked. The validators risk their reputation and their seat on the list.
- "Proof of space costs nothing." Disks cost money, and filling them with plots takes computing time.
- "A new 'proof of' means a new kind of security." Often it's a new name for an old trade-off.
Ask what's scarce
Next time a project pitches you a new "proof of something", ask two questions. What is scarce here? And what does a cheater lose?
If the answer is "the founders' reputation", you've found proof of authority with better marketing. Rosa would call it a guest list. The stranger at the gate would call it a revolution.
Frequently asked questions
What is proof of history?
Proof of history is a sequence of hashes that proves the order of events and the passage of time between them, described in Solana's white paper. It works alongside a consensus mechanism such as proof of stake. Since Solana's Alpenglow upgrade in October 2026, it no longer paces Solana's block production.
Is proof of history a consensus mechanism?
Not on its own. Solana's white paper describes it as a clock used alongside a consensus algorithm such as proof of work or proof of stake. Validators with staked SOL still decide which blocks count.
What is proof of authority?
Proof of authority lets a fixed list of known validators sign blocks and vote members in or out. Hyperledger Besu's documentation says it works when participants know each other and there is a level of trust between them, which makes it common for private and test networks.
What is proof of space and time?
It is Chia's consensus design. Farmers fill disk space with precomputed plots and answer regular challenges, while timelords supply a proof that real time has passed. Storage capacity, not electricity or a deposit, is the scarce resource.
Does proof of space use less energy than proof of work?
Farming mostly means reading a disk now and then, so it uses far less power than constant guessing. Creating the plots takes real computing work up front, and the disks themselves cost money.
Sources
- Anatoly Yakovenko, Solana: A new architecture for a high performance blockchain (white paper v0.8.13)
- Solana, Alpenglow upgrade page
- Hyperledger Besu documentation, Proof of authority consensus
- Péter Szilágyi, EIP-225: Clique proof-of-authority consensus protocol (created 6 March 2017)
- Chia documentation, Consensus introduction
- Chia documentation, Consensus basics
- Chia documentation, Proof of space
- Chia documentation, Signage and infusion points
- Chia Network, Changes coming to 3.0 (27 February 2026)

