Level 2 · First stepsThe village#156

Fake exchanges and fake apps: the balance is a picture, and the exit is a fee

A fake exchange or app looks like a real trading platform, but the scammer controls it: the balance on screen is invented, and withdrawals are blocked by endless "taxes" and fees. Check that the firm is licensed in a register, and that you found it yourself.

The stranger at the gate has opened a stall. It looks just like the village money-changer's: same striped awning, same scales, a sign painted in the same letters. Hand him your coins and he writes your balance on a slate. Every day, the number on the slate goes up.

Grandma Rosa asks the obvious question. "Can I have my coins back?" Of course, he says. There's just a small withdrawal tax first. Then a verification fee. Then a penalty for withdrawing early.

The slate was never connected to anything. In the village notebook, the real one, Rosa's coins moved to the stranger on the first day, and the line says so in ink.

What it is

A fake exchange is a website or app that copies the look of a trading platform. You deposit real crypto or money. The scammer keeps it and shows you a made-up balance. Some copy the name of a real firm, which regulators call a clone; others invent a brand from nothing.

The FBI's report for 2025 describes how victims "are enticed to send cryptocurrency to fake investment scam platforms or apps and are shown fake profits" (FBI IC3, 2025 report). Most people don't find these platforms by chance. They are sent there by a new online friend, an ad or an "investment group", the scripts from our article on romance scams.

How it works: three fake apps, one ending

On 18 July 2022 the FBI warned US banks and investors about fake crypto investment apps (FBI, 2022). It had identified 244 victims and an estimated $42.7 million in losses. Three cases from that notice:

  1. The borrowed bank. From 22 December 2021 to 7 May 2022, an app used the name and logo of a real US financial institution. At least 28 victims lost about $3.7 million, which averages about $132,000 each. When 13 of them tried to withdraw, they were told by email to pay "taxes" first. They paid. They still couldn't withdraw.
  2. The ghost exchange. From 4 October 2021 to 13 May 2022, an app called YiBit took about $5.5 million. YiBit had been a genuine exchange that appeared to close in 2018. The criminals likely reused its name.
  3. The surprise rule. In November 2021, an app called Supay told one customer he had been enrolled in a programme requiring a $900,000 minimum balance. Deposit the difference, or the account would be frozen.

Same ending each time: money goes in, a number goes up, nothing comes out. The US Federal Trade Commission describes the pattern: the website "looks real, but it's really fake, and so are their promises" (FTC).

Why it matters

A fake platform turns every safety habit inside out. You check your balance, and it's fine. You see charts, a support chat, even a licence number. Everything a careful person looks for is on screen, because the scammer built the screen.

The only thing he can't fake is the village notebook. On the blockchain, the deposit went to his address, not to an exchange's. And the other thing he can't fake is a regulator's register, as long as you open it yourself.

Where people get it wrong

  • "It's a proper app, with a logo and reviews." In the FBI's cases, victims were told to download apps carrying a real bank's name and logo. An app proves someone can build an app. Check the firm and its licence.
  • "My balance keeps growing." It's a number the scammer types. The SEC warns that fraudsters show small "profits" to build trust before asking for larger sums (SEC, 2024).
  • "I just have to pay the tax to withdraw." Real exchanges don't hold your money hostage for an advance tax payment. The fee is the next stage of the scam.
  • "It uses the name of a real company." Clones copy real names on purpose. Contact the real firm using details from the official register, not from the app.

Check the register, not the screen

Before you deposit anything, look the firm up yourself. In the EU, crypto-asset service providers need authorisation under MiCA (EUR-Lex), and ESMA publishes the interim MiCA register of authorised firms (ESMA). In the UK, the Financial Conduct Authority keeps a Warning List of firms it is "concerned are working without our permission", and its Firm Checker for authorised ones. It warns that scammers may pose as "clone firms (a copy of a genuine firm)" (FCA). The FCA issued 2,329 warnings about unauthorised or potentially scam firms in 2025 (FCA, 2026).

Then test the exit before the entrance: a real platform lets you withdraw a small amount without a "tax". Rosa found the money-changer's name in the register. The stall at the gate wasn't there. That told her everything the slate couldn't.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if a crypto exchange is fake?

Look up the firm's exact name in your regulator's register, such as ESMA's interim MiCA register in the EU or the FCA's register in the UK, and reach it through details you find there. Be wary of any platform you were sent to by a new online contact, and of any that asks for fees or taxes before you can withdraw.

Why can't I withdraw from my crypto app?

If you are asked to pay taxes, fees or penalties before a withdrawal, the platform is very likely fake and controlled by a scammer. Paying more won't release the money. Stop paying and report it to the police and your national regulator.

Is a crypto app safe if someone sent me the download link?

Not by itself. In the cases the FBI described in July 2022, victims were told to download apps that used a real bank's name and logo or the name of a closed exchange. Check the firm's exact name in a regulator's register, and reach it only through the details listed there.

What is a clone firm?

A clone firm is a scam that copies the name, address or registration details of a real, authorised firm. The UK's FCA advises contacting a firm only through the details on its official register, not those the caller or website gives you.

How much have people lost to fake crypto apps?

In July 2022 the FBI warned of 244 victims who had lost an estimated $42.7 million to fake crypto investment apps. Its report for 2025 names fake investment platforms and apps as part of crypto investment fraud, which caused $7.2 billion in reported losses that year.

Sources

  1. FBI, Private Industry Notification 20220718-001: Cyber criminals create fraudulent cryptocurrency investment applications to defraud US investors (18 July 2022)
  2. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report
  3. US SEC, Investor alert: 5 ways fraudsters may lure victims into scams involving crypto asset securities (29 May 2024)
  4. US Federal Trade Commission, What to know about cryptocurrency and scams
  5. Financial Conduct Authority, FCA Warning List of unauthorised firms
  6. Financial Conduct Authority, FCA cracks down on illegal promotions and market abuse in first year of new strategy (9 July 2026)
  7. ESMA, Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA), incl. the interim MiCA register
  8. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)

Read next.