How to check if a token is a scam: the notebook shows the trap, if you read it before you buy
Anyone can create a token with any name in minutes. Before you buy one, get its contract address from the project's own source, then use a block explorer to see who holds it, what its owner can do, whether anyone has managed to sell, and whether the trading looks real. In the EU, also look for its white paper in ESMA's register.
The stranger at the gate is selling a new coin. It's stamped "Village Gold", it shines, and he says the whole valley is buying it. Grandma Rosa likes the name. It sounds like something that already exists.
Anna doesn't look at the coin. She asks to see its page in the notebook: who made it, who holds most of it, and whether anyone who bought it has ever managed to sell it back. The stranger is suddenly very busy.
That's the whole method. A token is a line of code on a public blockchain, and the notebook shows almost everything about it. The trap is usually there in plain sight. You just have to read it before you buy, not after.
What it is
A token is a coin created by a smart contract on an existing blockchain, such as Ethereum. Creating one takes minutes and costs little. The creator picks the name, the ticker and the supply, and can copy the name of any famous token. The only thing that makes a token unique is its contract address.
A scam token is one built to take your money: a copycat of a real token, a "honeypot" you can buy but never sell, a token whose creator can print more or freeze yours, or one whose price and volume are faked. Rug pulls, where the creator drains the trading pool, have their own article.
The check
Each step takes a minute or two on a block explorer, the public website that displays the notebook.
1. Who brought it to you?
A token that finds you, through a direct message, a group chat, an airdrop into your wallet or an ad, starts with a minus. The stranger chose you. You didn't choose the token.
Check: you found it yourself, through the project's own channels.
2. Get the real contract address
Search by name and you'll find copies. Take the contract address only from the project's official website or documentation, typed in yourself, and compare it on the explorer.
Check: the address you're about to trade matches the one the project publishes, start, middle and end.
3. Is the code published?
Explorers let creators publish ("verify") the source code behind a contract. Ethereum's developer documentation warns that without verification, "malicious smart contracts can have backdoors" that go unnoticed (ethereum.org).
Check: the explorer marks the contract as verified. If not, stop.
4. What can the owner do?
Some contracts let an owner create new tokens, pause trading, block addresses or raise the sales fee to 100%. You don't need to read code to spot the danger: explorers list the contract's functions and show whether an owner address still controls it.
Check: no owner, or an owner whose powers are documented and limited.
5. Who holds it?
Open the holders list. If a few wallets that aren't exchanges or locked contracts hold most of the supply, they can sell into your purchase at any moment.
Check: no single unexplained wallet holds a large share.
6. Has anyone sold?
A honeypot lets you in and never out. Look through the recent transactions for sales, not only purchases, from ordinary wallets.
Check: many different addresses have sold successfully.
7. Is the trading real?
Volume can be bought. On 9 October 2024, US prosecutors charged 18 people and firms with manipulating crypto markets. The FBI had created its own token, NexFundAI, to catch market makers who allegedly ran "wash trades" to fake activity. One defendant allegedly said the aim was that "the token looks organic and looks live and people get interested in trading it". More than $25 million in crypto was seized (US Attorney, Massachusetts).
Check: trading is spread across many addresses, not a few bouncing between each other.
8. Look for the paperwork
In the EU, a firm offering a crypto-asset to the public must generally be a legal person and draw up, notify and publish a white paper under MiCA Article 4 (EUR-Lex; ESMA rulebook, Article 4). Small offers, such as those under €1,000,000 over 12 months, are exempt. ESMA keeps a register of these white papers, updated weekly, alongside a list of non-compliant entities (ESMA; Article 109).
Check: a token sold to you in the EU has a white paper in the register, and its seller isn't on the non-compliant list.
Why it matters
Token scams don't break the notebook. They use it. Every scam token is a perfectly valid line in the ledger, and every purchase is a payment you signed yourself. Nobody can reverse it afterwards. The checks above move the reading to before you sign, when it still costs nothing.
Where people get it wrong
- "It has the right name and logo." Names are free. Only the contract address counts.
- "It's listed on a price site, so it's checked." Listing sites show what trades. They don't vouch for it.
- "The trading volume is high, so people must trust it." Volume can be faked by wash trading, as the NexFundAI case showed.
- "I'll sell as soon as it doubles." In a honeypot, the sell button is the part that doesn't work.
The rule at the gate
If you can't tick all eight, don't buy. If you can, you've avoided the obvious traps, nothing more. A token that passes is not a good investment; it's just not obviously a fraud.
The stranger can stamp any name on a coin. He can't stamp a clean history onto the notebook. Read that first.
Frequently asked questions
How do I check if a crypto token is legitimate?
Get the contract address from the project's official website, then look it up on a block explorer. Check that the contract code is verified, who controls it, how the supply is spread across holders, and whether ordinary wallets have been able to sell. In the EU, also check ESMA's register for its white paper.
What is a honeypot token?
A honeypot is a token whose contract lets people buy but blocks them from selling, or charges a sales fee so high that selling is pointless. The price chart can look healthy because only purchases go through. Checking the transaction list for successful sales by different wallets helps expose it.
Why does a token's contract address matter more than its name?
Anyone can create a token with any name, ticker and logo, including copies of famous tokens. The contract address is the only unique identifier. Always take it from the project's own official source, never from a message, an ad or a search result.
Can trading volume be faked?
Yes. In wash trading, the same people buy and sell to each other to make a token look popular. In October 2024 US prosecutors charged 18 people and firms after an FBI sting in which the bureau created its own token to catch market makers allegedly faking volume.
Does a token need approval to be sold in the EU?
Under MiCA, an offer of a crypto-asset to the public in the EU generally requires a published and notified white paper, with exemptions for small offers. ESMA keeps a public register of these white papers. It's a register, not a stamp of quality: being listed doesn't make a token a good investment.
Sources
- ethereum.org, Verifying smart contracts
- US Attorney's Office, District of Massachusetts, Eighteen individuals and entities charged in international operation targeting widespread fraud and manipulation in the cryptocurrency market (9 October 2024)
- Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA), EUR-Lex
- ESMA, Interactive single rulebook, MiCA Article 4: Offers to the public of crypto-assets other than asset-referenced tokens or e-money tokens
- ESMA, Interactive single rulebook, MiCA Article 109: Register of crypto-asset white papers
- ESMA, Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA), incl. the interim MiCA register

