Stablecoins vs CBDCs: the shopkeeper's chit or the town's own coin
A stablecoin is a private company's promise to pay; a central bank digital currency (CBDC) would be a claim on the central bank itself. The EU is building a digital euro with holding limits, while a US executive order of 23 January 2025 told federal agencies not to establish one.
In a boomtown, the assay office and the general store print their own chits. "Worth one dollar, redeem it at the counter." The chits work as long as the counter does.
Now imagine the town itself printed a digital chit, backed not by a shop's strongbox but by the mint. That's the difference between a stablecoin and a central bank digital currency, or CBDC.
Both look like digital dollars or euros on a screen. Who you are trusting is completely different.
What it is
A stablecoin is a private company's liability. Its value rests on the issuer's reserves and its willingness to redeem. If the issuer fails, holders join a queue.
A CBDC would be central bank money in digital form, like a banknote but on a phone. The central bank can't run out of its own currency, so there's no reserve to worry about. There is a different question instead: how much the state sees, and how much it lets you hold.
How it works: the digital euro and a US no, step by step
The two largest Western economies took opposite turns. Dated steps:
- 23 January 2025, United States. An executive order sets a policy of "taking measures to protect Americans from the risks of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs)". Section 5 says "agencies are hereby prohibited from undertaking any action to establish, issue, or promote CBDCs" (White House, 23 January 2025). The US bet on regulated private stablecoins instead.
- 30 October 2025, euro area. The ECB's Governing Council decides to move the digital euro to its next phase. If the EU adopts the law in 2026, "a pilot exercise and initial transactions could take place as of mid-2027", and the Eurosystem aims to be ready for a first issuance "during 2029". It puts development costs until then at about EUR 1.3 billion and running costs at about EUR 320 million a year from 2029 (ECB, 30 October 2025).
- 19 December 2025. EU finance ministers agree the Council's position. The ECB would set holding limits, under an overall ceiling set by the Council and reviewed at least every two years. The digital euro would work online and offline (Council of the EU, 19 December 2025).
- 9 July 2026. The European Parliament votes 416 in favour, 169 against, with 22 abstentions, and is ready to negotiate with the Council. Its text says "there would be a cap on how many digital euros any individual could hold" (European Parliament, via Mondo Visione).
The ECB says its final issuance decision comes only once the law is adopted. Some quick sums on its own figures: if the first issuance comes in 2029, five years of running costs, 2029 to 2033, would be 5 times EUR 320 million, EUR 1.6 billion, on top of the EUR 1.3 billion to build it. The ECB expects these costs to be covered by seigniorage, the income from issuing money.
Why it matters
Who holds the risk:
- Stablecoin: you hold a claim on a company. Its reserves sit at banks and in bonds, and you rely on rules and an accountant's report.
- CBDC: you hold a claim on the central bank. No reserve risk, but you rely on the law to limit what the state can see and do.
Who earns the interest:
- Stablecoin: the issuer keeps the income from the reserve; MiCA (EUR-Lex; readable version: ESMA, Article 50) and the GENIUS Act bar issuers from paying interest to holders.
- Digital euro: the central bank's issuing income pays for the system, per the ECB.
Why holding limits: banks fund loans with deposits. If everyone moved savings into a central bank wallet, banks would shrink, and in a panic a digital euro could speed up a bank run. A cap keeps the digital euro a wallet for payments, not a savings account.
The ECB doesn't hide which side it prefers. ECB President Christine Lagarde said on 8 May 2026 that "Stablecoins are private liabilities whose stability depends on the credibility and liquidity of their backing" (ECB, 8 May 2026).
Where people get it wrong
- "A CBDC is just a government stablecoin." No reserve backs it; it is the reserve. That's the whole difference.
- "The digital euro exists." It isn't money you can hold. The ECB's own target for a first issuance is 2029, and only after the law is adopted.
- "A CBDC will replace cash." The Council paired its digital euro position with rules to protect cash as legal tender.
- "Stablecoins are anonymous, CBDCs are surveillance." Major stablecoin issuers can freeze addresses, and every transfer is on a public ledger. Privacy depends on the rules of each system.
Ask who stands behind the counter
Whatever digital money you use, ask one question: if this fails, whose promise am I holding? A company's, a bank's, or the central bank's? Then read who can freeze it and who can see it.
Every chit has someone behind the counter. Make sure it's someone you can name.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a stablecoin and a CBDC?
A stablecoin is issued by a private company and backed by its reserves. A CBDC is issued by a central bank and is a direct claim on it, like a digital banknote. The first carries issuer risk; the second carries no reserve risk but raises questions about privacy and state control.
When will the digital euro launch?
The ECB said on 30 October 2025 that, if EU law is adopted in 2026, a pilot could start from mid-2027 and the Eurosystem should be ready for a first issuance during 2029. The final issuance decision comes only after the law is adopted.
Will there be a limit on how much digital euro I can hold?
Both the Council and the European Parliament back a holding limit. Under the Council's position of 19 December 2025, the ECB would set the limit under an overall ceiling set by the Council. The ECB says such safeguards are built into the design to avoid risks to financial stability.
Does the US have a CBDC?
No. An executive order of 23 January 2025 prohibited federal agencies from taking any action to establish, issue or promote a CBDC. The US instead set rules for private stablecoins in the GENIUS Act of July 2025.
Who pays for the digital euro?
The ECB estimated on 30 October 2025 that development until a first issuance would cost about EUR 1.3 billion, with running costs of about EUR 320 million a year from 2029. The Eurosystem would bear these costs and expects them to be offset by seigniorage, its income from issuing money.
Sources
- ECB, Eurosystem moving to next phase of digital euro project (press release, 30 October 2025)
- Council of the EU, Single currency: Council agrees position on the digital euro and on strengthening the role of cash (19 December 2025)
- European Parliament, Digital euro: MEPs ready to start negotiations (press release, 9 July 2026), via Mondo Visione
- The White House, Strengthening American Leadership in Digital Financial Technology (Executive Order, 23 January 2025)
- EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)
- ESMA, Interactive single rulebook: MiCA Article 50, Prohibition of granting interest
- ECB, Christine Lagarde, Stablecoins and the future of money: separating functions from instruments (8 May 2026)

