Level 3 · How it worksThe gold rush#246

Arbitrum and Optimism explained: Ethereum's busiest suburbs, with one gatekeeper each

Arbitrum One and OP Mainnet are optimistic rollups: they run transactions off Ethereum, post the data back to it, and give anyone about a week to prove a mistake. Each still has one sequencer ordering transactions and a security council that can step in.

When the boomtown gets too crowded, suburbs grow on its edge. They don't keep their own land registry. They do business all day, then send every receipt to the town hall in the city, where anyone can check the sums.

The suburb trusts its own clerk to write the receipts in the right order. The city trusts nobody: any citizen gets a week to object to a wrong sum before the city signs it off.

That's an optimistic rollup, and Arbitrum and Optimism are the two biggest examples on Ethereum. Optimistic means "assume it's right unless someone proves otherwise". The question for you is who the clerk is, and who can change the rules of the suburb.

What it is

A rollup runs transactions away from Ethereum, then posts the transaction data and the resulting state back to Ethereum. An optimistic rollup doesn't prove each batch is correct. It allows a challenge period in which anyone can submit a fraud proof showing a batch was wrong. Rollups get their own article in the scaling section; here are the two towns.

  • Arbitrum One, built by Offchain Labs, "the initial developers of Arbitrum". Since its ARB token airdrop on 23 March 2023, governance has run through the Arbitrum DAO (Arbitrum Foundation).
  • OP Mainnet, built on the OP Stack and governed by Optimism's own DAO with the OP token. The OP Stack is open software that other chains reuse. Base, Coinbase's chain, is "an Optimistic Rollup built with the OP Stack" (ETHBEAT).

How it works

Four parts, with real settings.

  1. The clerk (sequencer). Each chain has one sequencer that receives transactions and puts them in order. Arbitrum's own docs call the design "a centralized Sequencer", run as one logical sequencer (Arbitrum docs). If it ignores you, you can post your transaction directly to Ethereum; on Arbitrum, the docs put that bypass at about 24 hours.
  2. The objection window. Arbitrum One's dispute window is "45818 blocks (about 6.4 days)" of Ethereum blocks (Arbitrum docs).
  3. Who may object. On OP Mainnet, permissionless fault proofs went live on 10 June 2024, so withdrawals could be proven "without involvement from any trusted third parties" (Optimism). Arbitrum's version, BoLD, went live on Arbitrum One on 12 February 2025 (Arbitrum docs).
  4. The override. A security council can still step in. Arbitrum's has 12 members, and "Performing any Emergency Action requires a 9-of-12 approval", which can "execute any software upgrade" with no delay (Arbitrum DAO Constitution).

Now the arithmetic of leaving the suburb.

  • The wait. Ethereum makes a block every 12 seconds. 45,818 × 12 = 549,816 seconds, which is 6 days, 8 hours, 43 minutes and 36 seconds. ETHBEAT lists Arbitrum One's challenge period as "6d 8h" (ETHBEAT). Same number, two sources. That's why a withdrawal through the official bridge takes about a week, while deposits arrive in minutes.
  • The council. 9 of 12 is exactly 75%. To block an emergency action, 12 minus 9, plus 1, so 4 members must refuse or be unreachable. On OP Mainnet ETHBEAT lists a 10-of-13 council, 76.9%, and again 4 members can block. Base's council is 8 of 11, 72.7% (ETHBEAT).

Who holds the keys

ETHBEAT, the risk tracker formerly called L2BEAT, ranks rollups in stages from 0 to 2, depending on how far users are protected if the operators misbehave. Read on 19 November 2026, Arbitrum One, OP Mainnet and Base are all at Stage 1: a working proof system is in place, but a security council can still step in over it in an emergency. None has reached Stage 2. Optimism said as much when it launched fault proofs: its council "retains the power to intervene and revert the system back to a permissioned state" (Optimism).

Why it matters

  • Users usually pay lower fees than on Ethereum for the same kind of app, and their funds are protected by Ethereum's rules plus a working fraud proof, not by a separate validator set as on a sidechain.
  • Operators decide the order of every transaction. One sequencer means one business sitting at the till.
  • Everyone carries the governance risk. A few people with keys can upgrade the contracts that hold all the money.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Layer 2 means as safe as Ethereum." Only as safe as its proof system, its upgrade keys and its sequencer allow. That's what the stages measure.
  • "My withdrawal is stuck." A week is the design. Fast bridges cut the wait by fronting you the money, for a fee and with their own risk.
  • "Governance tokens make the chain decentralised." ARB and OP holders vote. A small council can still act in an emergency, with no delay.
  • "Base is Optimism." Base was built with the OP Stack, but Coinbase runs it with its own council and its own proof setup.

Read the risk page before the bridge

Before you move money to any rollup, open its page on ETHBEAT and read four lines: the stage, the challenge period, who runs the sequencer, and the size of the council. It takes three minutes.

The suburb is cheaper than the city. The deeds still have a clerk's name on them.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Arbitrum and Optimism?

Both are optimistic rollups on Ethereum with a challenge period for fraud proofs. Arbitrum One was built by Offchain Labs and is governed by the Arbitrum DAO with the ARB token; OP Mainnet runs on the OP Stack and is governed by Optimism's DAO with the OP token. Their proof systems, councils and fee settings differ in detail.

Why do withdrawals from Arbitrum take a week?

The official bridge waits for the dispute window to pass, so anyone can challenge a wrong state. On Arbitrum One that window is 45,818 Ethereum blocks, about 6.4 days. Deposits to Arbitrum don't need this wait.

Who runs the sequencer on Arbitrum and Optimism?

Each chain uses a single sequencer that orders transactions. Users who are ignored can force their transaction in through Ethereum, after a delay of about 24 hours on Arbitrum. Plans to decentralise sequencing exist but had not replaced the single sequencer on 19 November 2026.

What does Stage 1 mean for a rollup?

Stage 1 is a rating from ETHBEAT, formerly L2BEAT. It means a working proof system is in place, but a security council can still step in over it in an emergency. Arbitrum One, OP Mainnet and Base were all at Stage 1 on 19 November 2026.

Is Base part of Optimism?

Base is built with Optimism's open-source OP Stack. Coinbase operates it with its own security council and proof setup, so its risks need checking separately from OP Mainnet's.

Sources

  1. Arbitrum docs, Chain parameters (dispute window)
  2. Arbitrum docs, The Sequencer and censorship resistance
  3. Arbitrum docs, BoLD adoption (launch dates on Arbitrum One and Nova)
  4. Arbitrum Foundation, The Constitution of the Arbitrum DAO
  5. Arbitrum Foundation, DAO governance and ARB airdrop announcement (16 March 2023), via PR Newswire
  6. Optimism, Permissionless fault proofs and Stage 1 arrive to the OP Stack (10 June 2024)
  7. ETHBEAT (formerly L2BEAT), Arbitrum One (read on 19 November 2026)
  8. ETHBEAT (formerly L2BEAT), OP Mainnet (read on 19 November 2026)
  9. ETHBEAT (formerly L2BEAT), Base (read on 19 November 2026)

Read next.