Level 3 · How it worksThe gold rush#249

Bitcoin Cash, Ethereum Classic and other forks: life in the town that split off

Bitcoin Cash split from Bitcoin on 1 August 2017, and Ethereum Classic is the chain that refused Ethereum's DAO fork on 20 July 2016. Both kept running, but with far fewer miners than the chains they left, and Ethereum Classic paid for that with 51% attacks in 2019 and 2020.

Every gold-rush town has a quarrel sooner or later. About water rights, the claim rules, who gets to be mayor. Most quarrels end in a vote. A few end with half the town packing its wagons and building a new settlement on the next hill, with the same maps and the same records up to the day they left.

In crypto, that's a chain split. Both towns keep the shared history. From the split on, each writes its own.

The new town keeps the maps. What it doesn't automatically keep is the guards. This article is about what happens to the town that split off, using the two best-known cases. How forks work in general is in "What is a fork?".

What it is

  • Ethereum Classic (ETC) is the original Ethereum chain that kept running when most of the network adopted the DAO fork at block 1,920,000 on 20 July 2016 (Etherscan). In ethereum.org's words: "Some miners refused to fork because the DAO incident wasn't a defect in the protocol" (ethereum.org). The full story is in "The DAO hack and the Ethereum split".
  • Bitcoin Cash (BCH) split from Bitcoin on 1 August 2017 to allow bigger blocks. Bitcoin SV split from Bitcoin Cash on 15 November 2018, after another quarrel over the rules (via The Block).

How it works: the splits and what followed, step by step

  1. 20 July 2016. Ethereum's DAO fork. The chain that refused it carries on as Ethereum Classic.
  2. The replay problem. Same history, same addresses: a payment signed on one chain could be copied onto the other. The fix was a chain ID inside each signed transaction. Ethereum Classic's is 61 (ECIP-1066). Our article on EVM-compatible chains explains how it works.
  3. 1 August 2017. The last block both Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash share is 478,558, mined at 13:16:14 UTC (Blockchain.com). Bitcoin Cash's next block, 478,559, arrived at 18:12:41 UTC and weighed 1,915,175 bytes (Blockchain.com). That's 1.9 times the old one-megabyte limit, so Bitcoin nodes threw it out.
  4. 15 November 2018. Bitcoin Cash splits again. Both sides mine a block 556,767, and The Block reports that "major exchanges have halted trading for bitcoin cash" until the dust settles.
  5. 5 January 2019. Coinbase detects "a deep chain reorganization of the Ethereum Classic blockchain". By the evening of 7 January it counts 15 reorganisations, "12 of which contained double spends", totalling 219,500 ETC, about $1.1 million at the time, with depths from 25 to 123 blocks (Coinbase).
  6. August 2020. Three more attacks on Ethereum Classic in one month, rewriting 3,693, 4,000 and then over 7,000 blocks, according to figures reported by CoinDesk (via CoinDesk).

Do the sums on January 2019. 219,500 ETC over 12 double spends is about 18,292 ETC each. Coinbase paused ETC on 5 January and re-enabled sends and receives on 11 March 2019: 65 days of a shop with its door shut. A reorganisation 123 blocks deep means an exchange that credited a deposit after fewer than 123 confirmations could have been paid with coins that later vanished.

Why the split-off town gets robbed

A proof-of-work chain is as safe as the cost of out-mining it. When a town splits, the miners choose where to dig. If most stay with the bigger chain, the smaller one is guarded by a fraction of the hash rate, and an attacker who can bring more machines than that can rewrite its recent history. The attack article explains the mechanics. Ethereum Classic in 2019 and 2020 is the textbook case.

Why it matters

  • Holders at the time of a split end up with coins on both chains. Whether the new coin is worth anything is the market's call, not a gift.
  • Exchanges carry the attack risk. They respond by pausing deposits or demanding many more confirmations.
  • Everyone learns that "the original chain" is an argument, not a fact. Each side claims the name.

Where people get it wrong

  • "A fork is a free copy of a coin." You get coins on both chains, but you need to claim them safely, and a sloppy claim can expose your keys or replay a payment.
  • "Same code means same security." Same code, different crowd of miners. Security comes from the hash rate behind the chain, not the software.
  • "Ethereum Classic is the copy." It's the chain that kept the old rules. Which one is "the original" depends on who you ask.
  • "51% attacks only hit tiny coins." Ethereum Classic was a well-known coin on major exchanges when it was hit in 2019 and again in 2020.

Count the confirmations

If you ever deposit a split-off coin on an exchange, look up how many confirmations it demands for that coin, and compare it with Bitcoin or Ethereum on the same page. A much bigger number isn't red tape. It's the exchange telling you how cheap it thinks an attack is.

The new town kept the maps. It's still hiring guards.

Frequently asked questions

What is Ethereum Classic?

Ethereum Classic is the original Ethereum chain that kept running after most of the network adopted the DAO fork on 20 July 2016 at block 1,920,000. Miners and users who refused the fork stayed on it. Its chain ID is 61.

When did Bitcoin Cash split from Bitcoin?

On 1 August 2017. Both chains share every block up to 478,558. The first Bitcoin Cash-only block, 478,559, was 1,915,175 bytes, too big for Bitcoin's rules at the time.

What is Bitcoin SV?

Bitcoin SV came out of a further split of Bitcoin Cash on 15 November 2018, when two camps disagreed on the rules. Both chains kept the shared history up to the split and continued separately.

Has Ethereum Classic been 51% attacked?

Yes. Coinbase reported deep reorganisations from 5 January 2019, including 12 double spends worth 219,500 ETC. In August 2020 the chain was hit three more times in one month, with reorganisations of thousands of blocks.

What is a replay attack?

When two chains share history and address formats, a transaction signed for one chain may be valid on the other, so someone can copy it across. Chain IDs, built into each signed transaction, stop this on Ethereum-style chains.

Sources

  1. Blockchain.com explorer, Bitcoin Cash block 478,558
  2. Blockchain.com explorer, Bitcoin Cash block 478,559
  3. Etherscan, Block 1,920,000
  4. ethereum.org, The history of Ethereum
  5. Ethereum Classic, ECIP-1066: Ethereum Classic network description
  6. The Block, Bitcoin Cash hard fork activates, splitting the chain in two (15 November 2018)
  7. Coinbase, Deep chain reorganization detected on Ethereum Classic (ETC) (7 January 2019)
  8. CoinDesk, Ethereum Classic hit by third 51% attack in a month (29 August 2020)

Read next.