Level 2 · First stepsThe village#088

Custodial vs non-custodial wallets: someone else's key is someone else's promise

In a custodial wallet, a company holds the keys and owes you the coins. In a non-custodial wallet, you hold the keys and nobody owes you anything, including help. The difference shows on the day something goes wrong.

Grandma Rosa doesn't like keys. She loses her reading glasses twice a day. So she leaves her coins with the exchange stall in the market, and the stall writes in its own little book: "Rosa, 10 coins."

In the village notebook, the one every house can read, Rosa's name appears nowhere. The coins there belong to the stall's key. Rosa owns a line in the stall's private book, and the stall's promise to honour it.

That's a custodial wallet. A non-custodial wallet is the opposite: Rosa holds her own key, and the village notebook answers to her signature alone. One gives her a promise. The other gives her a responsibility.

What it is

In a custodial wallet, a company, usually an exchange or a payment app, holds the private keys. You log in with a password, and the balance you see is the company's record of what it owes you. Moving coins means asking the company to sign for you.

In a non-custodial wallet, sometimes called a self-hosted wallet, the keys are created and kept on your own device or on paper. Nobody else can sign for you, freeze you or lose your coins on your behalf. Nobody else can recover them for you either.

The coins on the blockchain look the same in both cases. What changes is whose key opens them, and therefore what you own: a coin, or a claim.

How it works: what FTX customers owned

When the exchange FTX collapsed, its customers found out exactly which of the two they had.

  1. 11 November 2022. FTX files for bankruptcy in the US. This becomes the "petition date".
  2. The hole. The company's own disclosure statement later said more than $10 billion of net customer deposits had been misappropriated from the FTX.com exchange during 2022, and that after the petition date the exchange owed customers a shortfall of about $9.2 billion (Disclosure statement, 2024).
  3. 26 June 2024. The bankruptcy judge ruled on how to value customer claims. Customers had filed them "in quantities of digital assets", so many bitcoin, so many ether. The court held that "the value of the claims must be determined as of the petition date" (US Bankruptcy Court, 2024).
  4. 7 October 2024 and 18 February 2025. The court confirms the plan. FTX says 98% of creditors by number will receive approximately 119% of their allowed claims, in cash (FTX, 2024). The first payouts begin on 18 February 2025 (via The Block).

Read that again. A customer who had one bitcoin on FTX didn't get one bitcoin back. They got dollars, worked out from what a bitcoin was worth in November 2022. Most also got a top-up on that figure. Whatever bitcoin did after that date was no longer their business.

That's the honest description of a custodial balance. It's not a coin with your name on it. It's a line in someone else's book, and if the book closes, a court decides what the line is worth.

Why it matters

Custody isn't a scandal in itself. Banks hold your money, brokers hold your shares, and both are regulated. Crypto custody is catching up. In the EU, MiCA says that coins a licensed provider holds for clients "shall be legally segregated" from the provider's own estate, so creditors of a failed firm can't simply take them. The firm is also liable if it loses clients' coins, with liability "capped at the market value" of the lost coins at the time of the loss (EUR-Lex, MiCA; ESMA, Article 75).

That's real protection, and it depends on the firm being licensed and the rules being followed. FTX's customers had no such shield.

Non-custodial has its own bill. No firm can run off with your coins, and no firm will answer the phone when you lose your recovery words. Our article on lost bitcoin shows how many coins have gone quiet that way.

Where people get it wrong

  • "My exchange balance is my bitcoin." It's the exchange's promise to give you bitcoin. Usually good, until it isn't.
  • "Non-custodial means safer." It means nobody else can lose your coins. You still can.
  • "A custodian can't freeze my coins." It can, and sometimes must, for example under a court order or anti-money-laundering rules.
  • "An app that shows me recovery words is non-custodial." Not by itself. Read the terms to see whether the company also holds keys, or parts of them.
  • "If the custodian fails, I get my coins back." You get what a court or the rules decide. At FTX, that was dollars at November 2022 values.

Ask who can sign

For each place your coins live, ask one question: who can sign a transaction without me? If the answer is "the company", that's custodial, so check its licence and read what happens in insolvency. If the answer is "nobody", that's non-custodial, so check where your recovery words are.

If the answer is "I'm not sure", you've found the place to look first. Rosa found hers the day the stall closed, and the stall had kept its key.

Frequently asked questions

What is a custodial wallet?

A custodial wallet is one where a company, such as an exchange, holds the private keys for you. Your balance is the company's record of what it owes you, and every transaction needs the company to sign it.

What is a non-custodial wallet?

A non-custodial wallet, also called a self-hosted wallet, is one where you create and keep the private keys yourself. Nobody else can move or freeze your coins, and nobody else can recover them if you lose your recovery words.

What happens to my crypto if a custodial exchange goes bankrupt?

It depends on the law and on how the exchange held the coins. In the FTX bankruptcy, customers' claims were valued at prices on the petition date, 11 November 2022, and paid out in cash. In the EU, MiCA requires licensed custodians to keep clients' coins legally segregated from their own estate.

Is a non-custodial wallet safer than a custodial one?

Neither is safe by default. A non-custodial wallet removes the risk of a company failing or misusing your coins, but puts the risk of loss, theft and mistakes entirely on you. A licensed custodian reduces your own risk of losing keys but adds the risk of trusting the company.

Can I use both kinds of wallet?

Yes, and many people do. A common pattern is to buy on an exchange, keep only what you trade there, and move the rest to a wallet whose keys you hold.

Sources

  1. US Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware, In re FTX Trading Ltd., Case No. 22-11068 (JTD), Memorandum opinion and order on digital asset estimation (Judge John T. Dorsey, 26 June 2024)
  2. US Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware, In re FTX Trading Ltd., Disclosure statement for the debtors' joint Chapter 11 plan of reorganization (Doc 15521, 22 May 2024), via CourtListener
  3. FTX, FTX receives US Bankruptcy Court confirmation of its plan of reorganization (7 October 2024), via PR Newswire
  4. The Block, FTX begins initial fund distributions to customers (18 February 2025)
  5. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)
  6. ESMA, Interactive single rulebook: MiCA Article 75, Providing custody and administration of crypto-assets on behalf of clients

Read next.