How to choose a hardware wallet: five checks, and the logo isn't one of them
A hardware wallet is only as good as where it came from, the chip that guards the key, the code you can check, the backup standard it uses and how you'd recover without it. Check those five things. The brand on the box tells you none of them.
A stranger arrives at the village gate with a sack of small lock boxes. Cheaper than in the shop, he says. Already set up, to save you the trouble. Look, the seal is unbroken.
Grandma Rosa likes a bargain. But a hardware wallet isn't a toaster. It's the one object in the house that holds the key to your line in the village notebook. If the box was opened before it reached you, the key may already have a twin in the stranger's pocket.
So don't ask which brand. Ask five questions about the box in front of you. They work for any maker, and they still work after the makers change.
What it is
A hardware wallet is a small device that creates your private keys and keeps them inside. Your computer or phone prepares a payment, the device shows it on its own screen, you confirm with a button, and the device signs it. The key never leaves the box. That's the whole promise, and each check below tests a different part of it.
The five checks
1. Where did it come from?
In May 2023, Kaspersky took apart a fake Trezor bought through a classifieds website. From outside it looked genuine, holographic stickers intact. Inside, the chip had been swapped, the bootloader's checks removed, and the "random" recovery phrase replaced by one of 20 phrases preset in the firmware. The attackers simply waited for money to arrive, then moved it out (Kaspersky, 2023). Kaspersky's main advice: buy "directly from the official vendor".
Check: bought from the maker or a reseller the maker lists, never second-hand, never "pre-configured". If the box already contains a list of words, return it.
2. What guards the key inside?
Some devices store the key in a general-purpose chip. Others use a secure element, a chip built to resist physical tricks such as reading memory or disturbing the power supply.
The difference showed in January 2020. Kraken Security Labs said it could extract the encrypted recovery phrase from Trezor One and Model T devices by voltage glitching, with "15 minutes of physical access", and then brute-force a short PIN. Kraken's own advice was a BIP 39 passphrase, which "is not stored on the device" and so blocks this attack (Kraken, 2020).
Check: find out what the maker says about physical attacks and secure chips, and whether the device supports a passphrase. Physical theft is a real risk in a burglary.
3. Can anyone check the code?
The device runs firmware, and firmware decides what happens to your key. An update can change that. If the code is published, independent researchers can read it and check that what ships matches what's published. If it's closed, you are trusting the maker's word.
Open code isn't automatically safer, and closed isn't automatically worse. But one is checkable by strangers, and one isn't.
Check: is the firmware source published? Can outsiders rebuild it and compare? Does the device show you what an update changes before you install it?
4. Which backup standard does it use?
Most devices give you a BIP 39 phrase of 12 or 24 words, the same standard most software wallets read (BIP 39). Some offer SLIP-39, which splits the backup into several shares. Its authors write that it is "mainly intended as a replacement for BIP-0039" and that "for the most part, the two are not compatible" (SLIP-0039). Neither is wrong. But you should know which one you have, and which other wallets can read it.
Check: the name of the standard your device uses, and at least two other wallets, from other makers, that can restore it.
5. How would you recover without it?
Devices break, get lost and get discontinued. Your coins don't live in the device, they live in the notebook. What you need is the backup, the passphrase if you set one, and software that understands both. Our article on what happens if the wallet company dies covers this in full.
Check: can you restore your backup on a device or app from a different company? Does the device show the receiving address on its own screen, so you can compare it with the one on your computer?
Why it matters
A hardware wallet moves the risk from your laptop to a small box. That's a good trade when the box is genuine, the chip is hard to read, the code is checkable and the backup works elsewhere. Fail one of those and the device can be worse than a free app: it gives you the feeling of a vault around a key someone else already has.
Where people get it wrong
- "The seal was intact." In the Kaspersky case, so were the holographic stickers.
- "The most expensive one is the safest." Price says nothing about supply chain, firmware or backup standard. The five checks do.
- "My coins are on the device." They're in the notebook. The device holds the key, and the backup can rebuild it.
- "I'll set up a passphrase later." If you set one, write it down separately. Forget it and the wallet is gone for good.
Unbox it like a detective
When the parcel arrives, take your time. Does it come from the maker? Does the device create a fresh set of words on its own screen, in front of you? Does it ask you to install firmware from the maker's own software? Do you know which standard your words follow?
If anything arrives already written down, already set up or already "activated for you", don't use it. A hardware wallet that comes with a recovery phrase comes with a co-owner.
Frequently asked questions
Is it safe to buy a hardware wallet second-hand or from a marketplace?
It's risky. In 2023, Kaspersky examined a fake device bought through a classifieds website that looked genuine but used a preset recovery phrase. Buy from the maker or a reseller the maker lists.
What is a secure element in a hardware wallet?
A secure element is a chip designed to resist physical attacks, such as reading its memory or disturbing its power supply. Devices without one have been shown to leak keys to an attacker with physical access, as Kraken Security Labs demonstrated in 2020.
Does open-source firmware make a hardware wallet safe?
Not by itself. It means outside researchers can read the code and check it, so you don't have to rely only on the maker's word. You still need a genuine device and a good backup.
Can I restore a hardware wallet backup on another brand?
Usually, if both use the same standard, such as BIP 39. SLIP-39 share backups are mostly not compatible with BIP 39, so check which wallets can read yours before you rely on it.
Should I use a passphrase on my hardware wallet?
A passphrase adds protection if someone steals the device or your written words, because it isn't stored on the device. The price is one more thing to back up. If you forget it, nobody can recover the wallet.

