Paper wallets: still a thing? A souvenir, not a safe
A paper wallet is one private key and one address printed on paper. It was popular from about 2011 to 2016 and is now widely treated as obsolete: a website and a printer sit in the middle, the key can be photographed, and spending part of it can quietly move the rest somewhere else.
Grandma Rosa is clearing out a drawer and finds a folded sheet from years ago. On it, two square codes, a long string of letters and the words "do not share". It was a birthday present: "a bitcoin gift, keep it safe".
Rosa has kept it safe. She has also no idea what to do with it, and neither, it turns out, does most of the internet.
That sheet is a paper wallet. The honest answer to "is it still a thing?" is: as a souvenir, yes. As a place to keep savings, no. It's a key that anyone who sees it can copy, and a trap for the day you try to spend from it.
What it is
A paper wallet is a single private key and its matching address, printed on paper, usually as text and as QR codes. The address is for receiving. The private key is for spending, and whoever reads it can spend.
The Bitcoin Wiki doesn't soften it. A paper wallet is "an obsolete and unsafe method of storing bitcoin", popular between 2011 and 2016, and "This method has a large number of downsides and should not be used" (Bitcoin Wiki). It suggests recovery words, the seed phrases most wallets use today, as the better way to do the same job.
How it works: two ways a paper wallet empties
The photograph. In December 2013, a Bloomberg TV host handed two colleagues printed bitcoin gifts worth $20 each, live on air. One of them held his up to the camera long enough for the QR code to be read. A viewer scanned the private key from the broadcast and moved the $20 to an address of their own (via Entrepreneur; via Business Insider). A paper key isn't a lock. It's a password written in large print.
The change. This one is quieter, and the arithmetic explains it. A worked example:
- Rosa's paper wallet address holds 0.5 bitcoin.
- She types the private key into a wallet app and sends 0.1 bitcoin to Anna.
- Bitcoin doesn't spend part of a coin. The transaction uses the whole 0.5 as input: 0.1 goes to Anna, a small fee goes to the miner, and the rest, a little under 0.4, goes back as change.
- Many wallets send that change to a new address of their own, not back to the paper.
- Rosa looks up her paper address. It shows zero.
The money isn't lost, yet. It's in the app, under keys the app made. If Rosa deletes the app, believing the paper is her backup, it's gone. The Wiki describes exactly this: people "mistakenly believe the remaining funds are still on the paper wallet when in reality they are in a change address" (Bitcoin Wiki).
Why it fell out of use
- The website. Most paper wallets were made on websites. If the site, the browser or the computer was compromised, the key was known before the ink dried.
- The printer. The Wiki points out that printers often store what they print, and shared or Wi-Fi printers add more ears.
- One address. A paper wallet has one address, so every payment to it is linked in public. That's the address reuse problem covered in "Bitcoin addresses explained".
- The fix that came late. BIP 38, assigned in November 2012, added a passphrase to protect printed keys, "intended for use on paper wallets" (BIP 38). It helps against the photograph. It does nothing about the change, and it adds a passphrase you can forget.
Where people get it wrong
- "Paper can't be hacked." The computer that made it could be. The camera that sees it can copy it.
- "I'll spend a little and keep the rest on the paper." The rest usually leaves the paper in the same transaction.
- "The QR code is just the address." Usually there are two. One is safe to share, one empties the wallet.
- "A paper wallet is the same as writing down my recovery words." Recovery words recreate a whole modern wallet. A paper wallet is one bare key.
If you find one in a drawer
Don't photograph it, don't post it, and don't spend part of it. Set up a modern wallet first and write down its recovery words. Then use the wallet's "sweep" option, which the Wiki calls "the best way to redeem the bitcoins from a private key": it moves the whole balance from the paper key into your new wallet in one go. After that, the paper is just paper.
Keep it if you like. It makes a lovely souvenir, as long as it's empty.
Frequently asked questions
What is a paper wallet?
A paper wallet is a private key and its matching address printed on paper, often as QR codes. Anyone who sees or copies the private key can spend the coins, and the method is widely considered obsolete.
Are paper wallets safe?
Not by modern standards. The key is often created on a website, can be stored by printers, can be photographed, and partial spending can move the remaining balance to a change address elsewhere. Seed phrase wallets do the same job with fewer traps.
How do I get bitcoin out of an old paper wallet?
Set up a modern wallet, write down its recovery words, and use its sweep function to move the entire balance from the paper key into the new wallet in one transaction. Don't spend only part of it, and don't share images of the paper.
Why did my paper wallet show zero after I spent some of it?
Because the transaction spent the whole balance and sent the leftover to a change address, usually one that belongs to the wallet app you used. The coins are in that app, so don't delete it until you have moved them somewhere safe.
What is BIP 38?
BIP 38 is a standard from 2012 for encrypting a private key with a passphrase, designed for paper wallets. A thief who copies the printed key also needs the passphrase, but if you forget the passphrase, you can't spend the coins either.
Sources
- Bitcoin Wiki, Paper wallet
- Mike Caldwell and Aaron Voisine, BIP 38: Passphrase-protected private key
- Entrepreneur, Lesson learned: TV anchor shows off bitcoin, is instantly robbed (23 December 2013)
- Business Insider, A Bloomberg TV host gifted bitcoin on air and it immediately got stolen (December 2013)

