Level 1 · Start hereThe village#033

What gives a coin its value? Whatever the next person will give you for it, and why

A coin is worth what other people will pay for it. That willingness rests on different things for different coins: a promise to redeem, a use you can't get otherwise, a fixed supply that people believe in, or nothing at all.

Ben has started his own notebook. He calls it Bencoin. On the first page he writes, in large letters: "One Bencoin is worth ten loaves of bread."

He walks into Anna's bakery with five Bencoin and asks for fifty loaves. Anna reads the page, looks at Ben, and asks him to pay in village coins like everyone else. Ben points at the page. "It says ten loaves!" "It says that because you wrote it," says Anna.

Grandma Rosa, buying rolls, asks the right question. "So why is a village coin worth a loaf, when Bencoin isn't?" The answer is the whole article: a coin is worth what someone else will give you for it. Writing a number on the first page doesn't make anyone give it.

What it is

The value of a coin is its price: what buyers will pay at a given moment. Nothing in a coin's software sets that price. The code sets the rules, the supply and who owns what. People set the price.

So the useful question isn't "what is it worth?" It's "why would the next person want it?" For crypto, there are a handful of honest answers, and one dishonest one.

How it works: four coins, four reasons

Take four real examples and ask what each one's value rests on.

  1. A claim on someone: USDC. A dollar stablecoin is worth about a dollar because an issuer promises to swap it for one. Circle's own notice states that holders of e-money tokens "have the right of redemption against the issuer at any time and at par value" (Circle, 2024). Its value is borrowed from the dollar and rests on the issuer keeping its word. Like a voucher from an honest miller.
  2. A use you can't get otherwise: ether. Anyone who wants to run a program or move a token on Ethereum must pay for it, and "Gas fees have to be paid in Ethereum's native currency, ether (ETH)" (ethereum.org). Part of ether's demand comes from that. It's like the only coin the village ferry accepts. How much the ferry is worth to people is a separate question.
  3. A fixed supply people believe in: bitcoin. Bitcoin's code allows no amount above 21 million coins, and its own comment notes the actual supply will be slightly less (Bitcoin Core). Nobody can write extra. But scarcity alone creates nothing. Plenty of things are rare and worthless. Bitcoin's price rests on scarcity plus enough people trusting the network and wanting to hold it.
  4. Nothing but the first page: OneCoin. OneCoin claimed to be a cryptocurrency. According to US prosecutors, it "lacked a true blockchain", and the company "arbitrarily set the value of the coin without regard to market forces". More than 3.5 million victims put in over $4 billion. On 12 September 2023, co-founder Karl Sebastian Greenwood was sentenced to 20 years in prison (US Attorney SDNY, 2023). That was Bencoin, sold to millions.

Notice the pattern. Each value rests on a reason someone else wants the coin, and each reason can fail in its own way. Remove the reason and only the first page is left.

The other ingredients

  • The network effect. A coin that many people accept is more useful, which makes more people accept it. The village coin is worth a loaf partly because the whole village takes it.
  • Liquidity. If you can sell a coin quickly without moving its price, it's worth more to you than one nobody is buying.
  • Speculation. Many buyers want a coin only because they expect someone else to pay more later. The SEC's staff said of meme coins in February 2025 that they "typically have limited or no use or functionality" (SEC staff statement). For those, belief about the next buyer is most of the value.

Why it matters

  • Value can vanish. If the reason goes, so does the price. EU regulators warned in March 2022 that consumers face "the very real possibility of losing all their invested money" (ESMA, EBA and EIOPA, 2022).
  • Different coins carry different risks. A stablecoin's risk sits with its issuer. A platform coin's risk sits with its use. A scarce coin's risk sits with belief.
  • Price isn't proof. A number on a screen shows what the last buyer paid, not that the coin is sound.

Where people get it wrong

  • "It has value because it's on a blockchain." The blockchain records ownership. It doesn't create demand.
  • "It's scarce, so it'll be valuable." Scarce and wanted is valuable. Scarce and unwanted is clutter.
  • "Crypto has no value because there's nothing behind it." Some coins have a claim behind them, some a use, some only belief. Treat them differently.
  • "The company says it's worth X." That's the OneCoin model. The market decides, not the man with the pen.

Ask why the next person wants it

Before you buy any coin, finish this sentence: "Someone will want this from me later because..." If you can say "they can redeem it", "they need it to use the network" or "they trust its supply", you've found its foundation and its risk.

If the only ending is "because it'll go up", you're holding Bencoin. And Anna still won't take it for bread.

Frequently asked questions

What gives cryptocurrency its value?

The price people are willing to pay for it. That willingness can rest on a claim to redeem it for money, a use inside a network, a limited supply that people trust, or simply speculation. Nothing in the code sets the price.

Why is bitcoin valuable?

Bitcoin's supply is capped by its software at 21 million coins and no one can create more at will. Its price depends on enough people trusting the network and wanting to hold it. Scarcity alone wouldn't be enough.

Why is ether valuable?

Ether is needed to pay gas fees on Ethereum, so anyone using the network needs some. That creates demand for it. Its price also depends on how much people want to use Ethereum and on speculation.

Why are stablecoins worth one dollar?

Because their issuer promises to redeem them at par. Circle states that holders of its e-money tokens, such as USDC, can redeem them against the issuer at any time at par value. The value holds only as long as the issuer can keep that promise.

Can a coin's value go to zero?

Yes. If the reason people want a coin disappears, its price can collapse. EU regulators warned in March 2022 that consumers face the very real possibility of losing all their invested money in crypto-assets.

What was OneCoin?

OneCoin was sold as a cryptocurrency but, according to US prosecutors, had no true public blockchain and its value was set by the company. More than 3.5 million victims invested over $4 billion. Co-founder Karl Sebastian Greenwood was sentenced to 20 years in prison in September 2023.

Sources

  1. Circle, Circle is first global stablecoin issuer to comply with MiCA, EU's landmark crypto law (1 July 2024)
  2. ethereum.org, Gas and fees
  3. Bitcoin Core, src/consensus/amount.h (MAX_MONEY)
  4. US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, Co-founder of multibillion-dollar cryptocurrency scheme OneCoin sentenced to 20 years in prison (12 September 2023)
  5. US SEC, Division of Corporation Finance, Staff statement on meme coins (27 February 2025)
  6. ESMA, EBA and EIOPA, EU financial regulators warn consumers on the risks of crypto-assets (17 March 2022)

Read next.