Level 2 · First stepsThe gold rush#131

Proof of reserves explained: the assay office weighs the gold, not the IOUs

Proof of reserves is an exchange showing, on one day, that it controls at least as many coins as it owes its customers, and letting each customer check their balance was counted. It's useful. It's not an audit, and it can't show debts the exchange keeps elsewhere.

Every boomtown needed an assay office: someone who weighed the gold and said what it was worth. When people started to wonder whether the general store really had their gold in its safe, the obvious move was to call the assayer.

He opens the safe, weighs what's inside, and writes it down. That's worth something. But he weighs the gold, not the IOUs. He can't tell you what the shopkeeper owes the bank across the street, or whether half the bars were borrowed for the afternoon.

That's proof of reserves in one picture. It shows the gold on the day of the visit. It can't show the debts.

What it is

Proof of reserves is a check that an exchange holds at least as many coins as its customers' balances add up to. It has two halves.

The safe. The exchange shows which blockchain addresses it controls, usually by signing messages with their keys. Anyone can then read the balances of those addresses on the public blockchain.

The book. The exchange takes a snapshot of every customer's balance, turns each one into a hash, and combines them step by step into a single number, the Merkle root. Each customer gets a short proof that their own balance was part of that root, without seeing anyone else's.

Divide the safe by the book and you get a reserve ratio. 100% means one coin in the safe for every coin owed.

How it works: one exchange's report

Kraken publishes such reports. On its proof-of-reserves page, read on 19 November 2026, the snapshot date was 30 September 2026. The reserve ratios listed included bitcoin at 103.2% and ether at 100.7% (Kraken). We use it as an example of the method, not as a recommendation.

In plain numbers: for every 1,000 bitcoin Kraken owed clients in that snapshot, about 1,032 sat at addresses it showed it controlled. For ether, 1,007 for every 1,000.

The page says an "independent 3rd party accountant" builds the Merkle tree from anonymised client balances. Customers can sign in and check that their own balance was included, and Kraken offers an open-source tool to verify the proof (Kraken, 2025).

The idea is older than most exchanges. In 2011, Mt. Gox, then the largest bitcoin exchange, "proved that they had funds by sending a transaction that moved 424242 BTC" to an address it had announced in advance (Buterin, 2022). Three years later it collapsed. Our article on Mt. Gox tells that story.

Why it matters

Proof of reserves answers the Mt. Gox question, "are the coins in the safe?", for one day. That's better than a promise. But look at what the exchange itself lists under "shortcomings" on the same page. The review cannot prove "exclusive possession of private keys", it "cannot identify any hidden encumbrances or prove that funds had not been borrowed", and keys may have been lost or funds stolen since the last review.

Read that again: an exchange telling you, honestly, what its own report can't do.

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin pointed to the same hole in November 2022: "Shuttling collateral back and forth between each other to do proof of reserves is something that exchanges could easily do", which "would allow them to pretend to be solvent when they actually are not" (Buterin, 2022).

The US audit regulator, the PCAOB, went further on 8 March 2023. It warned that proof-of-reserve engagements "are not audits", that the reports "do not provide any meaningful assurance", and that the procedures "likely do not address the crypto entity's liabilities" (PCAOB, 2023).

In the EU, MiCA doesn't use the term. It requires licensed custodians to keep clients' coins separate "on the distributed ledger" from their own, to keep a register of each client's positions, and to send clients a statement "at least once every three months" (EUR-Lex; readable version in ESMA's single rulebook). That's a rule with a supervisor behind it, not a snapshot the company chooses to publish.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Proof of reserves is an audit." The PCAOB says it isn't, and the exchange's own fine print agrees.
  • "Over 100% means the exchange is solvent." It means the coins covered the customer balances on one day. Loans, lawsuits and other debts aren't in the picture.
  • "My balance is in the tree, so my coins are safe." It means you were counted. Not that the coins can't leave tomorrow.
  • "They published one, so they're fine." A snapshot ages. Check the date.
  • "All my coins were checked." Reports cover a list of assets. If your coin isn't on it, it wasn't weighed.

Read the date, the list and the fine print

If your exchange publishes proof of reserves, do three checks. Find the snapshot date. Find your coin in the list of assets covered. Then use the verification tool to confirm your own balance was in the tree, and read the section on limitations.

If there's no report, ask why. If there's one with no limitations section, ask why louder.

The assay office can tell you there was gold in the safe on 30 September. It can't tell you who the shopkeeper owed on 1 October.

Frequently asked questions

What is proof of reserves?

A check in which an exchange shows that the coins at addresses it controls are at least equal to the total of its customers' balances at one point in time. Customers can usually verify that their own balance was included, using a cryptographic proof based on a Merkle tree.

Is proof of reserves the same as an audit?

No. The US audit regulator, the PCAOB, warned in March 2023 that proof-of-reserve engagements are not audits and do not provide meaningful assurance. They usually don't examine the company's debts or its wider finances.

What does a reserve ratio of 103% mean?

That on the snapshot date the exchange controlled about 103 coins for every 100 it owed customers in that asset. It says nothing about other debts, about coins borrowed for the day, or about what happened after the snapshot.

How can I check my balance in a proof of reserves?

Exchanges that publish proof of reserves usually let you sign in and see a proof that links your balance to the published Merkle root. Some also offer an open-source tool to verify it yourself. Check that the snapshot date and the coins covered match what you hold.

Does MiCA require proof of reserves?

MiCA doesn't require a public proof of reserves. It requires licensed custodians to keep clients' coins separate from their own on the blockchain, keep a register of each client's positions and send clients a statement at least every three months, under the supervision of a national authority.

Sources

  1. Kraken, Proof of reserves (snapshot of 30 September 2026, read on 19 November 2026)
  2. Kraken, Proof of reserves June 30 2025 (blog, 30 July 2025)
  3. Vitalik Buterin, Having a safe CEX: proof of solvency and beyond (19 November 2022)
  4. PCAOB, Investor advisory: Exercise caution with third-party verification/proof of reserve reports (8 March 2023)
  5. EUR-Lex, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA)
  6. ESMA, Interactive single rulebook: MiCA Article 75, Providing custody and administration of crypto-assets on behalf of clients

Read next.