Why mining moves between countries: miners follow cheap power, the sheriff sets the clock
Bitcoin mining goes where electricity is cheap and the rules allow it. China held about three quarters of the hash rate in 2019 until its government ordered mining shut down in 2021; the machines moved, mostly to the United States and Kazakhstan, and some stayed hidden.
Gold rush camps never stayed put. When a creek ran dry, or the law turned against the diggers, the camp packed up overnight and the tents went up somewhere else.
Bitcoin miners behave the same way, with one difference: they aren't chasing gold, they are chasing electricity. Mining machines earn the same per terahash everywhere on earth, so the only thing that differs from place to place is what the power costs, and whether the local sheriff lets you plug in.
The clearest example happened in 2021. The country that hosted most of the world's mining told its miners to leave. Within weeks, a large part of the network's machines went dark, then switched back on in other countries.
What it is
Mining is unusually easy to move. A miner needs power, cooling, an internet connection and permission. It doesn't need customers nearby, because the product, a valid block, travels around the world in seconds.
So mining follows two things. Cheap electricity, often power that nobody else nearby wants. And friendly rules, which can change faster than a power contract. When either changes, the machines are unplugged, put in containers and shipped.
How it works: China, 2019 to 2022, step by step
- September 2019. The Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, which estimates mining locations from data shared by several large pools, put China's share of Bitcoin's hash rate at 75.5% (Cambridge, 2021).
- April 2021. Before any ban, China's share had already fallen to 46%. The United States had 16.8%, Kazakhstan 8.2% (Cambridge, 2021).
- 21 May 2021. A meeting of the State Council's Financial Stability and Development Committee called for a crackdown on "比特币挖矿和交易行为", Bitcoin mining and trading (gov.cn).
- 3 July 2021. The network felt it. At block 689,472, difficulty fell from 19,932,791,027,263 to 14,363,025,673,660, a drop of 27.9% in one retarget (mempool.space). Blocks had been coming slowly because so many machines were switched off. In hash rate terms, the difficulty went from about 143 to about 103 EH/s at ten-minute blocks.
- 3 September 2021. The National Development and Reform Commission and ten other departments issued a notice to "严禁新增虚拟货币'挖矿'项目,加快存量项目有序退出": strictly prohibit new mining projects and speed up the orderly exit of existing ones (NDRC). The reason given: mining's energy use and carbon emissions are high and its contribution to the economy is low.
- 15 September 2021. The People's Bank of China and nine other bodies declared that "虚拟货币相关业务活动属于非法金融活动": virtual currency business activities are illegal financial activities (gov.cn).
- September 2021 to January 2022. The machines reappeared elsewhere, and some never left. Cambridge found China's reported hash rate "effectively plummeted to zero" in July and August 2021, then reappeared at 22.29% in September 2021. In January 2022, the United States led with 37.84% and Kazakhstan had 13.22% (Cambridge, 2022). Cambridge pointed to underground mining, and to miners hiding their location behind VPNs, which its pool-based method can't see through.
The network itself barely noticed in the long run. The difficulty at block 975,744 on 14 November 2026 was about 9.4 times that of July 2021.
Why it matters
- Decentralisation is geographic too. One country holding three quarters of the mining is one government away from a shock. 2021 showed what that shock looks like, and that the network survives it.
- Power prices set the map. Machines are the same everywhere. Cheap power, often stranded or surplus power, decides where they sit. "Mining and energy: where the power comes from" looks at what that power is.
- Rules move faster than miners. A power plant takes years to build. A ban takes a meeting.
- Who pays. The miners who moved paid for shipping, new sites and months of idle machines. The ones who stayed in place gained a bigger share of blocks while difficulty was low.
Where people get it wrong
- "China's ban ended Chinese mining." Cambridge's data showed a large share reappearing within months, though its numbers may be distorted by VPNs.
- "The ban broke Bitcoin." Blocks slowed, then the difficulty adjustment did what it was built for and cut the difficulty by 27.9%.
- "The US now holds 75% of mining." Cambridge's April 2025 industry report found 75.4% of its surveyed firms' activity in the United States, and warned that strong participation by US firms "likely has led to the country's share being overstated" (Cambridge, 2025). It is a survey of 49 firms, not a census.
- "Mining location data is precise." All of it is estimated, from pool data or surveys. Miners have every reason to be discreet.
Watch the sheriff, not the saloon
When you read that a country "welcomes" or "bans" mining, find the government's own text. The 2021 Chinese notices are public, dated and short. A minister's interview or an influencer's thread is not a rule.
The saloon announces every new mining paradise. The sheriff decides how long it lasts.
Frequently asked questions
Why does Bitcoin mining move between countries?
Because mining earns the same per hash everywhere, so profit depends mostly on electricity costs and on whether the rules allow it. When power gets more expensive or a government turns against mining, miners ship their machines somewhere cheaper or friendlier.
When did China ban Bitcoin mining?
The State Council's Financial Stability and Development Committee called for a crackdown on 21 May 2021. On 3 September 2021, the National Development and Reform Commission and ten other departments ordered a ban on new mining projects and an orderly exit of existing ones.
How much Bitcoin mining was in China before the ban?
The Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance estimated China's share at 75.5% in September 2019 and 46% in April 2021, based on data from several mining pools.
Where did the miners go after China's ban?
Cambridge's data for January 2022 put the United States first with 37.84% of hash rate and Kazakhstan at 13.22%. China reappeared at about 21% for September 2021 to January 2022, which suggests some miners stayed in hiding.
Did China's mining ban affect the Bitcoin network?
Blocks slowed in mid-2021 as machines were switched off, and on 3 July 2021, at block 689,472, the difficulty fell by 27.9% in a single adjustment. That made blocks easier to find for the miners still running, as the rule is designed to do.
Sources
- Cambridge Judge Business School, New data reveals timeline of China's bitcoin mining exodus (15 July 2021)
- Government of the People's Republic of China, Financial Stability and Development Committee, 51st meeting (21 May 2021)
- NDRC and ten other departments, Notice on rectifying virtual currency mining, Fagai Yunxing [2021] No. 1283 (3 September 2021)
- People's Bank of China and nine other bodies, Notice on further preventing and handling the risks of virtual currency trading speculation, Yinfa [2021] No. 237 (15 September 2021)
- mempool.space API, blocks 689,458 to 689,472 (3 July 2021)
- Cambridge Judge Business School, Bitcoin mining: new data reveal a surprising resurgence (17 May 2022)
- Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, Cambridge Digital Mining Industry Report (April 2025)

