Barter: why goats made bad currency, and why nobody really used them
Swapping goods directly only works when both sides want exactly what the other has, at the same moment. That rarely happens, which is why the textbook 'barter economy' may never have existed.
Ben has a goat. Ben wants a loaf of bread. Anna has bread, and Anna doesn't want a goat.
Even if she did, a goat is worth about forty loaves. Anna can't give Ben thirty-nine loaves of change, and Ben can't saw off one fortieth of a goat. Good luck, Ben.
That's barter: swapping goods directly, without money. It sounds simple. In practice it fails at the first awkward question, and the questions are always awkward.
What it is
Barter is trading one thing for another thing. No coins, no notes, no account. My eggs for your milk.
The economist William Stanley Jevons named its central problem in 1875. For a swap to happen, each person must want exactly what the other has. "There must be a double coincidence, which will rarely happen," he wrote (Jevons, 1875). Everything else wrong with barter follows from that.
How it works (and doesn't)
Jevons had a favourite example. A singer, Mademoiselle Zélie, gave a concert in the Society Islands in the Pacific, for a third of the takings. There was hardly any money on the island, so her share was paid in kind: three pigs, twenty-three turkeys, forty-four chickens and five thousand coconuts, plus bananas, lemons and oranges (Jevons, 1875).
A fine fee, on paper. But she couldn't eat it, couldn't carry it home and couldn't sell it fast enough. According to Jevons, much of the fruit ended up feeding the pigs and chickens.
Her problem had four parts, and every barter deal has them:
- Matching. You need someone who has what you want and wants what you have. In a village of fifty houses, that's a lot of knocking on doors.
- Splitting. A goat doesn't come in small change. Neither does a cow or a boat.
- Keeping. Turkeys must be fed. Bananas go brown. Wealth that rots isn't much of a savings plan.
- Pricing. With no common unit, every good needs a price in every other good. With 100 goods in the market, that's 4,950 separate exchange rates to remember. With money, it's 100 prices.
Fix all four and you have invented money.
The twist: the barter village probably never existed
Adam Smith told the classic story in 1776. A butcher has more meat than he can eat. The brewer and the baker would like some, but have nothing he wants. "No exchange can, in this case, be made between them," Smith wrote (Smith, 1776). So, the story goes, people picked a common good, and money was born.
It's a neat story. Anthropologists went looking for it and didn't find it. In 1985 the Cambridge anthropologist Caroline Humphrey wrote that "no example of a barter economy, pure and simple, has ever been described, let alone the emergence from it of money" (Humphrey, 1985).
What people did instead was keep track. Anna gives Ben bread, and Ben owes her. The village remembers, or writes it down. In other words: credit came first, a notebook of who owes whom. That's the same notebook from our first article.
Barter does turn up, but mostly where money has broken down or where people don't trust each other. Humphrey found it among strangers, and in economies cut off from money.
When barter comes back
The best-documented case happened in a prisoner-of-war camp in the Second World War. The economist R. A. Radford was a prisoner and wrote it up in 1945. Food and cigarettes arrived in Red Cross parcels, and prisoners swapped them. Within a short time, barter gave way to something better.
"The cigarette became the standard of value," Radford wrote (Radford, 1945). Even non-smokers sold for cigarettes, because everyone else accepted them. A cup of coffee cost two cigarettes. Laundry cost two cigarettes a garment.
Nobody decreed it. Cigarettes were easy to count, easy to carry, came in small units and everyone wanted them. When the parcels stopped, cigarettes ran short, prices fell and trade slid back towards barter. The money had a supply problem.
Why it matters
Barter is the background to every argument about money, including crypto.
- Money solves a coordination problem. It's not a luxury. It's what lets strangers trade without a matching wish list.
- Whatever becomes money needs certain properties. Easy to split, easy to carry, hard to fake, doesn't rot, and limited in supply. Goats fail most of these. Cigarettes passed most of them, for a while.
- Bitcoin was designed against this checklist. Divisible into tiny units, weightless, hard to fake, a fixed supply. Whether that makes it good money is a different question.
Where people get it wrong
- "Before money, everyone bartered." The evidence says otherwise. Credit and shared records came first.
- "Barter is fairer than money." It's slower and wastes more. Somebody always ends up with the brown bananas.
- "Barter disappeared." It returns whenever money fails: in prison camps, in crises, among people who don't trust each other's money.
- "Anything rare can be money." Rare isn't enough. It must also be easy to split, easy to check and widely accepted.
The goat test
Next time someone tells you a new token is "the future of money", run the goat test. Can you split it into small change? Can you check it's real without an expert? Will it keep for a year? Will the baker take it?
A goat fails three out of four. Plenty of coins sold by strangers at the gate fail all four.
Frequently asked questions
What is barter?
Barter is the direct exchange of goods or services without money, for example eggs for milk. It needs both sides to want exactly what the other has, which economists call the double coincidence of wants.
What is the double coincidence of wants?
It's the condition that each person in a trade must want what the other person offers, at the same time. The economist W. S. Jevons described it in 1875 as the main difficulty of barter.
Did people really use barter before money?
There's little evidence for whole economies run on barter. In 1985 the anthropologist Caroline Humphrey wrote that no pure barter economy had ever been described. Communities more often relied on credit and shared records of who owed what.
When do people go back to barter?
When money stops working or isn't trusted. In a Second World War prisoner-of-war camp, prisoners first bartered Red Cross goods, then started using cigarettes as currency, as R. A. Radford recorded in 1945.
What makes something good money?
It should be easy to divide, carry and check, should keep its value, and should be widely accepted. Goats fail most of these tests, which is why they never made good currency.
Sources
- W. Stanley Jevons, Money and the Mechanism of Exchange (1875), chapter 1, via Library of Economics and Liberty
- Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations (1776), book 1, chapter 4, via Library of Economics and Liberty
- Caroline Humphrey, Barter and Economic Disintegration, Man, Vol. 20, No. 1 (March 1985), via JSTOR
- R. A. Radford, The Economic Organisation of a P.O.W. Camp, Economica (November 1945)

