Level 1 · Start hereThe village#010

Why trust is the real currency: every notebook runs on belief

Every form of money depends on trust: that the keeper is honest, that the next person will accept it, that your balance is really there. When trust goes, money goes with it, often within hours.

Anna has never looked inside the keeper's notebook. Neither has Ben, and Grandma Rosa can't read his handwriting anyway. They all simply believe the numbers are right.

That belief does all the work. Anna bakes because she trusts the line she'll get in return. Ben accepts that line because he trusts the miller will take it. The keeper's pen is nothing without the village's faith in it.

The day the village stops believing, the notebook is just paper. Gold, notes, bank balances, crypto: different notebooks, same rule. Trust is the real currency. Everything else is bookkeeping.

What it is

Every payment is a bet that someone else will honour a promise. Your bank promises to pay out your balance. The central bank promises to keep prices fairly stable. The next shop promises, by habit, to accept your money.

The Bank of England puts it in one line: money is "a social institution that provides a solution to the problem of a lack of trust" (Bank of England, 2014). In a village of strangers, money is how you trade with people you have no reason to trust.

How it works: how fast trust can leave

Take Silicon Valley Bank, a large US bank, in March 2023. It hadn't been robbed. Its notebook still showed the money. What it lost was belief.

  1. The weak spot. About 94% of its deposits were uninsured at the end of 2022 (Federal Reserve, 2023). Its customers knew that if the bank failed, most of their money had no guarantee.
  2. The spark. Worried customers started talking to each other, many of them online.
  3. The run. On 9 March 2023, customers pulled out over $40 billion in a single day. The bank expected more than $100 billion more to leave on 10 March.
  4. The end. Regulators closed the bank on the morning of 10 March 2023.

The Federal Reserve's own review said the run "appears to have been fueled by social media" and that depositors withdrew "with unprecedented speed" (Federal Reserve, 2023). In the village, rumours spread at the well. In 2023 they spread at the speed of a group chat.

Compare that with the run on Northern Rock in September 2007, when people queued outside branches (House of Commons, 2008). Same panic. Different speed.

How the system props up trust

Because trust can vanish this fast, the old money system has built supports around it:

  • Deposit guarantees. Under EU rules, €100,000 per depositor is guaranteed through national schemes if a bank fails (ECB). Grandma Rosa doesn't need to queue at dawn.
  • Supervisors. Someone checks the keeper's books, at least in theory.
  • Central banks. They can lend to a solvent bank caught in a panic.

These supports don't remove the need for trust. They move it: from your local keeper to the state behind him.

Crypto doesn't escape trust either

Bitcoin's founding paper names the problem in its first lines. Online payments, it says, rely on "a trusted third party", and it proposes "an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust" (Nakamoto, 2008). Every house keeps a copy of the notebook, and anyone can check it.

That removes one kind of trust. It doesn't remove all of it. You still trust that the software does what it says, that you won't lose your keys, and, above all, that any company holding your coins for you is honest.

FTX shows what that last kind of trust can cost. Its founder, Samuel Bankman-Fried, was sentenced to 25 years in prison on 28 March 2024. US prosecutors said he stole over $8 billion of his customers' money (US Attorney SDNY, 2024). The customers had trusted a person, not a proof.

Why it matters

  • No money is trust-free. You can only choose whom, or what, you trust.
  • Guarantees are part of the price. A bank account comes with a state guarantee up to a limit. A coin left on an unregulated platform comes with none.
  • Speed cuts both ways. Digital money moves in seconds. So does panic.

Where people get it wrong

  • "My money is safe because it's in a bank." Up to the guarantee limit, in the EU €100,000 per depositor. Above that, you trust the bank.
  • "Crypto is trustless." It replaces trust in a keeper with trust in code, in your own key handling, and often in an exchange.
  • "A bank run needs queues." SVB lost over $40 billion in a day without one.
  • "Big means safe." SVB and FTX were both large and well known shortly before they failed.

The three-question trust check

Before you hand anyone your money, a bank, an app or an exchange, ask three questions. Who checks this keeper's books? What protects me if the keeper fails? Can I check anything myself?

If the answers are "nobody", "nothing" and "no", you're not trusting a system. You're trusting a stranger at the gate with a nice website.

Frequently asked questions

Why is trust important for money?

Money only works if people expect others to accept it and believe the institutions behind it will keep their promises. When that expectation fails, people rush to withdraw or switch, and the money or the bank can collapse.

What is a bank run?

A bank run is when many customers try to withdraw their money at once because they fear the bank will fail. In March 2023, Silicon Valley Bank customers withdrew over $40 billion in one day, and the bank was closed the next morning.

How much of my bank deposit is protected in the EU?

Under EU rules, national deposit guarantee schemes cover up to €100,000 per depositor if a bank fails. Amounts above that are not guaranteed.

Is crypto really trustless?

Not completely. Bitcoin lets anyone check the shared record instead of trusting one keeper. But users still trust the software, their own handling of keys, and any exchange that holds coins for them.

What happened to FTX customers?

FTX's founder, Samuel Bankman-Fried, was sentenced to 25 years in prison on 28 March 2024, and US prosecutors said he stole over $8 billion of customers' money.

Sources

  1. Bank of England, Money in the modern economy: an introduction (Quarterly Bulletin 2014 Q1)
  2. Federal Reserve, Review of the supervision and regulation of Silicon Valley Bank: Evolution of Silicon Valley Bank (April 2023)
  3. European Central Bank, What is a deposit guarantee scheme?
  4. US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, Samuel Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years in prison (28 March 2024)
  5. UK House of Commons Treasury Committee, The run on the Rock (Fifth Report of Session 2007-08)
  6. Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A peer-to-peer electronic cash system (2008)

Read next.