Level 1 · Start hereThe village#009

The 2008 financial crisis in 5 minutes: when the notebooks lied

Banks lent to people who couldn't repay, sold those loans on in bundles, and borrowed heavily to buy more. When house prices fell, the lines in their books turned out to be worth far less than claimed, and governments had to rescue them.

Ben wants a big house. Ben has no savings and an unsteady job. In a sensible village, the notebook keeper says no.

But this keeper doesn't plan to keep the line "Ben owes me". He bundles it with a hundred others like it and sells the bundle to a keeper in the next village, who borrows heavily to buy more bundles. Everyone gets paid a fee. Nobody checks whether Ben can pay.

Then house prices stop rising. Ben stops paying. And every keeper discovers that half the lines in his book are worth nothing. That was 2008.

What it is

The 2008 financial crisis was a collapse of trust in banks' books. It started in the US housing market, spread through the global banking system, and caused the deepest recession in decades.

The US recession ran from December 2007 to June 2009. Output fell 4.3% from peak to trough, and unemployment rose from under 5% to 10% (Federal Reserve History). The official US inquiry put it bluntly: "We conclude this financial crisis was avoidable" (FCIC, 2011).

How it works: the crash in five steps

  1. House prices rose and rose. Nationally, US home prices more than doubled between 1998 and 2006 (Federal Reserve History). Everyone assumed they always would.
  2. Lending got careless. If prices only go up, a borrower who can't pay can always sell. So lenders wrote mortgages for people with weak incomes, often called subprime loans.
  3. Loans were bundled and sold. Banks packaged thousands of mortgages into securities and sold them around the world. The lender no longer cared much whether the loan was repaid. The buyer often didn't know what was inside.
  4. Everyone borrowed to buy more. Banks financed these holdings with large amounts of short-term debt. That's leverage: a small fall in value wipes out a bank's own capital.
  5. Prices fell. From early 2007 to mid-2011, US home prices dropped by over a fifth. Borrowers defaulted, the bundles lost value, and nobody could tell which bank was holding the worst of them.

Then the trust ran out. In the UK, the support deal for Northern Rock was announced on 14 September 2007, and long queues formed outside its branches that same day. A parliamentary committee called it the first bank run in the UK "since Victorian times" (House of Commons, 2008).

In the US, Bear Stearns was taken over in spring 2008 with Federal Reserve help. In September 2008, Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy, and the next day the Fed stepped in to support the insurer AIG (Federal Reserve History). Banks stopped lending to each other, because none of them trusted the others' books.

Who paid

Governments stepped in. On 3 October 2008, the US enacted a law that authorised $700 billion for the Troubled Asset Relief Program, later reduced to $475 billion (Congressional Research Service, 2014). Central banks cut rates close to zero and lent on a large scale.

Some of the bank rescue money came back with interest. Much of the damage didn't. The US inquiry counted about four million families who had lost their homes to foreclosure (FCIC, 2011). People who had never bought a mortgage bundle lost their jobs anyway.

Why it matters

  • Banks are only as good as their books. When nobody trusts the numbers, money stops moving, even between banks.
  • Losses were shared out, gains weren't. Bankers kept the fees from the boom. Taxpayers and workers carried much of the bust.
  • It shaped a generation of rules. Higher capital requirements and closer supervision came out of 2008.
  • It shaped crypto. On 3 January 2009, the first block of Bitcoin was created. Its creator wrote a newspaper headline into it: "The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks" (mempool.space). Anyone can still read it in the public record. It wasn't decoration.

Where people get it wrong

  • "It was just greedy bankers." Greed played its part. So did regulators, rating agencies, politicians and borrowers who all assumed prices would keep rising.
  • "It only hit Americans." The bundles were sold worldwide. European banks held plenty, and the UK had its first bank run in over a century.
  • "The bailouts cost nothing because the money was repaid." Some programmes made money. Others, along with the recession, the lost homes and the lost jobs, cost a great deal.
  • "Crypto would have prevented it." Crypto can't stop people lending recklessly or buying things they don't understand. It has its own collapses, as later articles show.

Ask what's in the bundle

The lesson of 2008 fits on a sticky note: if you can't see what's inside something, and the seller makes money whether it works or not, be careful.

That applies to a mortgage bundle in 2006. It applies just as well to a "yield product" offered by the stranger at the gate, who promises returns and won't say where they come from.

Frequently asked questions

What caused the 2008 financial crisis?

A housing bubble in the US, careless mortgage lending, the bundling and resale of those loans worldwide, and banks borrowing heavily to hold them. When house prices fell, the losses spread through the banking system and trust collapsed.

When was the 2008 financial crisis?

Problems began in 2007, with the run on Northern Rock in the UK in September 2007. The worst came in September 2008, when Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy. The US recession lasted from December 2007 to June 2009.

How much did the US bank bailout cost?

The Troubled Asset Relief Program was authorised at $700 billion in October 2008, later cut to $475 billion. The Congressional Research Service reported in 2014 that some parts made a profit while others, including support for AIG, car makers and housing, made losses.

Was the 2008 crisis avoidable?

The official US Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission concluded in 2011 that it was. It blamed failures in regulation, risk management and corporate governance, among other things.

What does the 2008 crisis have to do with Bitcoin?

Bitcoin's first block, created on 3 January 2009, contains a Times headline about a second bank bailout. Bitcoin was designed as money that doesn't depend on banks or bailouts, though it brings risks of its own.

Sources

  1. Federal Reserve History, The Great Recession and its aftermath
  2. Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission, The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report (2011), via GovInfo
  3. UK House of Commons Treasury Committee, The run on the Rock (Fifth Report of Session 2007-08)
  4. Congressional Research Service, Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP): Implementation and status (R41427, 21 August 2014)
  5. mempool.space, Bitcoin genesis block coinbase transaction (block 0)

Read next.