"NFTs are just JPEGs": usually not even that, just a numbered receipt with a link
An NFT is a numbered token on a blockchain that records who holds it. The picture is usually stored somewhere else, reached through a link, and buying the token doesn't by itself give you the copyright.
Anna buys a painting from the village painter. The painting stays in the miller's barn, because Anna's house is small. In the notebook, the villagers write one line: "Painting number 7 belongs to Anna. It hangs in the miller's barn, third hook on the left."
Every house copies that line, and nobody can tear it out. But the notebook doesn't hold the painting. It holds a note about where the painting is. If the miller moves it, swaps it or lets the barn fall down, the line in the notebook still says number 7 is Anna's, third hook on the left.
That's an NFT. The myth says it's just a JPEG. Usually it's not even that. It's a numbered receipt with a link to a JPEG somewhere else.
What it is
NFT stands for non-fungible token: a token that is one of a kind, unlike a coin, where any one is as good as another. On Ethereum, most NFTs follow a standard called ERC-721, created in January 2018. It gives every token a number, its token ID, and records which address holds it (EIP-721).
The picture usually isn't in the token. The standard has an optional field called tokenURI, described as "A distinct Uniform Resource Identifier (URI) for a given asset", which "may point to a JSON file", a small text file of details called metadata. That file in turn usually points to the image.
How it works: follow the link
Take any NFT and follow the chain, link by link.
- On the blockchain: a contract address, a token ID and the current holder. This part is in every copy of the notebook.
- The tokenURI: a web address or another kind of link, stored in the contract.
- The metadata file: a name, a description and, usually, another link to the image.
- The image: a file on a server, or on a shared storage network such as IPFS.
Only step 1 is guaranteed by the blockchain. The rest depends on where the files live. A joint report by the US Patent and Trademark Office and the US Copyright Office, sent to Congress on 12 March 2024, found that "The vast majority of works associated with NFTs are stored off-chain" (USPTO and USCO, 2024). Some projects do put the image itself on the blockchain. They're the exception, and they pay for the space.
When the barn changes the painting
In January 2022, the programmer Moxie Marlinspike made an NFT to test this. He wrote that NFTs "contain a URL that points to the data", on a server where the image can be changed at any time. His NFT looked "one way on OpenSea, another way on Rarible", and in a crypto wallet showed a large poo emoji. The server simply sent different pictures to different visitors.
Then, he reports, "After a few days, without warning or explanation, the NFT I made was removed from OpenSea." Afterwards it "no longer appeared in any crypto wallet on my device", because the wallet got its NFT data from the same marketplace (Marlinspike, 2022).
A marketplace can't delete a token from the blockchain. It can only stop showing it, and so can every app that relies on that marketplace. What people saw was up to whoever ran the servers.
What you don't get
Buying an NFT doesn't, by itself, make you the owner of the artwork's copyright. The same government report says owning a token "does not necessarily mean the token transfers to the holder any intellectual property rights", and that "there is nothing inherent to a token that would automatically transfer the rights in an associated asset" (USPTO and USCO, 2024).
What you may do with the image depends on the licence the seller attaches, if any. The report found that the most common concern raised was "consumer confusion about the IP rights" that come with an NFT. Anna owns line 7. Whether she may print posters of the painting is a separate question, answered by the painter, not the notebook.
Where people get it wrong
- "I own the JPEG." You hold a token. The image is usually a file someone else hosts.
- "I own the copyright." Not unless the terms say so. A token transfers nothing automatically.
- "It's on the blockchain, so it's permanent." The token is. The link may break, and the picture at the end of it may change.
- "So NFTs are worthless." The record of who holds the token is real and hard to forge. The question is what it points to, and what rights come with it.
Follow the link before you pay
Before you buy any NFT, do three things. Open the token on a block explorer and find its tokenURI. Check where the metadata and image live: a company server, a shared storage network or the blockchain itself. Then find the licence: what you may do with the image, in writing.
If the link leads to a server run by the seller, you're buying a line in the notebook that points at his barn. Make sure you like his barn.
Frequently asked questions
What does an NFT actually contain?
An NFT on Ethereum usually records a token ID, the address that holds it and a link, the tokenURI. The link points to a metadata file, which usually points to the image. The image itself is mostly stored off the blockchain.
Can the image behind an NFT change or disappear?
Yes, if it's hosted on a server someone controls. In January 2022 Moxie Marlinspike showed an NFT whose image differed depending on who looked at it. If the server goes offline, the token stays on the blockchain but the link can lead nowhere.
Does buying an NFT give me the copyright?
Not automatically. A 2024 report by the US Patent and Trademark Office and the US Copyright Office says nothing inherent in a token transfers rights in the associated work. Your rights depend on the licence the seller attaches.
Where are NFT images stored?
Mostly off-chain, on ordinary web servers or on shared storage networks such as IPFS. A few projects store the image on the blockchain itself, which is more permanent and more expensive.
Is an NFT the same as a crypto coin?
No. Every coin of the same kind is interchangeable, like banknotes. Every NFT has its own token ID and is one of a kind, even if the picture it links to has been copied a million times.
Sources
- William Entriken, Dieter Shirley, Jacob Evans and Nastassia Sachs, ERC-721: Non-Fungible Token Standard (EIP-721, created 24 January 2018)
- US Patent and Trademark Office and US Copyright Office, Non-fungible tokens and intellectual property: a report to Congress (12 March 2024)
- US Copyright Office, Non-fungible token study
- Moxie Marlinspike, My first impressions of web3 (7 January 2022)

