NFT royalties explained: the contract names a price, the marketplace decides whether to pay it
An NFT royalty is a share of each resale meant for the creator. The token can announce the percentage through a standard called EIP-2981, but paying it is up to the marketplace, and from 2022 to 2023 the big marketplaces made it optional.
Imagine a claim company that writes a line into every deed it sells: "On each resale, five per cent to the founder." A fine idea. The founder keeps earning as the town grows.
Then the deeds start changing hands at a trading post down the street. The clerk there reads the line, shrugs, and asks the seller: "Do you want to pay that?"
That is the story of NFT royalties. The token can say what the creator should get. The marketplace that runs the sale decides whether anyone pays.
What it is
An NFT royalty, which marketplaces call a creator fee or creator earnings, is a percentage of each resale sent to the creator.
The Ethereum standard for it is EIP-2981, created on 15 September 2020. Its own summary says it lets NFT contracts "signal a royalty amount". A marketplace asks the contract royaltyInfo with the token ID and the sale price, and gets back an address and an amount. The standard says plainly why that is all it can do: "The royalty payment must be voluntary, as transfer mechanisms such as transferFrom() include NFT transfers between wallets" (EIP-2981).
A token can be moved without any sale at all, so the contract can't tell a gift from a trade. The marketplace can.
How it works
The arithmetic. Imagine an NFT whose contract signals a 5% royalty, sold for 2 ether on OpenSea. OpenSea's help page, read on 19 November 2026, lists a "1% fee for selling NFTs, which is included in the price displayed to buyers", and says each collection's creator earnings are either required or optional (OpenSea Help).
- The contract's
royaltyInforeturns 5% of 2 ether: 0.1 ether, and the creator's address. - OpenSea's 1% fee: 0.02 ether.
- If the seller pays the royalty: 2 minus 0.02 minus 0.1 leaves the seller 1.88 ether.
- If the royalty is optional and the seller skips it: 2 minus 0.02 leaves 1.98 ether. The creator gets nothing.
The 0.1 ether difference is the whole fight.
The history, in the marketplaces' own words:
- 14 October 2022: the Solana marketplace Magic Eden said "The decision on how much royalties to pay will be passed to the buyer", while "By default, ALL collections/listings will honor full royalties" (via The Block).
- November 2022: OpenSea released code that new collections could add to block sales on marketplaces that don't enforce creator fees, later called the Operator Filter (via The Block).
- 17 February 2023: competing with Blur, OpenSea cut its own fee to zero "for a limited time" and made creator fees optional, "starting at 0.5%", for collections without on-chain enforcement (via CoinDesk).
- 17 August 2023: OpenSea announced "We're sunsetting the OpenSea Operator Filter on August 31" and that "creator fees will be optional for all new collections beginning August 31". Collections that had used the filter kept enforced fees "through February 29, 2024" (OpenSea; date via The Block). The reason it gave: other marketplaces, Blur among them, did not adopt the filter.
- 2 April 2024: OpenSea said creators "can now use ERC721-C from Limit Break to set and enforce their own creator earnings on OpenSea", if their contract follows that standard or can be upgraded to it (OpenSea).
So by 19 November 2026 the town had two kinds of deed: older ones where the line is a polite request, and newer ones written with locks that only let approved trading posts handle the sale.
Why it matters
For creators, royalties were the promise that made NFTs different from selling a print once. For traders, every royalty is a cost on every flip. Marketplaces sit in the middle and compete for traders, and the cheapest place to sell usually wins.
That is a race to the bottom: one trading post drops the fee, and the others follow or lose business.
Where people get it wrong
- "Royalties are written into the blockchain, so they're automatic." EIP-2981 signals an amount. Payment is up to the marketplace.
- "The royalty is a legal right." It is a marketplace policy or a contract rule, not copyright.
- "Optional means zero." Optional means the seller chooses. Some pay in full.
- "Enforced royalties can't be avoided." They hold on marketplaces that respect the contract's rules. Contracts that restrict who can move tokens also restrict where you can sell.
Check the collection's earnings setting
Before buying an NFT for a creator's sake, look at the collection page on the marketplace: are creator earnings "required" or "optional", and at what percentage? If optional, decide whether you will pay them when you sell.
The founder wrote five per cent on the deed. The trading post reads it out loud, then hands you the pen.
Frequently asked questions
What are NFT royalties?
NFT royalties, also called creator fees or creator earnings, are a percentage of each resale meant for the original creator. The percentage is set by the creator. Whether it is actually paid depends on the marketplace's rules and the collection's contract.
What is EIP-2981?
EIP-2981 is the Ethereum standard, created in September 2020, that lets an NFT contract tell marketplaces how much royalty is owed on a sale and to whom. It only signals the amount. The standard itself says payment must be voluntary.
Did OpenSea stop paying royalties?
OpenSea made creator fees optional for new collections from 31 August 2023, and for collections that used its Operator Filter after 29 February 2024. From 2 April 2024 it let collections using the ERC721-C standard enforce their creator earnings on OpenSea.
Why can't royalties be enforced on-chain?
A token can move between wallets without a sale, so a standard contract can't tell a trade from a gift. Enforcement only works if the contract limits which marketplaces may move its tokens, as ERC721-C does.
Does the buyer or the seller pay the royalty?
In practice the royalty comes out of the sale price, so the seller receives less. On OpenSea, the marketplace fee and any creator earnings are included in the price the buyer sees.
Sources
- Ethereum Improvement Proposals, ERC-2981: NFT Royalty Standard (created 15 September 2020)
- The Block, Solana NFT platform Magic Eden opts for optional royalty payments (15 October 2022)
- The Block, OpenSea creates tool to help NFT collections enforce royalties on-chain (6 November 2022)
- CoinDesk, OpenSea goes zero-fee, creator royalties optional (17 February 2023)
- OpenSea, On creator fees (August 2023)
- The Block, OpenSea disables royalty enforcement tool, makes creator fees optional (17 August 2023)
- OpenSea, Creator earnings: ERC721-C compatibility on OpenSea (2 April 2024)
- OpenSea Help Center, What fees do I pay on OpenSea?, read on 19 November 2026

