Algorithmic stablecoins: a strongbox full of IOUs from yourself
An algorithmic stablecoin tries to stay at one dollar by letting holders swap it for a dollar's worth of a sister token that the system prints. That works while people want the sister token. When they don't, every exit prints more of it, its price falls, and the next exit needs even more.
Imagine an assay office that hands out dollar chits but has no gold dust in the strongbox. Instead, it promises: bring a chit to the counter and we'll give you a dollar's worth of shares in the assay office.
While the town believes in the assay office, the shares are worth plenty and the promise sounds fine. Then one morning a crowd turns up with chits. The office prints shares to pay them. The crowd sells the shares. The share price falls, so the next chit needs even more shares.
That's an algorithmic stablecoin, and that's how it breaks. The backing is a token the system prints itself, and in a run everybody is selling it at once.
What it is
An algorithmic stablecoin aims for one dollar without holding a dollar for each token. Instead, a rule lets holders swap the stablecoin for newly created units of a sister token, worth one dollar at the current price, and the other way round.
The best-known case was Terra's UST, with LUNA as the sister token. In the SEC's words, UST "supposedly maintained its peg to the U.S. dollar by being interchangeable for another of the defendants'" tokens, LUNA (SEC, 2023). The SEC called UST an "algorithmic stablecoin". Terra's own docs describe the plumbing: the offered coins are burned, the asked coins are minted, at "the proper exchange rate reported by the Oracle" (Terra docs).
How it works: the death spiral in toy numbers
The numbers below are invented for the arithmetic. They are not Terra's figures.
A system has 10 billion stablecoins. Its sister token, call it SIS, has 1 billion units at 10 dollars each. The rule: burn one stablecoin, receive one dollar of newly minted SIS.
When it works. The stablecoin trades at 0.98 dollars. A trader buys 1,000 of them for 980 dollars, swaps them for 1,000 dollars of SIS and sells it. Profit 20 dollars, fewer stablecoins in circulation, price back up. Same arbitrage as a fiat-backed coin, except the payout is printed, not taken from a strongbox.
When it breaks.
- Round 1. Holders swap 2 billion stablecoins. At 10 dollars, that takes 200 million new SIS. Supply rises to 1.2 billion. They sell the SIS, and suppose the price halves to 5 dollars.
- Round 2. Another 3 billion stablecoins come in. At 5 dollars, that's 600 million new SIS. Supply: 1.8 billion. Suppose the price falls to 2 dollars.
- Round 3. Another 3 billion. At 2 dollars, that's 1.5 billion new SIS. Supply: 3.3 billion, more than three times the start. Suppose the price falls to 50 cents.
- The scoreboard. 2 billion stablecoins are left. All the SIS together is worth 3.3 billion times 0.50, or 1.65 billion dollars. Less than the stablecoins it is meant to back.
The key line: the same one billion dollars of exits costs 100 million SIS at 10 dollars, 1 billion at 1 dollar and 10 billion at 10 cents. The falling price makes the printing faster, and the printing makes the price fall. That's the spiral.
In May 2022, the SEC says, "UST depegged from the U.S. dollar, and the price of it and its sister tokens plummeted to close to zero". The full story is in "Terra/Luna and FTX: the 2022 collapses".
A year earlier: IRON and TITAN
Iron Finance ran IRON, a stablecoin only partly backed by USDC, with its own token TITAN covering the rest. Its post-mortem, dated 17 June 2021, describes 16 June: "TITAN dropped from 65$ to 30$ in 2 hours, which later recovered in 1 hour to 52$" (Iron Finance). Then selling resumed, and "more TITAN was created (as a result of IRON redemptions) and the price kept going down". The team's own words: "This caused a negative feedback loop."
A detail from the same post: its price feed was a 10-minute average, so "TITAN spot price drops even further in comparison to the TWAP redemption price". The oracle lagged the crash. TITAN ended "close to 0".
Why it matters
The pitch is attractive: a dollar coin with no bank, no strongbox and money for the founders whenever demand grows. In good times the sister token rises, and early holders do well.
Who pays: the last people holding either token when confidence goes. There is nothing outside the system to sell, so the exit door is exactly as wide as the market's appetite for the sister token.
Where people get it wrong
- "The code guarantees one dollar." The code guarantees one dollar's worth of the sister token, at the oracle price. That can be nearly nothing.
- "Arbitrage always restores the peg." Only while the sister token has buyers. In a run, arbitrage adds to the selling.
- "Partly backed is safe enough." Iron Finance had USDC in its reserve and still collapsed.
- "High yield proves it works." Yield paid on a stablecoin has to come from somewhere. If nobody can say where, ask.
Ask what's in the strongbox
Before holding any stablecoin, ask one question: if everyone redeemed at once, what would they be paid with? If the answer is a token the same system can print, you have your answer.
A promise backed by more of your own promises is still one promise.
Frequently asked questions
What is an algorithmic stablecoin?
It is a stablecoin that tries to stay at one dollar using rules instead of a full reserve. Usually holders can swap one stablecoin for one dollar's worth of a sister token that the system creates. Terra's UST, swapped against LUNA, was the best-known example.
What is a death spiral?
When many holders exit at once, the system prints more of its sister token to pay them. They sell it, its price falls, and each further exit needs even more new tokens. The supply balloons and the price heads towards zero.
Why did UST collapse?
UST's peg depended on demand for LUNA, the token it could be swapped for. According to the SEC, UST depegged in May 2022, and UST and its sister tokens fell close to zero. The full story is in "Terra/Luna and FTX: the 2022 collapses".
What happened to Iron Finance?
On 16 June 2021, its token TITAN fell from 65 dollars to 30 dollars in two hours, recovered, then fell close to zero. IRON redemptions created more TITAN, which was sold, creating what the team called a negative feedback loop.
Are all algorithmic stablecoins doomed?
This site doesn't predict. What can be said: any design that pays exits in a token it prints itself depends on people wanting that token at the worst possible moment. Check what a stablecoin pays you with if everyone leaves together.

