Crypto-backed stablecoins: dollars borrowed against ether, with a margin that can tear
A crypto-backed stablecoin is created when someone locks up more crypto than the stablecoins they borrow, inside a smart contract. The extra is the safety margin. If the collateral falls too far, the contract sells it, and on Maker's Black Thursday in March 2020 that safety net tore.
Imagine a prospector who needs cash but won't sell his gold. He takes a sack of dust to a lender and gets paper money for part of it. The lender keeps the sack, and keeps it bigger than the loan, because gold prices move.
If the price of gold falls far enough, the lender doesn't wait for the prospector to come back. He sells the sack, pays himself and hands over whatever is left.
A crypto-backed stablecoin is that lender, written as a smart contract. Nobody holds dollars in a strongbox. The stablecoins exist because people borrowed them against more crypto than they are worth.
What it is
A crypto-backed stablecoin is created when a borrower locks crypto, usually ether, in a smart contract called a vault (Liquity calls it a Trove) and takes out newly minted stablecoins against it. The contract demands more collateral than the loan. That's overcollateralisation.
Four numbers run the system:
- Collateral ratio: the value of the locked crypto divided by the debt.
- Liquidation ratio: the lowest ratio allowed. In Maker's code it is stored as
mat, "the liquidation ratio for a given ilk", meaning a collateral type (Sky docs, Spot). - Stability fee: interest charged on the debt. Maker's Jug contract exists to "accumulate stability fees for a particular collateral type" (Sky docs, Jug).
- The price feed: an oracle tells the contract what the collateral is worth.
The best-known example is DAI from the Maker protocol, whose developer docs are published under the Sky name. A simpler one is LUSD from Liquity's first version.
How it works: one Liquity vault
Liquity's first version is a good worked example because its rules are fixed in code. From its docs: the minimum collateral ratio "is set to 110%", the borrowing fee range is "between 0.5% and 5%", a one-off fee with no interest, and ether is "the only collateral type accepted" (Liquity, Borrowing). A 200 LUSD liquidation reserve is set aside, and it "counts as debt and is taken into account for the calculation of a Trove's collateral ratio". The borrowing fee "is added to the debt".
Now a vault. The ether price here is an assumed round number for the arithmetic, not a market reading.
- Deposit 3 ETH at an assumed price of 2,000 dollars: 6,000 dollars of collateral.
- Borrow 3,000 LUSD. At the minimum fee of 0.5%, the fee is 15 LUSD.
- Debt: 3,000 plus 15 plus the 200 reserve is 3,215 LUSD.
- Collateral ratio: 6,000 divided by 3,215 is about 186.6%.
- The line: 110% of 3,215 is 3,536.50 dollars. Divided by 3 ETH, that's an ether price of about 1,178.83 dollars.
- The margin: a fall from 2,000 to 1,178.83 dollars is about 41.1%. Beyond that, the vault can be liquidated.
What keeps LUSD near one dollar? Anyone can redeem it "for ETH at face value (i.e. 1 LUSD for $1 of ETH)", against a fee that starts at 0.5% (Liquity, Redemptions). The docs say redemption and the 110% minimum ratio "create a price floor and price ceiling (respectively)". No company and no bank counter: the counter is the contract.
When the safety net tore: 12 March 2020
Maker's own write-up, dated 1 April 2020, describes the day (MakerDAO, archived copy):
- Over a 36-hour period on 12 to 13 March, the collapse "removed over 50% in value from ETH, BTC, and the crypto market in general".
- Ethereum clogged. Vault owners couldn't add collateral in time, and oracles "were affected by the same delays as everyone else".
- About 1,200 vaults were liquidated, and 4,447 auctions were triggered. Some were won by "zero bids", because the bidders who normally compete were stuck or out of DAI.
- The result was a shortfall of "approximately 5.4M+ Dai". By 29 March, Maker had created and sold 20,980 new MKR tokens for 5.3 million DAI to fill the hole.
And DAI went the other way: on Maker's figures it traded as high as 1.126447 dollars on 12 March, because everyone needed DAI to repay. Governance then added USDC as collateral. The crypto-only stablecoin took on a fiat-backed one to stay stable.
Why it matters
Crypto-backed stablecoins don't need a bank or a company's promise. The rules are public and anyone can check the collateral on the blockchain.
The price for that: capital sits idle, and the system leans on oracles, a working network and buyers for liquidated collateral, all on the worst day of the year. Borrowers pay fees and risk losing their collateral. Holders rely on liquidations working. How liquidations work in detail is its own article, "Collateral and liquidation explained".
Where people get it wrong
- "Overcollateralised means it can't fail." Black Thursday left a shortfall of about 5.4 million DAI.
- "No company, no risk." The risks move to code, oracles and network congestion.
- "The stability fee is a savings rate." It's interest the borrower pays.
- "It's pure crypto." DAI accepted USDC as collateral after March 2020.
Check the ratio, not the label
If you ever open a vault, look up the protocol's own minimum ratio and work out the price at which you get liquidated, before you borrow. Then ask whether you could add collateral during a day when the whole network is jammed.
A safety margin is a fine idea. On the day you need it, half the town needs it too.
Frequently asked questions
What is a crypto-backed stablecoin?
It is a stablecoin created when someone locks crypto in a smart contract and borrows newly minted stablecoins against it. The locked crypto must be worth more than the loan. DAI and Liquity's LUSD are examples.
Why do I need to lock up more than I borrow?
Crypto prices move fast, so the extra collateral is a buffer. In Liquity's first version, the minimum collateral ratio is 110%. If the collateral falls below that, the position can be liquidated.
What happened to MakerDAO on Black Thursday?
On 12 and 13 March 2020, crypto prices fell by over half and Ethereum was congested. About 1,200 vaults were liquidated, some auctions were won with zero bids, and Maker reported a shortfall of about 5.4 million DAI. It sold newly created MKR to cover it.
What is a stability fee?
It is the interest a borrower pays on stablecoins taken out of a Maker vault. It accrues over time on the debt. Liquity's first version charged a one-off borrowing fee instead.
Can crypto-backed stablecoins lose their peg?
Yes, in both directions. On 12 March 2020, DAI traded as high as 1.126447 dollars, according to Maker, because borrowers rushed to buy it to repay their loans. Collateral crashes can also leave the system short.

