Fiat-backed stablecoins: the peg is held by big traders chasing half a cent
A fiat-backed stablecoin stays near one dollar because large verified customers can mint new tokens for a dollar and redeem them for a dollar. When the market price drifts, they trade the gap away. Ordinary holders ride on that trade without being able to make it.
Imagine the assay office in a boomtown hands out chits: one dollar of gold dust each, redeem at the counter. Out in the street, prospectors trade the chits among themselves. Some days a chit goes for 99 cents, some days for a dollar and a half-cent.
Nobody at the assay office sets the street price. A few merchants with deep pockets do. When chits are cheap in the street, they buy a stack and cash it at the counter for full value. When chits are dear, they bring dust to the counter, take fresh chits and sell them in the street.
That's how a fiat-backed stablecoin holds its peg. Not by decree, but by arbitrage: big traders who can reach the counter, chasing gaps of half a cent.
What it is
A fiat-backed stablecoin is a token issued by a company that holds reserves in ordinary money and assets like short-term government debt. The company promises to issue a token for each dollar it receives, and to pay a dollar for each token it takes back.
There are two markets. The primary market is the counter: the issuer itself, open only to verified customers. The secondary market is the street: exchanges and trading apps, where everyone else buys and sells.
How it works: half a cent either side
Who may use the counter? For USDT, Tether's terms say: "In order to cause Tether Tokens to be issued or redeemed by Tether, you must be a verified customer of Tether" (Tether terms). For USDC, Circle says its Circle Match service is "available to approved Circle Mint customers and access is eligibility-gated" (Circle Match). These are examples, not recommendations: two issuers, same principle.
Now the fees. Tether's schedule, read on 19 November 2026: a minimum of 100,000 dollars to acquire or redeem, 0.1% to acquire, and "the greater of $1,000 or 0.1%" to redeem (Tether fees). Take a verified trader with 1,000,000 dollars, and ignore exchange fees and wire costs.
Case 1: USDT trades at 0.995 dollars.
- Buy 1,000,000 USDT on an exchange: 1,000,000 times 0.995 is 995,000 dollars.
- Redeem them with Tether. 0.1% of 1,000,000 is 1,000 dollars, the same as the minimum fee.
- Receive 999,000 dollars.
- Profit: 999,000 minus 995,000 is 4,000 dollars. Buying pushes the street price back up.
Case 2: USDT trades at 1.005 dollars.
- Wire 1,000,000 dollars to Tether. The 0.1% fee is 1,000 dollars.
- Receive 999,000 new USDT.
- Sell them at 1.005: 999,000 times 1.005 is 1,003,995 dollars.
- Profit: 3,995 dollars. Selling pushes the price back down.
Case 3: the small trader. Same gap, at Tether's minimum of 100,000 dollars. Buy 100,000 USDT at 0.995 for 99,500 dollars. The redemption fee is the greater of 1,000 dollars or 0.1% (100 dollars), so 1,000. You receive 99,000 dollars and lose 500.
At 100,000 dollars, the redemption fee is 1%, so the street price has to fall below 99 cents before redeeming pays. At a million or more, it's 0.1%, and anything below 99.9 cents pays. The peg is defended by those with the most money.
Why it matters
The street price is what you get. If you hold a few hundred dollars of a stablecoin, you can't redeem it. You sell it, at whatever the market pays.
That price stays close to one dollar only while three things hold: big traders are willing to arbitrage, the issuer keeps paying out at the counter, and the banks that move the dollars are open. On a weekend, wires don't move, so the counter is effectively shut. "Stablecoins are always stable" shows what that looked like for USDC in March 2023.
Who gains: the issuer, which collects the fees and the interest on its reserves, and the arbitrageurs, who collect the gaps. Who pays: whoever sells in a panic, below the counter price, to someone who can redeem.
Where people get it wrong
- "The issuer keeps the price at one dollar." It keeps a promise at the counter. Traders keep the street price near it.
- "Anyone can redeem." Only verified customers, above a minimum. The terms call the right "personal to you", meaning the customer, not every holder.
- "A price of 0.998 means trouble." Small gaps inside the fee band are normal. Nobody can profit from closing them, so nobody bothers.
- "Arbitrage is risk-free." Only if the counter pays. If traders doubt the redemption, they stop buying cheap tokens, and the gap grows instead of closing.
Check who stands at the counter
Before you rely on a stablecoin, open the issuer's own fee page and terms. Find the minimum, the redemption fee and the list of who qualifies. Then ask how often the street price has drifted outside that fee band, and for how long.
Behind every stable dollar is a trader who thinks the counter will pay. The day he stops thinking that, so does the dollar.
Frequently asked questions
How does a fiat-backed stablecoin keep its peg?
Verified customers can buy new tokens from the issuer for one dollar each and redeem them for one dollar each. When the market price drifts away from one dollar, they buy or sell to profit from the gap, which pushes the price back. Fees decide how wide the gap must be before this pays.
What is the difference between the primary and secondary market for stablecoins?
The primary market is the issuer itself, where tokens are created and redeemed for money. It is open only to verified customers above a minimum. The secondary market is every exchange and app where holders trade tokens with each other.
Why can't I redeem my USDT directly with Tether?
Tether's terms say you must be a verified customer to have tokens issued or redeemed. Its fee page, read on 19 November 2026, set a minimum of 100,000 dollars and a redemption fee of the greater of 1,000 dollars or 0.1%. Most holders sell on an exchange instead.
Is stablecoin arbitrage risk-free?
No. It depends on the issuer paying out, on banks moving money in time and on exchange liquidity. If traders doubt any of these, they stop closing the gap and the price can fall further.
Why does a stablecoin sometimes trade at 0.998 dollars?
Small gaps cost more to close than they earn, once redemption fees and transfer costs are counted. So prices can sit slightly off one dollar without anyone stepping in. Large gaps that last are the ones worth watching.

