Level 4 · Money and marketsThe gold rush#327

Market makers explained: the clerk who always buys and always sells, a little apart

A market maker quotes a price to buy and a slightly higher price to sell, all day, so others can always trade. It earns the gap, the spread, and often a rebate from the exchange. In crypto, the name has also been used as a cover for faking trading volume.

Picture a clerk at the trading post who never goes home. Whenever a prospector wants to sell dust, he buys. Whenever someone wants to buy, he sells. He chalks two prices on his board, one a little lower than the other.

Nobody has to wait for a buyer to wander in. That's useful, and the clerk charges for it: he buys at the lower price and sells at the higher one, all day long.

That's a market maker. The honest ones keep the trading post open. The dishonest ones, as the sheriff found out in 2024, were paid to fill the board with trades that never really happened.

What it is

A market maker is a trader, usually a firm running software, that keeps a buy order (the bid) and a sell order (the ask) on an exchange's order book at the same time. It earns the spread, the gap between the two, as other traders take its prices.

It isn't betting on the price going up or down. It wants to buy and sell roughly equal amounts and end the day holding little. "Order books explained" and "The spread" cover the basics; this article is about the person on the other side.

How it works

A worked example with assumed numbers. The mid price is the house figure, $63,154.72 per bitcoin at 18 November 2026 prices (CoinGecko).

  1. The quotes. The market maker bids $63,148.40 and asks $63,161.04. The spread is $12.64, about 0.02% of the price.
  2. A round trip. A seller hits the bid: the market maker buys one bitcoin at $63,148.40. Minutes later a buyer takes the ask: it sells one bitcoin at $63,161.04. Earned: $12.64.
  3. The rebate. Exchanges pay for this service. Read on 19 November 2026, Kraken's liquidity programme advertises "Maker rebates up to 0.020% across spot, futures and xStocks" (Kraken). Coinbase offers clients "who provide large amounts of liquidity" "lower, more competitive fees" (Coinbase). These are examples, not recommendations. At a 0.020% rebate, each side of the round trip above earns about $12.63, so the two rebates together are worth about twice the spread.
  4. The risk. Say the market maker buys one bitcoin and, before it can sell, the price drops 1%. That costs $631.55, the spread from about 50 round trips. Market makers survive by keeping their holdings small and pulling quotes when prices move fast.

That last step is why spreads widen in a sell-off. The clerk doesn't vanish, but he chalks his prices further apart, or takes the board down for a while.

Why it matters

  • They're why you can trade at all. On a quiet coin, without a market maker, you could wait hours for someone to take the other side.
  • Coin projects hire them. A token project can pay a firm to quote its token on exchanges. Quoting is legal. What the firm is paid to do is the question.
  • Sometimes the service was fake. On 9 October 2024, the SEC charged "three so-called market makers", ZM Quant, Gotbit and CLS Global, saying token promoters "hired so-called market makers ZM Quant and Gotbit to provide market-manipulation-as-a-service" (SEC). The US Attorney in Boston charged four firms that day, adding MyTrade MM. The FBI had created its own token, NexFundAI, to catch them (US Attorney's Office, District of Massachusetts). "Wash trading and fake volume" covers what they did.
  • Or it hid a problem. In December 2024, a subsidiary of Jump Trading, Tai Mo Shan, agreed to pay about $123 million. The SEC found that when TerraUSD lost its dollar peg in May 2021, the firm's own buying, which Terraform had given it an incentive for, helped restore the price, and that this "deceived the market into believing that Terraform's algorithmic mechanism was working". Tai Mo Shan neither admitted nor denied the findings (SEC).

Where people get it wrong

  • "Market makers set the price." They set their quotes. If they quote badly, others trade against them and they lose.
  • "They must be on the other side of my trade, so they want me to lose." They want you to trade, both ways, at their spread. Your direction is not their bet.
  • "A token with a market maker is a safe token." A market maker can make any coin easy to trade. It can't make it worth anything.
  • "Lots of trading means lots of interest." Some "market makers" were paid to trade with themselves.

Check who keeps the board busy

On a small token, look at the order book. If the bids and asks sit at exactly the same distance from the price, in tidy round sizes, a market-making bot is probably keeping the board busy. That's normal. Then ask who paid it, and what for.

The clerk earns a little on every sale. The clerks the sheriff charged in 2024 earned a lot on sales that never happened.

Frequently asked questions

What does a market maker do in crypto?

A market maker keeps buy and sell orders on an exchange's order book at the same time, so others can trade instantly. It earns the spread between its buy and sell prices, and often a rebate or lower fees from the exchange.

How do market makers make money?

Mainly from the spread: buying slightly below the market price and selling slightly above it, many times a day. Exchanges such as Kraken also pay maker rebates to large liquidity providers.

Are crypto market makers regulated?

It depends on the country and the asset. In October 2024, US authorities charged several crypto firms calling themselves market makers with wash trading and manipulation, in a case built partly on a token the FBI created.

Why do spreads widen when the market crashes?

Market makers hold small amounts of the coin and lose money when the price moves sharply against them. To protect themselves, they quote their buy and sell prices further apart, or stop quoting for a while.

Is a market maker the same as an automated market maker?

No. A market maker is a trader quoting prices on an order book. An automated market maker is a smart contract that prices swaps with a formula from a pool of two tokens.

Sources

  1. Kraken, Liquidity provider program (read on 19 November 2026)
  2. Coinbase, Exchange liquidity program overview (read on 19 November 2026)
  3. US SEC, SEC charges three so-called market makers and nine individuals in crackdown on manipulation of crypto assets offered and sold as securities (press release 2024-166, 9 October 2024)
  4. US Attorney's Office, District of Massachusetts, Eighteen individuals and entities charged in international operation targeting widespread fraud and manipulation in the cryptocurrency markets (9 October 2024)
  5. US SEC, Tai Mo Shan to pay $123 million for negligently misleading investors about stability of Terra USD (press release 2024-212, 20 December 2024)

Read next.