Level 1 · Start hereThe village#072

"Crypto is a Ponzi scheme": some schemes were, the notebook isn't

Plenty of crypto schemes have been Ponzi schemes, and regulators have proved it in court. Bitcoin itself isn't one by the regulators' own definition: nobody promises you a return or pays it out of newer buyers' money. Its price still depends on the next buyer, and that part of the critique is fair.

A stranger arrives at the village gate with a fine coat and a better offer. "Lend me ten coins," he tells Grandma Rosa, "and every Sunday I'll pay you one back. Forever." For a few weeks, the Sunday coin arrives. Rosa tells her friends.

Her friends lend him coins too. Their coins are what pays Rosa on Sunday. When new lenders stop coming, the Sundays stop, and so does the stranger.

That's a Ponzi scheme, and crypto has had plenty of them. But the notebook in every house, the shared record that keeps track of who owns which coins, isn't one. Nobody in the village pays you anything for holding a line in it.

What a Ponzi scheme is

The US Securities and Exchange Commission defines it in one line: "A Ponzi scheme is an investment fraud that pays existing investors with funds collected from new investors" (SEC, Investor.gov).

The organisers "often promise to invest your money and generate high returns with little or no risk", the SEC says. In many cases they don't invest it at all. They use it to pay earlier investors and keep some for themselves.

Three parts, then: a promoter, a promised return, and old investors paid with new investors' money. Remove any one and it's something else. Possibly still a bad idea, but not a Ponzi.

How it works: the first bitcoin Ponzi

The first US criminal securities fraud case involving bitcoin is the textbook. Here it is in steps, from the SEC and the Justice Department.

  1. The offer. From about September 2011, Trendon Shavers, writing as "pirateat40" on an online bitcoin forum, ran Bitcoin Savings and Trust. He offered "up to seven percent interest weekly". Prosecutors put that at 3,641% a year (US Attorney SDNY, 2016).
  2. The story. He claimed the returns came from bitcoin trading. The SEC said the business "was not in the business of buying and selling Bitcoin at all" (SEC, 2013).
  3. The engine. He paid the weekly interest and withdrawals with bitcoin from newer investors. Classic Ponzi.
  4. The size. Prosecutors said he fraudulently obtained about 146,000 bitcoin, then worth about $807,380.
  5. The end. The scheme collapsed in 2012. At least 48 of about 100 investors lost all or part of their money. On 21 July 2016 he was sentenced to 18 months in prison.

Notice who the fraud was. Not the bitcoin. Shavers. The coins moved exactly as the notebook said. It was the promise of a Sunday payment that was fake.

It didn't stop there. In August 2024 the SEC sued NovaTech, alleging it raised more than $650 million in crypto from more than 200,000 investors between 2019 and 2023. The SEC alleges that NovaTech "used the majority of investor funds to make payments to existing investors" (SEC, 2024). Add OneCoin, from our article on what gives a coin its value, and BitConnect, from altcoins explained, and you have a long row of strangers at the gate.

Where Bitcoin is different

Hold Bitcoin up against the SEC's three parts.

  • No promoter. Nobody runs Bitcoin as a business. The rules are in software that thousands of houses check. Satoshi Nakamoto's last forum post was on 12 December 2010 (see our article on who Satoshi is), and the notebook kept going.
  • No promised return. Holding bitcoin pays you nothing. No interest, no Sunday coin. If its price rises, that's because someone chose to pay more for it, not because someone owes it to you.
  • No pool of money being paid out. When you buy bitcoin, your euros go to the seller, not into a central fund. Nobody holds the village's money to pay the early lenders.

A Ponzi collapses when withdrawals exceed new deposits, because the money is gone. Bitcoin can't run out of money to pay you, because it never promised to pay you. That's not a compliment. It just means a different risk.

Where the critique has a point

The myth is wrong in its label and right in its worry.

Bitcoin's price rests on what the next buyer will pay. Two senior ECB staff, Ulrich Bindseil and Jürgen Schaaf, wrote in November 2022 that "Speculative bubbles rely on new money flowing in" and that Bitcoin "has also repeatedly benefited from waves of new investors" (ECB Blog, 2022). The ECB notes those were their views, not necessarily the bank's.

That's a description of a speculative asset, not of fraud. But for someone who buys at the top, the result can feel the same: the money came from them, and it went to whoever sold.

And many crypto products layered on top do have a promoter and a promised return. A platform paying "8% a year on your coins" has to get that 8% from somewhere. That's exactly where the Ponzi lives.

Where people get it wrong

  • "Bitcoin is a Ponzi." By the SEC's definition, no: there's no promoter paying returns from new money. It's a speculative asset that can fall hard.
  • "It's on a blockchain, so it can't be a Ponzi." Shavers took deposits in bitcoin. The blockchain recorded every one perfectly. The fraud was in the promise.
  • "Early buyers getting rich proves it's a Ponzi." Early buyers of anything gain if prices rise. A Ponzi needs someone paying them with your money.
  • "Only tiny scams do this." NovaTech is alleged to have taken over $650 million from 200,000 people.

Find the man who pays you

Before you put money into anything with crypto in its name, ask one question: who pays me, and with what? If the answer is "nobody, I can only sell it to someone else", you're speculating. Know that, and size it so you can lose it.

If the answer is a person or a company promising a fixed return, check the SEC's red flags: high returns with little or no risk, overly steady returns, and trouble getting paid. Then ask where the Sunday coin comes from. If he can't show you, it comes from Rosa's friends.

Frequently asked questions

Is Bitcoin a Ponzi scheme?

Not by the SEC's definition. A Ponzi scheme pays existing investors with money from new investors, run by a promoter who promises returns. Bitcoin has no promoter and pays holders nothing; its price simply depends on what buyers will pay, which makes it speculative and risky.

What is a Ponzi scheme?

The SEC defines it as an investment fraud that pays existing investors with funds collected from new investors. Organisers often promise high returns with little or no risk, and in many cases never invest the money at all.

What was the first bitcoin Ponzi scheme prosecuted in the US?

Bitcoin Savings and Trust, run by Trendon Shavers from 2011 to 2012. He offered up to 7% interest a week and paid it with newer investors' bitcoin. He was sentenced to 18 months in prison on 21 July 2016 in the first federal securities fraud case involving bitcoin.

How can I spot a crypto Ponzi scheme?

The SEC lists red flags including high returns with little or no risk, overly consistent returns, unregistered investments, unlicensed sellers, complex secretive strategies and difficulty withdrawing money. A fixed return promised on crypto deposits deserves the hardest look.

Why do critics still call crypto a Ponzi?

Because a coin that pays nothing can only rise in price if new buyers pay more. ECB staff wrote in 2022 that speculative bubbles rely on new money flowing in. That makes bitcoin speculative, but not a Ponzi scheme in the legal sense.

Sources

  1. SEC, Investor.gov, Ponzi scheme
  2. US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, Texas man sentenced for operating Bitcoin Ponzi scheme (21 July 2016)
  3. SEC, SEC charges Texas man with running Bitcoin-denominated Ponzi scheme (23 July 2013)
  4. SEC, Litigation Release No. 26072, SEC v. NovaTech Ltd., et al. (12 August 2024)
  5. ECB Blog, Ulrich Bindseil and Jürgen Schaaf, Bitcoin's last stand (30 November 2022)

Read next.