"Crypto is anonymous": your name is missing, your diary isn't
Bitcoin and most other blockchains are pseudonymous, not anonymous. Your name isn't in the ledger, but every payment is, forever. Link one address to you and the rest of the trail can follow, as the thieves behind the 2016 Bitfinex hack found out.
In the village notebook, nobody writes their name. Each line just says "house with the green door paid house with the red roof, three coins". Ben loves this. "Nobody knows it's me," he says, and pays the stranger at the gate from the green door.
Then Ben buys bread from Anna, from the same green door. Anna knows exactly who lives there. Now every line the green door ever wrote belongs to Ben, in every copy, in every house.
That's the myth in one scene. Crypto isn't anonymous. It's pseudonymous: written under a label instead of a name. Labels come off.
What it is
Anonymous means nobody can tell who did something. Pseudonymous means it's done under a stand-in name that can, with work, be tied to you.
Bitcoin's white paper says it plainly. Privacy comes from "keeping public keys anonymous", and "The public can see that someone is sending an amount to someone else" (Nakamoto, 2008). The paper even warns: "Some linking is still unavoidable with multi-input transactions." So the record was public by design from the first page.
How it works: the Bitfinex trail
The best way to see what pseudonymous means is to follow someone who tried hard to stay hidden. This is the US Justice Department's account (DOJ, 2022).
- 2016. A hacker breaks into Bitfinex, a crypto exchange, and makes more than 2,000 unauthorised transactions. 119,754 bitcoin go to a single wallet.
- The disguise. Over five years, about 25,000 of those bitcoin are moved out through a "complicated money laundering process". Prosecutors listed fake identities for online accounts, programs that automated thousands of transactions, deposits and withdrawals through darknet markets and exchanges, and "chain hopping": swapping bitcoin into other coins, including privacy coins.
- The slip. Some of the funds ended up in financial accounts controlled by Ilya Lichtenstein and Heather Morgan. Exchanges and banks know who their customers are. That's where the labels came off.
- The keys. With search warrants, agents got into an online account of Lichtenstein's. It held a file with the private keys to the wallet that had received the stolen bitcoin. More than 94,000 bitcoin were still in it.
- 8 February 2022. Both were arrested. The seized bitcoin was worth more than $3.6 billion at the time. Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said "cryptocurrency is not a safe haven for criminals."
- 14 November 2024. Lichtenstein, who according to court documents had carried out the hack himself, was sentenced to five years in prison (DOJ, 2024).
Five years of effort, and the notebook never forgot a line. It only had to wait for one line to meet a real name.
Other trails like it are in our articles on Silk Road and on whether crypto is only for criminals.
Where the labels come off
For ordinary users, the label usually comes off in one of three places.
- Exchanges. To buy crypto with euros at a regulated exchange, you show your passport. That's KYC, know your customer. From then on, the exchange knows which addresses it sent coins to.
- Payments to people who know you. Pay a shop, a friend or an online store that has your delivery address, and your address meets your name.
- Patterns. Analytics firms group addresses that are used together and follow coins between them. The white paper itself admits that inputs spent together reveal they had the same owner.
What about privacy coins?
Some coins are built to hide more. The Monero project says "The sender, receiver, and amount of every single transaction are hidden", using stealth addresses, ring signatures and RingCT (Monero). Other designs offer privacy as an option, not by default.
They are harder to trace on the ledger. But to turn them into euros you usually go through an exchange, and the Bitfinex launderers used them too. This site explains these tools; it doesn't teach anyone to hide.
Why it matters
Privacy cuts both ways, and the myth hurts honest people more than criminals.
If you think you're anonymous, you may post an address publicly, reuse it for years and let anyone who learns it see your balance and every payment. Privacy can matter to ordinary people too: researchers surveying El Salvador's bitcoin experiment found "privacy concerns are key barriers to adoption" (Alvarez, Argente and Van Patten, 2022).
Where people get it wrong
- "No name, so no trace." The trace is the whole ledger. The name is just the missing last link.
- "Mixing and hopping between coins makes it untraceable." The Bitfinex launderers did both, and investigators still followed the money.
- "Old transactions are forgotten." Nothing on a public blockchain is forgotten. The 2016 theft was solved in 2022.
- "Only criminals need privacy." Anyone who doesn't want their salary, savings or donations public has a reason to think about it.
Read your own diary
Take one address you have used and paste it into a public block explorer. Look at every payment in and out, the dates, the amounts and the balance. Then ask: who else knows this address is mine? The exchange, the friend who paid you, the shop?
Use a new address for every payment, which most wallets do on their own. And next time Ben says nobody knows it's him, tell him to buy his bread somewhere else.
Frequently asked questions
Is Bitcoin anonymous?
No. Bitcoin is pseudonymous: addresses don't carry names, but every transaction is public and permanent. Once an address is linked to a person, for example through an exchange that checked their ID, their payments can be traced through the ledger.
What is the difference between anonymous and pseudonymous?
Anonymous means nobody can tell who acted. Pseudonymous means acting under a stand-in name, such as a crypto address, that can be linked to the real person with enough information.
How did the US recover the Bitfinex bitcoin?
Investigators traced the stolen bitcoin through thousands of transactions to accounts in the suspects' own names, then found the private keys to the main wallet in an online account. More than 94,000 bitcoin, worth over $3.6 billion at the time, were seized in early 2022.
Are privacy coins like Monero anonymous?
Monero says it hides the sender, receiver and amount of every transaction by default, making on-chain tracing much harder. Users can still be identified where they buy or sell through exchanges that check identities, and in the Bitfinex case launderers who used privacy coins were caught anyway.
How can I keep my crypto payments more private legally?
Use a new address for each payment, which most wallets do by default, and avoid posting your addresses publicly. Remember that any exchange where you passed identity checks knows which addresses it sent your coins to.
Sources
- US Department of Justice, Two arrested for alleged conspiracy to launder $4.5 billion in stolen cryptocurrency (8 February 2022)
- US Department of Justice, Bitfinex hacker sentenced in money laundering conspiracy involving billions in stolen cryptocurrency (14 November 2024)
- Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A peer-to-peer electronic cash system (2008)
- Monero project, What is Monero?
- Fernando Alvarez, David Argente and Diana Van Patten, Are cryptocurrencies currencies? Bitcoin as legal tender in El Salvador (NBER Working Paper 29968, April 2022)

