Level 2 · First stepsThe village#166

"Guaranteed yield" and Ponzi schemes: the guarantee is paid by the next person through the door

Nobody can guarantee a high, fixed return on crypto. When a scheme does, and there is no real business behind it, the payouts come from newer investors' money. The arithmetic makes collapse certain; only the date is open. Ask where the yield comes from, and check the seller with your regulator.

The stranger has hired the village hall. There's music, a polished cart outside, and a board by the door: "Your coins, doubled in six months. Guaranteed."

Inside, a neighbour stands up and tells everyone he joined in spring and has already been paid. He means it. He has been paid. What nobody in the hall knows is whose coins paid him.

They were the coins of the people who joined in summer. That's the whole trick behind "guaranteed yield": no business, just a queue. Our myth article, "Crypto is a Ponzi scheme", explains why the notebook itself isn't one. This one is about the stranger in the hall.

What it is

A guaranteed-yield scheme promises a fixed, high return on your crypto: a percentage a day, a week or a month, "risk-free". When there is no real business behind the promise, it's a Ponzi scheme. The EU's three financial supervisors put it plainly: "there is no genuine business or profit being generated", and "the money comes solely from the contribution of newer investors" (EBA, EIOPA and ESMA).

Most of these schemes add a second engine: you earn extra for recruiting others. The supervisors call it a multi-level marketing structure, where "victims unknowingly become promoters".

How it works: the arithmetic of a guarantee

Take the promise from the board in the hall. It's a real one: IcomTech's promoters offered "guaranteed daily returns" and investors "doubling their money within six months", from crypto trading and mining that the Justice Department says never happened (US Attorney, SDNY, 4 October 2024).

Now do the sums, in a simplified version where everyone puts in €1,000.

  1. Month 0. Your €1,000 goes in. The scheme owes you €2,000 in six months.
  2. Month 6. With no business, your €2,000 must come from two newcomers. Each of them is now owed €2,000.
  3. Month 12. Paying those two takes four more. Then eight, then sixteen.
  4. Year 5. After ten doublings, keeping the promise to you alone takes 1,024 new investors.

Every guarantee doubles the queue. No village, and no country, has enough newcomers. Collapse isn't a risk in this design. It's the end of the calculation.

Here's how it played out at IcomTech. The scheme started around 2018. By August 2018 investors were complaining that they couldn't withdraw. They got "excuses, delays, and hidden fees", and by the end of 2019 it had collapsed. Most victims "ultimately lost their entire investments". Its founder, David Carmona, was sentenced to 121 months in prison in October 2024.

Change the numbers and the story stays. HyperFund allegedly promised "0.5% to 1% daily in passive rewards" from mining operations it "did not have", and began blocking withdrawals from at least July 2021. The Justice Department charged its alleged co-founder in January 2024 with a scheme that cost investors about $1.89 billion; one promoter pleaded guilty (DOJ, 29 January 2024).

Why it matters

The founders and the top recruiters gain. The last people in pay, and they are often the friends and relatives of the people who joined first.

The sums are large. Mirror Trading International took at least 29,421 bitcoin, valued at over $1.7 billion, from about 23,000 people in the US alone between May 2018 and March 2021, claiming a trading "bot" that didn't exist. The CFTC called it "the largest fraudulent scheme involving Bitcoin charged in any CFTC case" (CFTC, 30 June 2022). In September 2023 a court ordered the company to pay over $1.7 billion in restitution, and the CFTC warned that such orders "may not result in the recovery of any money lost" (CFTC, 7 September 2023).

Fake crypto investments of all kinds, not only Ponzis, cost Americans $7.2 billion in reported losses in 2025, according to the FBI (FBI IC3, 2025 report).

Where people get it wrong

  • "It paid me, so it's real." Early payouts are the advertising. The supervisors note that early investors "appear to receive payouts, encouraging more people to join".
  • "They have a trading bot, or a mining farm." MTI's bot was fake. IcomTech did no mining. A story about the source isn't the source.
  • "I'll get out before it ends." The exit is the first thing that closes: delays, fees, frozen withdrawals.
  • "Staking pays a yield too." Real yields vary, come from something you can name, and can fall to zero. A fixed, high figure that never moves is the warning sign.
  • "The court will get it back." Sometimes, partly, years later. The CFTC says a restitution order is no promise of recovery.

Ask where the yield comes from

Before anyone gets your coins, ask two questions. Where exactly does the return come from, in a way I could check? And who pays me if nobody else joins? If the answer to the first is a secret strategy and the answer to the second is silence, you have your answer.

Then check the seller's exact company name with your national financial regulator, its register and its warning list. A firm offering returns on your crypto without a licence is already telling you how it plans to treat the rules.

A guarantee means someone else pays. In a Ponzi, someone else is the next villager through the door.

Frequently asked questions

Is guaranteed crypto yield a scam?

A guarantee of a high, fixed return on crypto is one of the clearest warning signs of fraud. Real returns, such as staking rewards, vary and can fall. When the promised yield has no business behind it, the payouts come from newer investors' money, which is the definition of a Ponzi scheme.

How can I tell if a crypto platform is a Ponzi scheme?

Look for fixed daily or monthly returns, vague talk of bots or mining, bonuses for recruiting others, and trouble or fees when you withdraw. Ask where the money comes from and check the company with your national financial regulator. EU supervisors warn that in a Ponzi "there is no genuine business or profit being generated".

Why do Ponzi schemes always collapse?

Because the promised payouts grow faster than new money can come in. A scheme that doubles investors' money every six months with no real business needs twice as many newcomers each round. When recruitment slows, withdrawals stop and most investors lose most or all of their money.

Can I get my money back from a crypto Ponzi scheme?

Sometimes partly, often not. Courts can order restitution, as a US court did against Mirror Trading International for over $1.7 billion, but the CFTC warns that such orders may not result in recovery. Report the scheme to the police and your regulator, and ignore anyone who offers to recover it for a fee.

What is the difference between a Ponzi scheme and multi-level marketing?

A Ponzi scheme pays earlier investors with newer investors' money. Multi-level marketing pays people for recruiting others. Many crypto frauds combine both, so that victims recruit friends and family and, in the EU supervisors' words, "unknowingly become promoters".

Sources

  1. US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, Founder of cryptocurrency Ponzi scheme IcomTech sentenced to 121 months in prison (4 October 2024)
  2. CFTC, Release 8549-22, CFTC charges South African pool operator and CEO with $1.7 billion fraud involving bitcoin (30 June 2022)
  3. CFTC, Release 8772-23, Federal court orders South African company to pay over $1.7 billion in restitution for forex fraud (7 September 2023)
  4. US Department of Justice, Three individuals charged for roles in $1.89B cryptocurrency fraud scheme (29 January 2024)
  5. EBA, EIOPA and ESMA, Crypto frauds and scams: stay alert and protect yourself (factsheet, 15 December 2025)
  6. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report

Read next.